To be fair, it doesn't seem like "those people" are the only ones being defensive.clement wrote:I really don't see how or why suggesting that we make investments to create these kinds of options for people is so controversial and leads to the kind of defensiveness from a few people in this thread.
But apparently I'm an elitist. At least that's what Joe the Plumber thinks.
Sorry.
Rant: Chain Restaurants
- ThatGuy
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 5114
- Joined: October 15 06, 4:40 pm
- Location: Knoxville, TN
Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants
- cards2468
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 14745
- Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
- Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT
Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants
With all due respect, giving cities and other local governments money isn't the only aspect of the solution to the energy crisis. The military is very well aware of their inefficiencies with fuel. Over in Iraq, when they fill up their humvee, that gas isn't from a local pump. It's flown into the country from the US. The military has to spend something like $10 a gallon because of this. Plenty of research is being done in military contracted research labs as well as government labs, and that technology can be handed down to civilian applications. I personally am doing research with help from Army grant money and have 1 published paper with a 2nd on the way that are based around improving aerodynamic efficiency with focus on developing test methods for other applications, but as far as most people see, money to the military only pays for the bullets that penetrate innocent civilians.clement wrote:Not sure who said it was.ghostrunner wrote:I'm not buying this cars are unsolvable/unfixable thing.
But what on earth is wrong with investing in infrastructure and projects using technologies that we have already developed and that have proven to work rather than just sticking our heads in the sand and hoping that when we pull them back out, somebody somewhere will have invented the that perfect clean, abundant, and cheap fuel for automobiles? Is it just because people don't want to ride on a train? Nobody is suggesting that we drag anyone on to trains or buses if they don't want to ride them.
And a clean automobile technology still doesn't address a lot of the other sustainability and health issues that urban sprawl creates.
Personally, I've lived in and been to communities of all sizes (big cities, small towns, suburbs) that have had cars everywhere and others where cars are relatively sparse and many people find other ways of getting around (using their feet, as one example). Even if all those cars didn't produce one speck of pollution, the pleasantness of not being surrounded by automobiles whizzing by and clogging up roads while you're taking a Sunday stroll is enough to make me prefer the latter type of environment.
Around the developed world, nobody forces people to live in cities. Many people choose to, once they have viable public transportation options that allow them to move fairly freely and easily and comfortably between their residence and their place of work, or other places they have to go. And a natural consequence of that choice is cities that are pleasant and green and safe and clean. Many other people however will choose to live in suburbs and yet still take advantage of the commuter trains that are there to allow them to move around with relatively little hassle. Most of these people still own cars and they use them when it is more convenient, but public transportation can still be a part of their overall transportation portfolio.
I really don't see how or why suggesting that we make investments to create these kinds of options for people is so controversial and leads to the kind of defensiveness from a few people in this thread. (edit: that's not aimed at you ghost, I'm always up for a spirited discussion with you, even when we disagree).
But apparently I'm an elitist. At least that's what Joe the Plumber thinks.
Sorry.
All I'm saying is that while all this new technology is great, it still has to come from somewhere.
- clement
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 6008
- Joined: April 20 06, 10:26 pm
Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants
I get defensive when I put effort into posting something, whether right or wrong, I think it at least is worthy of debate or discussion and instead I get called elitist and angry by a few people, without a single counter-argument or counter-proposal put forward.ThatGuy wrote:To be fair, it doesn't seem like "those people" are the only ones being defensive.clement wrote:I really don't see how or why suggesting that we make investments to create these kinds of options for people is so controversial and leads to the kind of defensiveness from a few people in this thread.
But apparently I'm an elitist. At least that's what Joe the Plumber thinks.
Sorry.
I'm not really sure where I contradicted or even addressed anything you've said here. If I did, it certainly wasn't intentional. I'm absolutely not against trying to develop better efficiencies in fuel consumption or developing entirely different fuel sources. Our approach doesn't have to be either/or.cards2468 wrote:With all due respect, giving cities and other local governments money isn't the only aspect of the solution to the energy crisis. The military is very well aware of their inefficiencies with fuel. Over in Iraq, when they fill up their humvee, that gas isn't from a local pump. It's flown into the country from the US. The military has to spend something like $10 a gallon because of this. Plenty of research is being done in military contracted research labs as well as government labs, and that technology can be handed down to civilian applications. I personally am doing research with help from Army grant money and have 1 published paper with a 2nd on the way that are based around improving aerodynamic efficiency with focus on developing test methods for other applications, but as far as most people see, money to the military only pays for the bullets that penetrate innocent civilians.
All I'm saying is that while all this new technology is great, it still has to come from somewhere.
edit: I suppose the "bury our hands in the sand" might be interpreted as suggesting that we aren't actually doing work to research these kinds of things. Poor choice of words on my part there. I have always supported investing in developing new and cleaner technologies and I would absolutely be in favor of continuing and increasing this kind of research.
