Rant: Chain Restaurants

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
planet planet
http://tinyurl.com/2e4x5hy
Posts: 24904
Joined: April 15 06, 6:25 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by planet planet »

clement wrote:I have no ideological commitment to markets determining everything. I realize a statement like that is viewed as a threat to our nation's security, but so be it. And no I don't agree that taste is purely subjective.

And while it is true that there are still many independently owned restaurants opening and thriving, if we have seen a very clear trend of franchising growing over the past 30 years or so, then it stands to reason that there has to be losers to offset all those new winners. It just makes economic sense as well, with the economies of scale that favor larger organizations and chains over small business/independently owned restaurants.

As far as ranting about it is concerned, it's because people care what their country and their communities look like. Why waste energy defending the status quo? Obviously you care enough to do so.

And of course you would love chain restaurants, you're Cheddar Tom, the most plain, simple and bland cheese imaginable barely one step above processed American slices or Velveeta. If you were truly a cheese lover of high culture and exquisite taste you would be Camembert Tom, or Grana Padano Tom, or Pecorino Tom.

That last paragraph was completely tongue-in-cheek by the way. ;)
While I'm with you on the reasoning, your approach is a little overbearing. Cheddar Tom has a point; ultimately taste is a personal preference. I gave up that battle a long time ago.

Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by Arthur Dent »

clement wrote:And while it is true that there are still many independently owned restaurants opening and thriving, if we have seen a very clear trend of franchising growing over the past 30 years or so, then it stands to reason that there has to be losers to offset all those new winners. It just makes economic sense as well, with the economies of scale that favor larger organizations and chains over small business/independently owned restaurants.
Well, sure. There's always winners and losers, but I don't think that the places that got forced out were uniformly better. Some of the old-timey places are genuinely awful pre-chewed food type establishments. Some are undoubtedly good too. So it goes. At least in Austin, I don't feel like I'm suffering for a lack of interesting restaurant choices. There are other places that are dominated by chains with dystopian levels of logos per square inch, but often times the local stuff in those places was not so great either.

I think this is part of the tendency to think of big business as bad but small/local business as good which doesn't really make sense to me in general. There's a pretty good case to be made for this with restaurants since they are a form of entertainment and uniqueness is valuable in entertainment, but It's not the only thing that matters.

User avatar
clement
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 6008
Joined: April 20 06, 10:26 pm

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by clement »

planet pujolsian wrote:
clement wrote:I have no ideological commitment to markets determining everything. I realize a statement like that is viewed as a threat to our nation's security, but so be it. And no I don't agree that taste is purely subjective.

And while it is true that there are still many independently owned restaurants opening and thriving, if we have seen a very clear trend of franchising growing over the past 30 years or so, then it stands to reason that there has to be losers to offset all those new winners. It just makes economic sense as well, with the economies of scale that favor larger organizations and chains over small business/independently owned restaurants.

As far as ranting about it is concerned, it's because people care what their country and their communities look like. Why waste energy defending the status quo? Obviously you care enough to do so.

And of course you would love chain restaurants, you're Cheddar Tom, the most plain, simple and bland cheese imaginable barely one step above processed American slices or Velveeta. If you were truly a cheese lover of high culture and exquisite taste you would be Camembert Tom, or Grana Padano Tom, or Pecorino Tom.

That last paragraph was completely tongue-in-cheek by the way. ;)
While I'm with you on the reasoning, your approach is a little overbearing. Cheddar Tom has a point; ultimately taste is a personal preference. I gave up that battle a long time ago.
Which part is overbearing? I stand by my view that taste is not simply a matter of personal preference. I realize that's controversial to some, but why should I go along with that common perception if I don't agree with it? I like Aaron Miles more than Albert Pujols. That's personal preference. I think Aaron Miles is a better all-around ballplayer than Albert Pujols. That's pretty hard to defend. I realize that's an extreme example, but even comparing a player the calibre of a Chase Utley to Pujols can elicit some pretty passionate disagreement. Just because you have a bunch of numerical statistics to back up your argument doesn't mean that that that's valid while a more subjective assessment is not.

User avatar
Richie Allen
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 7458
Joined: December 22 06, 1:06 am

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by Richie Allen »

I haven't thought it through enough to know for sure but I'm wondering if you could substitute music (or bands) for restaurants in this thread and the arguments would be much the same.

planet planet
http://tinyurl.com/2e4x5hy
Posts: 24904
Joined: April 15 06, 6:25 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by planet planet »

clement wrote:
planet pujolsian wrote:
clement wrote:I have no ideological commitment to markets determining everything. I realize a statement like that is viewed as a threat to our nation's security, but so be it. And no I don't agree that taste is purely subjective.

