G. Keenan wrote:In that case most of us are savage people as millions of animals live in horrendous conditions and die terrible deaths so we can eat them. Just because we didn't kill them with our own hands doesn't mean we aren't responsible.
A person who drinks, drives, and kills somebody is behaving with complete disregard for human life. The "accident" doesn't diminish what a selfish moron they are. That is more objectionable to me than drowning a dog.
Motivation does count legally and morally. Vehicular homicide is not considered as serious a crime as first degree murder, and rightly so. That doesn't change the fact that drunk drivers are selfish morons who have risked the lives of others for their convenience.
The same applies to killing animals for food. Yes, many of the conditions are unnecessarily cruel, but this is not the motivation.
What's legal and what's moral don't overlap perfectly. I think vehicular homicide is just as immoral as first degree murder but for practical purposes it can't be punished as harshly legally.
The animal situation is different. It's like saying the ends justify the means. Well they don't. Inflicting unintended suffering, when it is in our power to avoid doing so, to satisfy our own wants is immoral.
<em>docellis</em> wrote:I disagree.
Taking a life, with your hands, on purpose will always be worse than accidentally taking a life no matter how bad your choices were that lead to it.
docellis wrote:I am going to say this again. The manner in which one takes a life matters as much or more than the life. If you electrocute a person, a dog, a rat...you are far more savage than a person who drives a car into a person, dog, rat accidentally.
In that case most of us are savage people as millions of animals live in horrendous conditions and die terrible deaths so we can eat them. Just because we didn't kill them with our own hands doesn't mean we aren't responsible.
A person who drinks, drives, and kills somebody is behaving with complete disregard for human life. The "accident" doesn't diminish what a selfish moron they are. That is more objectionable to me than drowning a dog.
You think driving under the influence and accidentally killing someone is worse that drowning or electrocuting a dog?
Absolutely.
If I had two people in front of me; one who killed someone while driving drunk and one who purposely drowned or electrocuted an animal and I had to pick which one should go to jail, I'd pick the drunk driver every single time.
PujolJunkie wrote:
If I had two people in front of me; one who killed someone while driving drunk and one who purposely drowned or electrocuted an animal and I had to pick which one should go to jail, I'd pick the drunk driver every single time.
Wow.
Is this really so shocking? A drunk driver kills a persons mother, daughter, father, son, cousin, best friend. A person kills a dog that was most likely rabid, had the taste for blood and knew nothing but fighting. If the dog was just let go to the street, it would have killed someone. So then what? Put the dog in jail? House arrest? Yeah, the person shouldn't be fighting dogs in the first place but after they get the taste of blood, especially pitbulls, good luck trying to reform them and keeping all of your fingers and toes.
I'm sorry. The pain of losing a sibling, parent or family member is 100x worse than the life of a dog who was destined to get killed or end up hurting someone in the first place. It's sad that the dogs died and they deserved a better fate. But if someone put a guy who killed dogs away before they put away a drunk driver who killed my mom, I'd be [expletive] furious.
Taking a life, with your hands, on purpose will always be worse than accidentally taking a life no matter how bad your choices were that lead to it.
This is nonsense, imo.
You eat meat. You don't kill it.
People and animals die all over the world. This isn't at my hands or yours.
It is not nonsense to insist that when people take lives, violently, they are at the least, looked at cross eyed. Vick has been and I don't care if he plays football.
But it is not nonsense to expect human beings to refrain from taking lives, brutally, with their hands.
Taking a life, with your hands, on purpose will always be worse than accidentally taking a life no matter how bad your choices were that lead to it.
This is nonsense, imo.
You eat meat. You don't kill it.
People and animals die all over the world. This isn't at my hands or yours.
It is not nonsense to insist that when people take lives, violently, they are at the least, looked at cross eyed. Vick has been and I don't care if he plays football.
But it is not nonsense to expect human beings to refrain from taking lives, brutally, with their hands.
I hate that you don't get this.
So just because the animals were killed by someone else, that makes it okay to eat them? If you killed a person, but I ate the body, does that mean that I'm stripped of responsibility?
I have a hard time working up empathy for people I don't know, much less dogs. Good grief. You just don't want people out there running around that kill humans or animals. I hate fake outrage, no one actually cares about these dogs. Those people should be incapacitated by the grief they feel for third-world people and unable to read the Michael Vick story.
docellis wrote:
But it is not nonsense to expect human beings to refrain from taking lives, brutally, with their hands.
Of course they should refrain from that but that's not what you've been saying in this thread. The implication of what you're saying is that violently killing a goldfish is worse than painlessly murdering a human.
G. Keenan wrote:I think vehicular homicide is just as immoral as first degree murder but for practical purposes it can't be punished as harshly legally.
Very few people would agree. I think this is a refusal to recognize distinctions. You can argue that as a practical matter, only outcomes matter, but morally motivation counts too. It's a distinction we recognize in all social interactions.
G. Keenan wrote:The animal situation is different. It's like saying the ends justify the means. Well they don't. Inflicting unintended suffering, when it is in our power to avoid doing so, to satisfy our own wants is immoral.
Sure, but we are talking about degrees of immorality here. Accepting animal cruelty for food production is not as bad as accepting it for entertainment.
Last edited by Arthur Dent on August 17 09, 11:49 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Taking a life, with your hands, on purpose will always be worse than accidentally taking a life no matter how bad your choices were that lead to it.
This is nonsense, imo.
You eat meat. You don't kill it.
People and animals die all over the world. This isn't at my hands or yours.
It is not nonsense to insist that when people take lives, violently, they are at the least, looked at cross eyed. Vick has been and I don't care if he plays football.
But it is not nonsense to expect human beings to refrain from taking lives, brutally, with their hands.
I hate that you don't get this.
So just because the animals were killed by someone else, that makes it okay to eat them? If you killed a person, but I ate the body, does that mean that I'm stripped of responsibility?
For murder? Yes. For cannibalism? Nope, that's all you.