- cards2468
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 14745
- Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
- Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT
Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants
There was a mentioning of the military being a waste of money for the government earlier and then when you mentioned spending on infrastructure being important, I just wanted to address that people should look a little deeper into what the money is being spent on. The example using myself was just an example, but there actually is plenty of research being done on alternative fuels. In my school there's been groups working for the past few years on designing a satellite to be launched that will hold test equipment to allow tests to be done using bio-fuel so that space can be used to simulate a vacuum and being in orbit to simulate 0-g situations. The purpose is to find ways of using bio-fuel for manned missions in space; for instance, human waste on board the ISS is recycled into water, but there's a possibility it can also be used for on-board energy, and the idea is that it can be used in other applications.clement wrote:I'm not really sure where I contradicted or even addressed anything you've said here. If I did, it certainly wasn't intentional. I'm absolutely not against trying to develop better efficiencies in fuel consumption or developing entirely different fuel sources. Our approach doesn't have to be either/or.cards2468 wrote:With all due respect, giving cities and other local governments money isn't the only aspect of the solution to the energy crisis. The military is very well aware of their inefficiencies with fuel. Over in Iraq, when they fill up their humvee, that gas isn't from a local pump. It's flown into the country from the US. The military has to spend something like $10 a gallon because of this. Plenty of research is being done in military contracted research labs as well as government labs, and that technology can be handed down to civilian applications. I personally am doing research with help from Army grant money and have 1 published paper with a 2nd on the way that are based around improving aerodynamic efficiency with focus on developing test methods for other applications, but as far as most people see, money to the military only pays for the bullets that penetrate innocent civilians.
All I'm saying is that while all this new technology is great, it still has to come from somewhere.
- ghostrunner
- GOAT
- Posts: 30870
- Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm
Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants
I agree with and see what you're saying here. Though I do think it's pretty clear that many prefer life in the suburbs. And our country has been built up with that and automobiles in mind. Whether or not some people encouraged that, certainly many people were attracted to the option.clement wrote: But what on earth is wrong with investing in infrastructure and projects using technologies that we have already developed and that have proven to work rather than just sticking our heads in the sand and hoping that when we pull them back out, somebody somewhere will have invented the that perfect clean, abundant, and cheap fuel for automobiles? Is it just because people don't want to ride on a train? Nobody is suggesting that we drag anyone on to trains or buses if they don't want to ride them.
Around the developed world, nobody forces people to live in cities. Many people choose to, once they have viable public transportation options that allow them to move fairly freely and easily and comfortably between their residence and their place of work, or other places they have to go. And a natural consequence of that choice is cities that are pleasant and green and safe and clean. Many other people however will choose to live in suburbs and yet still take advantage of the commuter trains that are there to allow them to move around with relatively little hassle. Most of these people still own cars and they use them when it is more convenient, but public transportation can still be a part of their overall transportation portfolio.
I'm all for more commuter trains and light rail. But it should be realized how difficult something like light rail is to get going. Austin couldn't even get light rail approved in a public vote, despite much of the business community being behind it. Neighborhoods who didn't want their area disrupted were against it (city neighborhoods even). Other businesses and politicans opposed it.
We have the infrastructure for cars, and that's what people are used to. So when it comes to getting things as clean as possible, as fast as possible, that actually seems easier to me.
Cities aren't without their environmental warts either. You have light pollution, noise pollution, excessive heat. Runoff (sometimes polluted) from all the pavement. Living in small apartments, there's not much opportunity to produce your own energy. With single family homes, I've already heard about solar shingles for houses along with plaid old solar panels. There are wind turbines that are usable in the suburbs. I pay to have a good portion of my trash picked up and recycled. Not sure if that's done in the city or not. As with anything, all it takes is a change of mindset, and we've seen that happen to some extent already.
Getting all these suburban folks back to the city (not to mention the jobs) would take decades just from a practical standpoint. Never mind political realities and personal preferences. My own preference is the suburbs (though I'm in a more central suburb). If I want to go out and enjoy the weather, I don't have to drive anywhere or take a train. My son has enough room to play. My wife can garden, which is a big stress reliever for her. It's relatively quiet. No honking horns and no traffic. Which brings to mind that as far as the US goes, really only New York has enough mass transit to put a dent in the car usage. It's subway was built 100 years ago, so the city has grown around it. Every other US city is still largely dependent on cars. Even Chicago seems that way to me, though it's rail system is fairly old.
One thing I would be in favor of is curbing new development when there's ample room or opportunity to use existing land or structures. It's in a city's best interest not to have eyesores and land going untended.
