That doesn't really make sense as I didn't make anything near that suggestion. I was just backing up clement's statements and stating where I take offense.cards2468 wrote:So the suggestion here is to penalize people for not living in the city?JCShutout wrote:Gotta back Clement up, the suburban explosion did start around the 50s or so, was driven by the auto industry, and is completely unsustainable environmentally. You can look it up, there are documentaries. This is different from small towns which have been around forever.
And I know you're being defensive (although I don't know why), but I'm offended that you keep referring to cities as crime-ridden and filthy. Not every city and part of a city is near as bad as you say, and not every small town and suburb is as clean and pristine as your contrast indicates. For a couple of years in grad school I drove a truck all over the country for work. I drove through small towns and large cities between Denver and New York, and between Steven's Point, WI and some tiny town south of San Antonio. There were some small run-down towns I'd be wary of even stopping in, much less putting down roots.
Suburbs are unsustainable in a world in which oil is a finite resource. If the rest of the world lived the way most US citizens do, we would be fraked.
So yeah, we should live in a sustainable lifestyle. You can do that in a small town and in a city. You can do that if you have good public transportation and live near your work. You can do that if your economy isn't setup to produce significant waste. The way our current system is setup, this is not the case. Suburbs are part of the problem. The military is a huge user of oil and energy, another major problem.