And while it is true that there are still many independently owned restaurants opening and thriving, if we have seen a very clear trend of franchising growing over the past 30 years or so, then it stands to reason that there has to be losers to offset all those new winners. It just makes economic sense as well, with the economies of scale that favor larger organizations and chains over small business/independently owned restaurants.

As far as ranting about it is concerned, it's because people care what their country and their communities look like. Why waste energy defending the status quo? Obviously you care enough to do so.

And of course you would love chain restaurants, you're Cheddar Tom, the most plain, simple and bland cheese imaginable barely one step above processed American slices or Velveeta. If you were truly a cheese lover of high culture and exquisite taste you would be Camembert Tom, or Grana Padano Tom, or Pecorino Tom.

That last paragraph was completely tongue-in-cheek by the way. ;)
While I'm with you on the reasoning, your approach is a little overbearing. Cheddar Tom has a point; ultimately taste is a personal preference. I gave up that battle a long time ago.
Which part is overbearing? I stand by my view that taste is not simply a matter of personal preference. I realize that's controversial to some, but why should I go along with that common perception if I don't agree with it? I like Aaron Miles more than Albert Pujols. That's personal preference. I think Aaron Miles is a better all-around ballplayer than Albert Pujols. That's pretty hard to defend. I realize that's an extreme example, but even comparing a player the calibre of a Chase Utley to Pujols can elicit some pretty passionate disagreement. Just because you have a bunch of numerical statistics to back up your argument doesn't mean that that that's valid while a more subjective assessment is not.
Not exactly a fair comparison, but I get your point. There's evidence to support that Pujols is far and away a better player than Miles. The palate, however, cannot be quantified. Many people would think you are missing out on some of greatest gastronomic pleasures, simply because you're a vegetarian. Is that fair, regardless of the ethical reasons behind your decision? I'm frustrated with my sister's limited tastes, but I can't do anything about that.

User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30870
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by ghostrunner »

Arthur Dent wrote: I think this is part of the tendency to think of big business as bad but small/local business as good which doesn't really make sense to me in general.
I've already said I prefer local restaurants in general, but I agree with this. Just in my own experience (maybe I'm unique here), large business are far better employers. They might be more likely to let you go at some point, but every small business I've worked for has screwed over it's employees in terms of compensation and benefits, and management was either incompetent or insane or both. They work you harder and usually they're quite happy to lay the "we're a small business, we can't afford...." guilt trip BS on you. Meantime the owner grows the business and seems to do just fine. Every large company (with one exception) I've worked at has been respectful, procedures are in place to protect you from abuse, and the benefits and compensation have been better. And overall, far far less drama. I always look for those jobs first.

planet planet
http://tinyurl.com/2e4x5hy
Posts: 24904
Joined: April 15 06, 6:25 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by planet planet »

ghostrunner wrote:
Arthur Dent wrote: I think this is part of the tendency to think of big business as bad but small/local business as good which doesn't really make sense to me in general.
I've already said I prefer local restaurants in general, but I agree with this. Just in my own experience (maybe I'm unique here), large business are far better employers. They might be more likely to let you go at some point, but every small business I've worked for has screwed over it's employees in terms of compensation and benefits, and management was either incompetent or insane or both. They work you harder and usually they're quite happy to lay the "we're a small business, we can't afford...." guilt trip BS on you. Meantime the owner grows the business and seems to do just fine. Every large company (with one exception) I've worked at has been respectful, procedures are in place to protect you from abuse, and the benefits and compensation have been better. And overall, far far less drama. I always look for those jobs first.
At least SMB is touchy, feely while laying you off.

User avatar
haltz
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 22630
Joined: November 9 06, 6:45 am
Location: a proud midwestern metropolis

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by haltz »

In my personal experience, the big difference between chain restaurants and independent restaurants is that the people working at the indy places care more. Maybe I worked at particularly poor restaurants, but at the chain bar-grill places I never heard one conversation about food. No one gave a [expletive] if your steak fell on the floor and they stepped on it. It needs to go on a plate.

I don't know really, there's a lot more trying going on at independent places. Maybe that's because the one's I've worked at have been a little bit nicer, but the line chef that got to make a skate wing special that night can't wait to tell you all about it at lineup and wants to know what the customers that ordered it had to say.

