Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State

A forum for non-baseball sports
Faceman
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 4800
Joined: May 23 06, 11:56 am
Location: Memphis, TN

Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State

Post by Faceman »

phinstd wrote:
I get it...Miami isn't quite back to the big boy table...
I'm not trying to take shots at Miami. It was one line of my post. They are doing fantastically well with a ridiculous schedule.

The Big 10 is not as bad as non Big 10 fans think. They just end up playing the top SEC or USC every year.

The problem is the system. To make it fair, all 6 BCS conferences should have a championship game. That way an OSU can't just sit back and wait for everyone else to lose.

Or alternatively, USC (who is probably the most talented team year in and year out) could just do what they should do, and win every game. But they drop a clunker on the road every year. Somehow, they always get up to play OSU though. Go figure.

Faceman
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 4800
Joined: May 23 06, 11:56 am
Location: Memphis, TN

Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State

Post by Faceman »

phinstd wrote:
I don't get it...because I personally, and this is simply and only my opinion on the matter, they aren't an elite team, it is because Miami is pretty good?

Perhaps I came on too strong in all of this...I have a lot of fun chatting about college football, and I honestly and truly respect the heck of Kirk Ferentz.
No. And if that is the way my post read, I'm sorry about that. I do not think you think Iowa is far from elite because Miami is pretty good. I was trying to cut the top from the rest.

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31100
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State

Post by Popeye_Card »

IMO, any team that is undefeated during the regular season should at least have a chance to win a national championship on the field. That goes for any team from any conference. Once a team has a loss, their fate is up to the system.

So, IMO, if Iowa is the only or one of two undefeated teams at the end of the season, they deserve to be able to play for their sport's championship. I don't care if the game is Boise State vs. Iowa. To be able to win every game you play, but not be able to win a championship because of what conference you are in is silly. Dare I say, it is UN-AMERICAN.

Also, if you include Texas or OU in the perrenial powers, I think you have to include Ohio State too. They have just as good of track record as those teams, especially if you consider their close game with Texas last season despite being large underdogs. IMO, all three of these teams are a step below the SEC-school-of-the-year and USC.

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State

Post by phins »

Popeye_Card wrote:IMO, any team that is undefeated during the regular season should at least have a chance to win a national championship on the field. That goes for any team from any conference. Once a team has a loss, their fate is up to the system.

So, IMO, if Iowa is the only or one of two undefeated teams at the end of the season, they deserve to be able to play for their sport's championship. I don't care if the game is Boise State vs. Iowa. To be able to win every game you play, but not be able to win a championship because of what conference you are in is silly. Dare I say, it is UN-AMERICAN.

Also, if you include Texas or OU in the perrenial powers, I think you have to include Ohio State too. They have just as good of track record as those teams, especially if you consider their close game with Texas last season despite being large underdogs. IMO, all three of these teams are a step below the SEC-school-of-the-year and USC.
It is an interesting thought, but the fact remains all things aren't equal. Boise St. gets to play a lot of turdtastic teams each year. Should we punish Florida because they have NEVER, and I repeat that for those reading at home, NEVER EVER EVER EVER, had an undefeated season because they play a bunch of ridiculously good teams each week? It's tough to answer without a playoff, which I'm sure we all agree they should have one.

You beat #2, #7, #16, #21, and #25 all in the same season, but you lose a tough, close game one week. On the other hand, you beat #7, and #22, and then a bunch of mediocre to worse teams, without losing one. I'd have a hard time deciding between those teams.

For me, I think we should have something that adds in the quality of teams each week, and sort of use that in addition to the outcomes of the games, and yes even the "eyeball" test.

PS- Did I mention that Florida has never had an undefeated season? Man, I like saying that...hopefully that doesn't change this season. :P

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31100
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State

Post by Popeye_Card »

I agree that it is hard to choose. That is why I think it shouldn't be up to voters and computer rankings.

IMO, the system should be a playoff system. 16 total teams (4 rounds). Each conference champion gets a spot. Each additional undefeated team gets a spot. The last handful of spots go to at-large teams (can be chosen by a system similar to the BCS system). First round is at the home team. Final 3 rounds are at the major bowl sites.

