Popeye_Card wrote:IMO, any team that is undefeated during the regular season should at least have a chance to win a national championship on the field. That goes for any team from any conference. Once a team has a loss, their fate is up to the system.
So, IMO, if Iowa is the only or one of two undefeated teams at the end of the season, they deserve to be able to play for their sport's championship. I don't care if the game is Boise State vs. Iowa. To be able to win every game you play, but not be able to win a championship because of what conference you are in is silly. Dare I say, it is UN-AMERICAN.
Also, if you include Texas or OU in the perrenial powers, I think you have to include Ohio State too. They have just as good of track record as those teams, especially if you consider their close game with Texas last season despite being large underdogs. IMO, all three of these teams are a step below the SEC-school-of-the-year and USC.
It is an interesting thought, but the fact remains all things aren't equal. Boise St. gets to play a lot of turdtastic teams each year. Should we punish Florida because they have NEVER, and I repeat that for those reading at home, NEVER EVER EVER EVER, had an undefeated season because they play a bunch of ridiculously good teams each week? It's tough to answer without a playoff, which I'm sure we all agree they should have one.
You beat #2, #7, #16, #21, and #25 all in the same season, but you lose a tough, close game one week. On the other hand, you beat #7, and #22, and then a bunch of mediocre to worse teams, without losing one. I'd have a hard time deciding between those teams.
For me, I think we should have something that adds in the quality of teams each week, and sort of use that in addition to the outcomes of the games, and yes even the "eyeball" test.
PS- Did I mention that Florida has never had an undefeated season? Man, I like saying that...hopefully that doesn't change this season.
