Douchification of the Red Sox

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
User avatar
skmsw
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 6340
Joined: April 18 06, 7:12 pm
Location: The Hub

Re: Douchification of the Red Sox

Post by skmsw »

(chuckle) my "refuse to believe it" question was actually aimed at you, not the Sox fans you've encountered. You say they "refuse to believe it" as if any rational person has to accept your argument. Only way to see it. Win.

The "Evil Empire" quote from Luccino was made in, what, 2002 or 2003? For goodness sake, Tino Martinez was the Cards' first baseman then. The "evil empire" remark is about as relevent to the current Sox as Tino is to the current Cards. If that's the basis for your current opinions, it might be worth examining what is stopping you from moving on.

And if what is stopping you is lil ole 2002 Patriots and nasty 2004 Sox -- that's OK. You can admit it. We all have those. No one says it has to be reasonable -- just like Luccino was not being rational, was emotional and frustrated and felt out-done yet again -- when he made his "evil empire" remark in the first place. As long as we recognize that it is at least as much about us as it is about the object of our scorn -- it is not about what the Sox say or do, it is about how we feel about the Sox -- then there is no requirement to be reasonable.

Even if it is too painful to admit that the Cards are every bit the resource bully of their division that the Sox are in theirs.

User avatar
Cronos
In perpetuum
Posts: 34778
Joined: June 30 06, 7:49 am
Location: St. Louis

Re: Douchification of the Red Sox

Post by Cronos »

Edit: The quote boxes are going all googly on me, so I'll try posting this again.

Yes, I got that. I was looking past it in order to continue the discussion without it becoming personal.

And I should specify that I haven't had a lot of contact on a daily basis with Sawx fans for a few years, mainly ending a year after my undergraduate years ('01-05). My alma mater seemed to have a lot of New England sports fans on campus those years. The particular number of sox fans with which I've had the majority of contact over the years may not have been the best representation either, for all I know. But they seemed rather intelligent, clear thinking people compared to the common denominator.

In reference to the "little ole' Patriots and Sox" comment, I don't really know what you want there. I fully acknowledged that before I even started posting about anything else in my previous post that I still bear a grudge for those times as a sports fan. Childish? Maybe, but you're also acting rather childish falling back on that in this particular instance.

And the payrolls and dynamics of Cards/Cubs aren't anywhere comparable to the Yankees/Sox payrolls over those years, but if we are the "Evil Empire" of the NL Central, than as Theo and JoD have said, I will fully welcome the title rather than try and act "holier-than-thou as Sox fans did in villifying the yankees for doing what they themselves were doing.

User avatar
skmsw
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 6340
Joined: April 18 06, 7:12 pm
Location: The Hub

Re: Douchification of the Red Sox

Post by skmsw »

I was looking past it in order to continue the discussion without it becoming personal.
Hmmm. I'm sorry I overlooked your attempt to keep it from getting personal. We're in a thread with the word "douchification" in the title, featuring posts in which you yourself've admitted to a certain lack of rationality and grudge driving your perceptions and comments have been made about pretty much all of New England. So hopefully you'll indulge me a little if I figured that this whole conversation is personal. Not that it is directed, intentionally or otherwise, at me by any means, but it's pointed at an entire team, its fans, and even its home city, and as such personal nonetheless to any of us who happen to have an affiliation with that team, live in that city, etc. Not that my feelings are hurt -- but as the resident SoxApologist, the polemic was enough to get me to at least give the counter-arguments.
Childish? Maybe, but you're also acting rather childish falling back on that in this particular instance.
My initial response might be, it is not childish on my part to have rightly identified the driving (and flawed) factor behind your argument. You've admitted the point to be valid.

But that thought shared out loud, I'll simply acknowledge the feedback -- no disputing I've jumped into a brawl I entered intending to stay above!
. . . rather than try and act "holier-than-thou as Sox fans did . . .
As some Sox fans did. This kind of over-generalization is dangerous. You're a psych student, yes? You know better than this.

As I said in my initial post in this thread, there are Sox fans who are louts, loudmouths, and blowhards. In fact, probably three times as many such category of fans as there are like-minded Cards fans. But there are also three times as many intelligent, articulate, open-minded Sox fans as there are like-minded Cards fans, too. Boston is three times the size of STL, and all of new england and "red sox nation" around the country certainly is at least the equal of "the best baseball fans in america" and the Cards' historically regional fan base. You're letting your experiences with a small sample of Sox fans drive your perceptions. It's like someone from Boston visiting Cards Talk and living next door to a buffoon Cards fan, and deciding that those experiences are representative of all (not even typical but all) Cards fans. I'm quite confident that I can find Brewers or Astros fans who saw the Cards draft Miller, sign Mateo, and trade for Holliday and said "when did this become the AL East? And those damn Cards Talk fans think they're better then everyone else, if I hear one more word about how smart they are, one more of them talk about a pitcher getting Lidged, I'm gonna vomit."

