clevername wrote: If the impact with the ground knocks the ball loose, it's not a catch.
i have no interest in the Raiders actually a Rams fan, but the impact with the ground occurred when his butt hit the ground and he held the ball. then there was a separate and second impact when his arm hit the ground. even then he held for a bit.
If anything, its not conclusive enough to overturn.
Ok I'll stop
btw- was surprised Cable didn't go ballistic after that call.
well, then why isn't it when any part of him impacts the ground? so, when his feet hit before his butt hit, he's made contact and maintained possession.
In my eyes, he has to get down on the ground as much as he's going to no matter what hits first (as opposed to being "down" on a run), which he wasn't when his butt hit the ground. He still had to go further due to his momentum...and when he went further he may or may not have lost possession.
Man, this was a tough first week for some of the league's best players:
Urlacher - gone for season (wrist)
Shawn Andrews - gone for season (back)
Polamalu - out 3-6 weeks (knee)
McNabb - busted rib probably keeps him out a few weeks at minimum
Jerod Mayo - knee injury will keep him out for a while
clevername wrote:well, then why isn't it when any part of him impacts the ground? so, when his feet hit before his butt hit, he's made contact and maintained possession.
In my eyes, he has to get down on the ground as much as he's going to no matter what hits first (as opposed to being "down" on a run), which he wasn't when his butt hit the ground. He still had to go further due to his momentum...and when he went further he may or may not have lost possession.
I guess I disagree. I think it should be both of your feet down and if the ball isn't moving, that's a catch. The ground being able to knock the ball loose just doesn't make sense to me. If you land on the ground and your feet haven't been down, sure, but if you get your feet down and have control of the ball, that's a touchdown. That's the way it was for the majority of my life, and it worked fine.
I'd be fine with that if when your feet touched you're in control of your body at least and not just hitting your feet first on the way down. And if you can take a step or two before falling, yeah I can accept that as a catch.
When it's one fluid motion of jumping, catching the ball, coming down feet first, then in a continual motion coming down the rest of the way I think you should have to hold on to the ball.
clevername wrote:I'd be fine with that if when your feet touched you're in control of your body at least and not just hitting your feet first on the way down. And if you can take a step or two before falling, yeah I can accept that as a catch.
When it's one fluid motion of jumping, catching the ball, coming down feet first, then in a continual motion coming down the rest of the way I think you should have to hold on to the ball.
Obviously the NFL agrees with you, so point for clever...
Thing is that the rule is whatever the rule happens to be that season. The NFL is very reactionary esp in re to what constitutes a catch. And they do it in an attempt to more clearly define a catch and still they end up with this.
See: Immaculate Reception, Mel Gray's catch vs the Redskins, Bucs/Rams NFC Championship, etc. See also the tuck rule and the Raiders "fumble" into the endzone to beat SD.