Cut down the non-conference schedule to 2 games. Most teams play 10 games, conferences with championship games would play 11. Max of 15 games for the final two teams. I think this would be the most fair system. The bowls can be filled out with the non-playoff teams, and the big bowls like the Rose can play a traditional game with losers from the playoffs of their choice (in most years, they could still take the Pac and Big Ten champs).

Faceman
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 4800
Joined: May 23 06, 11:56 am
Location: Memphis, TN

Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State

Post by Faceman »

Good luck with that. I'm not sure where the loss is coming from.

@ MSU
UGA (cocktail party)
Vandy
@SC
Fla Int'l
FSU

Man - if they aren't playing FSU or Miami in non-con, it is cupcake city. Fla Int'l, Char (charlotte?), and Troy.

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State

Post by phins »

I have hope for Alabama in the championship game, and if the Hogs had a kicker, or Childs could run a step faster, or the refs hadn't helped Florida immensely, they'd already have a loss.

They've been the better team and lost several times...it's never happened without one.

Faceman
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 4800
Joined: May 23 06, 11:56 am
Location: Memphis, TN

Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State

Post by Faceman »

Popeye_Card wrote:I agree that it is hard to choose. That is why I think it shouldn't be up to voters and computer rankings.

IMO, the system should be a playoff system. 16 total teams (4 rounds). Each conference champion gets a spot. Each additional undefeated team gets a spot. The last handful of spots go to at-large teams (can be chosen by a system similar to the BCS system). First round is at the home team. Final 3 rounds are at the major bowl sites.

Cut down the non-conference schedule to 2 games. Most teams play 10 games, conferences with championship games would play 11. Max of 15 games for the final two teams. I think this would be the most fair system. The bowls can be filled out with the non-playoff teams, and the big bowls like the Rose can play a traditional game with losers from the playoffs of their choice (in most years, they could still take the Pac and Big Ten champs).
IMO, 16 is WAY too many. Go with 8. 6 conf champs and 2 at-large. And make sure every BCS league has a championship game. Not only does that affect rankings now (like OSU sitting on the sideline, waiting) but it also would eliminate some of the at-large possibles, so that there is less griping about those. Very rarely are you going to be able to make strong cases for more than 2 at-larges.

Faceman
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 4800
Joined: May 23 06, 11:56 am
Location: Memphis, TN

Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State

Post by Faceman »

phinstd wrote:I have hope for Alabama in the championship game, and if the Hogs had a kicker, or Childs could run a step faster, or the refs hadn't helped Florida immensely, they'd already have a loss.

They've been the better team and lost several times...it's never happened without one.
Or if they still had the Rebs on the schedule *grin* (my wife is from Oxford, and Ole Miss is 80 miles from Memphis). SEC football keeps me from gouging my eyes out. For instance, I got to watch Ole Miss at home beat up on UAB instead of watching Illinois crap the bed (again) at Indiana of all places.

Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21913
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: Purdue upsets #7 Ohio State

Post by Socnorb11 »

JL21 wrote:
Faceman wrote:You are all of a sudden bashing anything and everything Big 10 - for what? You have run socnorb into the ground. You saying this isn't based on the fact that for once the U doesn't completely suck anymore?
Where are you getting that? I think that's a ridiculous inference. "The only reason anyone could have for bashing the Big Ten is because their own team is doing really well". I find the notion that Iowa is elite to be laughable as well. Very good? Sure. Deserve their ranking? Yeah, I suppose, but only by default. If they continue to win games by their butt hair, then I'll eat crow and say they belong.

I think if you look at the long, long, long history of phins' posts both here and at CT before here, he's one of the most rational people in the Cardinals Forumsphere.
I think it's weird that you guys find it laughable that the #7 team in the country (as voted on by people that follow this for a living) is referred to as "elite", but nobody laughed when an earlier poster said that they didn't deserve to be in the top 15. Has there EVER been a 7-0 team from a major conference that wasn't ranked in the top 15? Ever? That's not laughable, but my subtle "elite" reference is? If Iowa wins out (which is a real possibility), then they will be in the discussion for the national championship game......... period. Any team in contention for the national championship should be considered "elite", in my opinion.

Post Reply