- clement
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 6008
- Joined: April 20 06, 10:26 pm
Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants
Yeah I guess part of my frustration is that there is in fact a lot of public opposition to building mass transport systems in cities. I don't understand it. Meanwhile in St. Louis (for example) there has been a pretty massive disruption of highway 40 that is taking up the better part of 3 years. When I lived in Georgia, voters rejected expanding the BART trains several times, while extension of Georgia 400 and the building of the Jimmy Carter Expressway made it through. And that's not even mentioning the adding of additional lanes to highways 75 and 85.
In the city where I currently reside, when I arrived several years ago, there were exactly two train lines in operation. Since I've been here, there has already been the completion of an entirely new third subway line (17 stations), some new stations added to the two existing lines, and several smaller local light rail lines have been put up. They are in the midst of building a new 4th line, which will have 31 stations and will be the longest contiguous metro train line in the world. The first phase of stations of that line opened earlier this year and the entire system is to be up and running by 2012. Fifth, sixth and seventh train lines are already in the works, as well as extensions of all the existing rail lines. And here, I actually take buses more frequently than trains. There are cities all over the world that are building brand new subway systems. Better late than never is how I see it.
I don't think that New York is the only place in the US where public transport puts a dent in car usage. In Manhattan the vast majority of people use subways and their feet because it's such a densely populated place. But there are very functional public transportation systems in San Francisco, Washington DC, and Boston, that I'm aware of. They could all be better and improved, but again, I believe doing something significant even if imperfect is much better than nothing.
In the city where I currently reside, when I arrived several years ago, there were exactly two train lines in operation. Since I've been here, there has already been the completion of an entirely new third subway line (17 stations), some new stations added to the two existing lines, and several smaller local light rail lines have been put up. They are in the midst of building a new 4th line, which will have 31 stations and will be the longest contiguous metro train line in the world. The first phase of stations of that line opened earlier this year and the entire system is to be up and running by 2012. Fifth, sixth and seventh train lines are already in the works, as well as extensions of all the existing rail lines. And here, I actually take buses more frequently than trains. There are cities all over the world that are building brand new subway systems. Better late than never is how I see it.
I don't think that New York is the only place in the US where public transport puts a dent in car usage. In Manhattan the vast majority of people use subways and their feet because it's such a densely populated place. But there are very functional public transportation systems in San Francisco, Washington DC, and Boston, that I'm aware of. They could all be better and improved, but again, I believe doing something significant even if imperfect is much better than nothing.
-
Michael
- GRB Founder
- Posts: 35304
- Joined: December 31 69, 6:00 pm
- Location: Chicago, IL
- Contact:
Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants
I'm in Ulaanbaatar Mongolia right now and they have only one recognizable food chain. Unbelievably it's Kenny Rogers Roasters, which really strange because chicken isn't a part of the Mongolian diet. Out of morbid curiosity I popped my head in to have a look. There were upscale leather booths with table cloth and a full bar. Naturally there were unappetizing pictures of Kenny Rogers everywhere.
Best. Cultural. Experience. Ever.
Best. Cultural. Experience. Ever.
- Popeye_Card
- GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
- Posts: 31087
- Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am
Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants
Let's see, trains. People pay the same fare to get from the same place to another same place. Sure sounds like socialism to me.
- clement
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 6008
- Joined: April 20 06, 10:26 pm
Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants
The funny thing is, that on Saturday, in the midst of this frothy chain restaurant debate, I actually went to Kenny Rogers Roasters in Singapore. Believe it or not, I go there now and then because I usually cycle on the East Coast and they have a restaurant there along my bike route. I like to get their side dishes, ... the corn on the cob, steamed broccoli & cauliflower, cole slaw, and the like. But I always comment to the poor teenager behind the counter, "It must be tough working here listening to that continuous loop of Kenny Rogers music all day. I bet by the end of your shift you're ready take that carving knife and hack everyone to pieces. I know I would."Michael wrote:I'm in Ulaanbaatar Mongolia right now and they have only one recognizable food chain. Unbelievably it's Kenny Rogers Roasters, which really strange because chicken isn't a part of the Mongolian diet. Out of morbid curiosity I popped my head in to have a look. There were upscale leather booths with table cloth and a full bar. Naturally there were unappetizing pictures of Kenny Rogers everywhere.
Hope you're enjoying Mongolia!
- Transmogrified Tiger
- Puppy Murderer
- Posts: 9323
- Joined: April 25 06, 6:07 pm
- Location: Across the River
Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants
My girlfriend had a similar experience in Beijing. The Pizza Hut was decked out like a really upscale sit down place, and they had really bizarre toppings available.Michael wrote:I'm in Ulaanbaatar Mongolia right now and they have only one recognizable food chain. Unbelievably it's Kenny Rogers Roasters, which really strange because chicken isn't a part of the Mongolian diet. Out of morbid curiosity I popped my head in to have a look. There were upscale leather booths with table cloth and a full bar. Naturally there were unappetizing pictures of Kenny Rogers everywhere.
Best. Cultural. Experience. Ever.