You'll never ever meet the miserable son of a [expletive] who made the Applebee's menu, but at any indy place you'll most likely know the guy who created the food and he'll be there every day.

I asked the kitchen manager at Houlihans what I should eat there during my first week, and eight years later I still remember his response "McDonald's."
Last edited by haltz on September 10 09, 12:44 am, edited 2 times in total.

User avatar
clement
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 6008
Joined: April 20 06, 10:26 pm

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by clement »

Arthur Dent wrote:
clement wrote:And while it is true that there are still many independently owned restaurants opening and thriving, if we have seen a very clear trend of franchising growing over the past 30 years or so, then it stands to reason that there has to be losers to offset all those new winners. It just makes economic sense as well, with the economies of scale that favor larger organizations and chains over small business/independently owned restaurants.
Well, sure. There's always winners and losers, but I don't think that the places that got forced out were uniformly better. Some of the old-timey places are genuinely awful pre-chewed food type establishments. Some are undoubtedly good too. So it goes.
To the part in bold, I never suggested otherwise. But if it's just about "in with the good and out with the bad", then the assumption has to be that all the chains that have replaced the independently owned restaurants were simply better in quality than those that went out of business. If I'm reading what you have written in this thread, then I don't think you're making that argument. They have survived yes, so their business model was more effective. If our measure of quality is success, then fine, we can be upfront about that. But people usually separate quality and success as two separate, but not necessarily independent concepts. I think in this way.

I don't think it's blasphemous for a community to decide that they want to create opportunities for local business owners to start businesses that will serve its community and add to its aesthetic environment. Even in America there have been city councils and townships that have prevented Starbucks and McDonalds from being allowed to open shop on certain streets or in certain neighborhoods. I see nothing wrong with these kinds of decisions, in fact I'm very supportive of them. I know that's controversial to many, especially in the US, and that's a debate worth having. But it's not an unheard of concept.
At least in Austin, I don't feel like I'm suffering for a lack of interesting restaurant choices. There are other places that are dominated by chains with dystopian levels of logos per square inch, but often times the local stuff in those places was not so great either.
Sure but it becomes a bit of a self-fulfilling prophecy at some point. A place like Austin attracts people from many different places, lots of young people, has a very cosmopolitan population; and so there are more people who are actively looking for different options than the usual run-of-the-mill stuff you get everywhere. I realize that different communities have different preferences as well. But I still make the point that it is harder for an independent shop to compete with a national chain. They have to perform much more profitably and efficiently in order to survive than their larger competitors.
I think this is part of the tendency to think of big business as bad but small/local business as good which doesn't really make sense to me in general. There's a pretty good case to be made for this with restaurants since they are a form of entertainment and uniqueness is valuable in entertainment, but It's not the only thing that matters.
You're assuming that I'm saying big business is bad. I'm saying that the big businesses have an advantage. And with the specific case of restaurants, since it is a part of the entertainment and cultural makeup of a community, I think that citizens have a right to have a voice in terms of what their communities will look like.

User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30870
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by ghostrunner »

planet pujolsian wrote:
ghostrunner wrote:
Arthur Dent wrote: I think this is part of the tendency to think of big business as bad but small/local business as good which doesn't really make sense to me in general.
I've already said I prefer local restaurants in general, but I agree with this. Just in my own experience (maybe I'm unique here), large business are far better employers. They might be more likely to let you go at some point, but every small business I've worked for has screwed over it's employees in terms of compensation and benefits, and management was either incompetent or insane or both. They work you harder and usually they're quite happy to lay the "we're a small business, we can't afford...." guilt trip BS on you. Meantime the owner grows the business and seems to do just fine. Every large company (with one exception) I've worked at has been respectful, procedures are in place to protect you from abuse, and the benefits and compensation have been better. And overall, far far less drama. I always look for those jobs first.
At least SMB is touchy, feely while laying you off.
Yeah, I'm sure that's falling on deaf ears in your situation. And I'm sure there's some good small business employers out there, but I'll be damned if I can find them. My current job frustrates the hell out of me. I've gradually lost pay and had workload increased the last two years. I'd trade the risk of layoff for getting rid of the daily grind of [expletive]. I get to drive a company car, which is pretty much all that's keeping me there. I'd basically have to find something that pays the same, plus the equivalent of a car payment and gas bill. And unfortunately my skills are not in high demand.

Anyway, I'm kind of running off topic here.

Post Reply