So, maybe I should ask the forum at large for some help here. After all, I did not wander into this thread (I usually steer clear of rants for just this reason), I was invited in (by a mod who felt my perspective might bring something interesting to the discussion). Not to single out Cronos -- his feelings are held by many otherwise-sensible posters -- How does one usefully discuss an over-generalization and personal comments generically directed at an entire region, team, and group of fans that is admittedly driven in no small part by resentment over the 02 superbowl and the 04 world series?

Or, are rants simply what they are -- insensitive tirades to be disregarded no matter who they ultimately ensnare?
Last edited by skmsw on August 26 09, 11:03 am, edited 2 times in total.

TimeForGuinness
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 20007
Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm

Re: Douchification of the Red Sox

Post by TimeForGuinness »

“I got nothing against no Bostonian. No Bostonian ever called me a Cubs fan.”

User avatar
skmsw
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 6340
Joined: April 18 06, 7:12 pm
Location: The Hub

Re: Douchification of the Red Sox

Post by skmsw »

TimeForGuinness wrote:“I got nothing against no Bostonian. No Bostonian ain't never called me no Cubs fan.”
Fixed.

TimeForGuinness
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 20007
Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm

Re: Douchification of the Red Sox

Post by TimeForGuinness »

skmsw wrote:
TimeForGuinness wrote:“I got nothing against no Bostonian. No Bostonian ain't never called me no Cubs fan.”
Fixed.
Hey now, I may butcher the places of an Ali quote...but I'm not tough enough to screw with triple negatives around him ;)

You sir, are a brave soul

User avatar
haltz
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 22630
Joined: November 9 06, 6:45 am
Location: a proud midwestern metropolis

Re: Douchification of the Red Sox

Post by haltz »

This kind of over-generalization is dangerous.
I don't know that it's so dangerous when it comes to sports rivalries. St. Louis dying, Wrigley's a giant bar, Boston is racist or loves fleece jackets or something? Not sure what the go-to line is there, but whatever.

I think the reason that people don't like the Red Sox is pretty simple. To an outside observer, especially as a fan of one of the best teams you'll ever see assembled only to trampled over by Destiny, the Sox went from a likable underdog to a team you could hate overnight. Instead of the AL version of the Cubs with some great history that you could actually root for and that didn't seem like such a pathetic franchise.

Anyway, after all of this ESPN took both franchises (NY and BOS) and rolled them up into one giant evil empire where the teams where indistinguishable if you didn't really care and shoved it in your face and made you look. I used to like both for different reasons. I cheered for the Sox in 2004 until the WS and got chills when I walked into Yankee Stadium for a July game vs the Blue Jays.

People used to like Brett Favre I think too. I think it's as simple as that. I know why ESPN did this - and I don't blame them. If it's not the Cinderella story anymore then they need to be a bad guy. Or something.
Last edited by haltz on August 26 09, 11:29 am, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Cronos
In perpetuum
Posts: 34778
Joined: June 30 06, 7:49 am
Location: St. Louis

Re: Douchification of the Red Sox

Post by Cronos »

haltz wrote:
I think the reason that people don't like the Red Sox is pretty simple. To an outside observer, especially as a fan of one of the best teams you'll ever see assembled only to trampled over by Destiny, the Sox went from a likable underdog to a team you could hate overnight. Instead of the AL version of the Cubs with some great history that you could actually root for and that didn't seem like such a pathetic franchise.

Anyway, after all of this ESPN took both franchises (NY and BOS) and rolled them up into one giant evil empire where the teams where indistinguishable if you didn't really care and shoved it in your face and made you look. I used to like both for different reasons. I cheered for the Sox in 2004 until the WS and got chills when I walked into Yankee Stadium for a July game vs the Blue Jays.

People used to like Brett Favre I think too. I think it's as simple as that. I know why ESPN did this - and I don't blame them. If it's not the Cinderella story anymore then they need to be a bad guy. Or something.
It certainly doesn't help.

It's gotten to the point where even the pundits on sportscenter make off-handed jokes about their own company's over-coverage of it.

