docellis wrote:There is stupidity and savagery. Vick was more of a savage than anyone in professional sports that I know of off the top of my head. Tons of athletes are stupid.
It's easy to call Vick a savage because he killed dogs, an animal we have deemed worthy of our affections. If you eat meat produced in a factory farm where the animals are so fat they can't stand and live in their own feces does that make you a savage? These people protest a guy who killed some dogs in a brutal way and then go eat a burger made from a cow that spent the last few months of its life standing in feces up to its own torso.
Missing the point entirely.
I've seen charities whose mission is to go to India and feed starving dogs. Seriously. They walk right past the starving children to feed the poor dogs. It's ludicrous.
I think it's very cruel, but I do think people can be taught to realize that and do better. I'm willing to accept his explanation and see how he does from here. Outside certain high risk or high security jobs, I don't think lying to a judge ought to keep you out of your chosen profession forever. He was given a sentence and he served it. That's good enough for me.
And I'm with GK as far as the other stuff. Nobody's protesting Brett Myers and they probably won't protest Donte Stallworth next year.
cardsfansince82 wrote:I'm guessing no one here grew up in a culture where dogfighting was not only acceptable but encouraged. For him to do that for gambling purposes when he had millions already is more stupid than anything else. He spent two years of his prime in prison and lost everything he had. I'd say he realizes more than anyone just how stupid his choices were.
You could say the same thing about slavery
Comparing dog fighting to animals used for food makes no sense to me.
ghostrunner wrote:I think it's very cruel, but I do think people can be taught to realize that and do better. I'm willing to accept his explanation and see how he does from here. Outside certain high risk or high security jobs, I don't think lying to a judge ought to keep you out of your chosen profession forever. He was given a sentence and he served it. That's good enough for me.
And I'm with GK as far as the other stuff. Nobody's protesting Brett Myers and they probably won't protest Donte Stallworth next year.
Did Stallworh get drunk and run over the pedestrian on purpose, to make money?
docellis wrote:There is stupidity and savagery. Vick was more of a savage than anyone in professional sports that I know of off the top of my head. Tons of athletes are stupid.
It's easy to call Vick a savage because he killed dogs, an animal we have deemed worthy of our affections. If you eat meat produced in a factory farm where the animals are so fat they can't stand and live in their own feces does that make you a savage? These people protest a guy who killed some dogs in a brutal way and then go eat a burger made from a cow that spent the last few months of its life standing in feces up to its own torso.
Missing the point entirely.
I've seen charities whose mission is to go to India and feed starving dogs. Seriously. They walk right past the starving children to feed the poor dogs. It's ludicrous.
In this country a dog is a household pet. We can't really compare this to other countries treatment of dogs. That said, if someone hung or electrocuted a chicken or a rat, I'd say that is pretty savage.
I doubt anyone would protest that, but the manner in which you take a life.....says a lot about you.
cardsfansince82 wrote:I'm guessing no one here grew up in a culture where dogfighting was not only acceptable but encouraged. For him to do that for gambling purposes when he had millions already is more stupid than anything else. He spent two years of his prime in prison and lost everything he had. I'd say he realizes more than anyone just how stupid his choices were.
You could say the same thing about slavery
Comparing dog fighting to animals used for food makes no sense to me.
Comparing it to slavery is silly. But in either instance it's not fair to completely vilify someone who wasn't raised to know better.
What should anger people is the fact that Stallworth got off with a slap on the wrist because he is rich. The niece of a co-worker of mine got drunk and killed a guy in Nogales with her car, and she is most likely going to spend the next ten years in prison because the man was Hispanic, and the DA wants to win the next election and the Hispanic vote is huge in Nogales Az. His family protests outside the cout house during every hearing.
ghostrunner wrote:I think it's very cruel, but I do think people can be taught to realize that and do better. I'm willing to accept his explanation and see how he does from here. Outside certain high risk or high security jobs, I don't think lying to a judge ought to keep you out of your chosen profession forever. He was given a sentence and he served it. That's good enough for me.
And I'm with GK as far as the other stuff. Nobody's protesting Brett Myers and they probably won't protest Donte Stallworth next year.
Did Stallworh get drunk and run over the pedestrian on purpose, to make money?
I don't know, that's probably a bad example. But I don't care. To me, after the time served and time lost, it's not a big deal. I don't know why you'd protest the guy without giving him a chance.