User avatar
heyzeus
Everday Unicorn
Posts: 43335
Joined: April 21 06, 10:14 am
Location: Austin, TX

Re: Douchification of the Red Sox

Post by heyzeus »

skmsw wrote:
So, maybe I should ask the forum at large for some help here. After all, I did not wander into this thread (I usually steer clear of rants for just this reason), I was invited in (by a mod who felt my perspective might bring something interesting to the discussion). Not to single out Cronos -- his feelings are held by many otherwise-sensible posters -- How does one usefully discuss an over-generalization and personal comments generically directed at an entire region, team, and group of fans that is admittedly driven in no small part by resentment over the 02 superbowl and the 04 world series?
?
Steve, the problem is you're taking simple generalizations, which you've identified as fallacious, personally. Don't conflate the two, and you're fine. What is sports, and rivalry, without generalizations? It's a large part of being a fan(atic) in any sport. There's nothing particularly rational about, say, hating the Cubs and their fans (the former is made up of professionals who play in a city for money then move on; the latter there are millions of that fall into every spectrum of humanity). But competitive sports make for rivalries that are often more emotional than rational. And they can be fun, too.

I don't doubt people feel stung when their team and city are denigrated. They also might sense a kernel of truth in the generalization and oversimplification of their team/region. And it's fair to point out the inaccuracies in such statements. But it's also not hard to understand - rivalries thrive on this stuff. Don't take it personally.

Finally, if you really think that it's only St Louisans who are bitter over '02 and '04 who dislike Boston sports fans, I suggest you check out the internet. The opinions expressed here are mild and restrained in comparison to other fanbases'.

planet planet
http://tinyurl.com/2e4x5hy
Posts: 24904
Joined: April 15 06, 6:25 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: Douchification of the Red Sox

Post by planet planet »

You Will Suffer Humiliation When the Sports Team from My Area Defeats the Sports Team from Your Area

As you can see from the calendar, the game is coming up this weekend. I'm sure you are as excited for it as I am, as our cities are rivals and have been for quite some time. Your confidence in your team is high, but rest assured, you will suffer humiliation when the sports team from my area defeats the sports team from your area.
On numerous occasions, you have expressed the conviction that your area's sports team will be victorious. I must admit that every time I hear you make this proclamation, I react with both laughter and disbelief. "Ha!" I say to myself with laughter. "What?!" I say to myself in disbelief. How could you believe that your sports team could beat my sports team? It is clear that yours is inferior in every way.
When the sporting contest begins, the players on your team will be treated as though they are inconsequential. It will be remarkably easy for my team to accumulate more points than yours. There are many reasons for this, starting with the inferior physical attributes of the players representing your area. Strength, speed, and agility are just three of the qualities that the players on the team from your area lack. The players representing my area, on the other hand, have these traits in abundance.
I would not be a bit surprised if the individuals on the team from your area were sexually attracted to members of their own gender. That is how ineffective they are on the field of battle.
Underscoring your team's inferiority is its choice of colors. It is ludicrous to believe that your team's colors inspire either respect or fear. Instead, they appear to have been chosen by someone who is colorblind or, perhaps, bereft of sight altogether. The colors for my team, on the other hand, are aesthetically pleasing when placed in proximity to one another. They are a superior color combination in every way.
While we are on the subject of aesthetics, let us compare the respective facilities in which our teams play. While my team's edifice is blessed with architectural splendor and the most modern of amenities, yours is a thoroughly unpleasant place in which to watch a sporting contest. I know of what I speak, for I once attended a game between our respective teams in your facility. Let's just say the experience left me wishing that my car was inoperable that day due to mechanical problems, rendering it impossible for me to get to your area to attend the game.
If you need another reason why the sporting franchise representing my area is superior, look no further than the supporters for the two sides. Not only are the supporters of the team from my region more spirited, but they are also more intelligent and of finer breeding than you and the rest of your ilk. In addition, the female supporters of the team from my area possess more attractive countenances and figures than yours. Some of the women from my side that I have observed could make a living by posing for pictures for major men's magazines. The women who cheer for your team, I'm afraid, are far too unattractive to do so.
One of the more pathetic aspects of the team from your area is the fact that only people in your immediate area possess an affinity for it. By means of contrast, the team from my area inspires loyalty and affection in individuals who live in many other geographic locations.
To illustrate this point, let me tell a brief story: Recently, I was on vacation in an area of the country far away from my own, and I saw many individuals wearing items of clothing that bore the insignia of my team. I approached one such individual and asked him if he originated from my area. He said no, explaining that he simply liked the team from my area and had for many years. Interestingly enough, during this trip, I saw no clothing or other paraphernalia bearing the insignia of your team.
Do you still doubt that the team from your area is inferior to the one from mine? Just look at our teams' respective histories. In the past, we have defeated you on any number of occasions. Granted, there were times when your team beat my team, but those were lucky flukes.
The day of the game will soon be at hand. And no matter how hard you pray to a higher power or how many foam accoutrements you wear in support of the team from your area, your team will be defeated. We will win and you will lose. This is your fate.
Prepare for humiliation. It shall be upon you at the designated hour.

Post Reply