rant...football injuries

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
User avatar
Sutter'sBeard
is the oscar meyer weiner kid
Posts: 3140
Joined: July 25 06, 1:02 pm
Location: Decatur, IL

Re: rant...football injuries

Post by Sutter'sBeard »

M1IRONMIKE wrote:My son, a junior in high school, had to miss the last game of the football season due to a injury. He has a neck injury causing a stinger down his left arm when he makes certain movements. xrays were negative and a MRI is scheduled for monday. Probably a pinched nerve of some sort which will almost certainly shut him down for at least a month. He planned on wrestling this winter and that appears to be in jeopardy. I love football but damn what a violent sport.

Image

Stinger's are probably the most common injury I have seen this year while officiating HS football. We've had three ambulance's brought onto the field this year for them. Although the trainers usually know they are stingers, they are always super cautious.

Overall, I don't think football is much more dangerous than basketball. Keep in mind that there are 22 players on the field at all times compared to 10 in basketball.

In my 5 years of officiating, I I've worked about 150 games. I'd say I've seen about 10 injuries that I would consider serious-Broken fingers, damaged knees, conscussions, dislocations.

On a personal note, I played 4 years of football and 4 years of basketball. I broke a thumb playing football and I broke one ankle and sprained both ankles, partially tore a meniscus, and broke a finger playing basketball.

Mike, what school does your boy play at?

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: rant...football injuries

Post by jim »

Freed Roger wrote:
jim wrote:I hate the sport. My kid not only lost the last half of his senior season (as a captain) and a playoff run that went to a state semi-final game, but his senior year of baseball because of a torn ACL. Tried to play at a small school but a week into camp was rushed off for another MRI because they thought he retore the freshly put together knee (he did not thankfully). It was a great relief to us when he decided he just wanted to go to college and not mess with it anymore.

Ever since that, the emotional pain of him not being able to be on the field his senior season, and it's just totally turned me off. Can't watch it at any level any longer.
I can't imagine how hard it is to watch your kid playing football. I know we live in an over-protective society (as if that does any good), but there are so many injuries in football that stick with you all season and potentially for your life. They've done retrospectives of the former Big Red in the P-D, what a terrible toll the game has taken on those guys. I was a shrimp trying to play a big guys game 20+ years ago, and it still hurts at times to watch the collisions. the padding and helmets only up the ante -it can be like being in a car wreck repeatedly.

My bro-in law is a sports PT. His two young chaps are pretty athletic little guys (of course they are, they're Freeds nephews :)). With the injuries he sees from football, that is one sport he won't let them play.

But I still like the game.
The worst part was watching him struggle with not being able to play. At our school they name the captains for the next year at the fall banquet, so he had this huge buildup of being the top dog going into the season plus the promise of a team that was going to be pretty good. I went to the state semi-final game wearing my sons jersey, he couldn't even go to the game. He had surgery Wed, developed a fever Fri. night so he had to sit in his bed listening on the radio. I can't even begin to tell you how difficult emotionally that was for all of us ... I mean this was supposed to be the day he had been working for for a long time and he's laying in bed in some contraption that keeps his knee moving back and forth for him.

During the game, a kid from Bloomington HS (McCavoy) who had verball commited to Michigan went down like a limp rag. Stinger ... had to bring the ambulance on. Scary as hell.

I saw that 60 minutes thing on football head injuries ... sick.

tscards
Veteran Player
Posts: 1233
Joined: April 20 06, 6:28 pm
Location: Sioux Falls, SD

Re: rant...football injuries

Post by tscards »

So is it really by sheer luck that people make it past high school, and into college, and then from there into the pros? I imagine that there's a great number of extremely talented players that can't play anymore early in their careers due to injury.

..and, sorry to hear about the injury! Hope nothing serious at all for the long run.

M1IRONMIKE
Well hello, pilgrim
Posts: 4129
Joined: October 7 06, 7:23 am
Location: springfield illinois

Re: rant...football injuries

Post by M1IRONMIKE »

Sutter'sBeard wrote:
M1IRONMIKE wrote:My son, a junior in high school, had to miss the last game of the football season due to a injury. He has a neck injury causing a stinger down his left arm when he makes certain movements. xrays were negative and a MRI is scheduled for monday. Probably a pinched nerve of some sort which will almost certainly shut him down for at least a month. He planned on wrestling this winter and that appears to be in jeopardy. I love football but damn what a violent sport.

Image

Stinger's are probably the most common injury I have seen this year while officiating HS football. We've had three ambulance's brought onto the field this year for them. Although the trainers usually know they are stingers, they are always super cautious.

Overall, I don't think football is much more dangerous than basketball. Keep in mind that there are 22 players on the field at all times compared to 10 in basketball.

In my 5 years of officiating, I I've worked about 150 games. I'd say I've seen about 10 injuries that I would consider serious-Broken fingers, damaged knees, conscussions, dislocations.

On a personal note, I played 4 years of football and 4 years of basketball. I broke a thumb playing football and I broke one ankle and sprained both ankles, partially tore a meniscus, and broke a finger playing basketball.

Mike, what school does your boy play at?




he plays for lanphier high school. He had an MRI today now we play the waiting game....

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: rant...football injuries

Post by jim »

tscards wrote:So is it really by sheer luck that people make it past high school, and into college, and then from there into the pros? I imagine that there's a great number of extremely talented players that can't play anymore early in their careers due to injury.

..and, sorry to hear about the injury! Hope nothing serious at all for the long run.
Absolutely there is luck. My son never missed a game, play, or practice that I can remember. Been playing since 4th grade. Senior year, running play up the middle and my son meets the ball carrier right at the line of scrimmage putting his hat right on the ball. Ball pops lose, big scrum, and his teammate who had been blown off the ball and was a good 5 yards down field comes sprinting in for the loose ball. He gets hit and loses his balance, and slams full bore right into the side of my sons leg who was in an awkard position. Bye bye ACL.

Let us know mike how things turn out. BTW - that McAvoy kid I told you about ended up playing at Michigan, so it wasn't as serious as it first seemed.

M1IRONMIKE
Well hello, pilgrim
Posts: 4129
Joined: October 7 06, 7:23 am
Location: springfield illinois

Re: rant...football injuries

Post by M1IRONMIKE »

This is old hat for Mikey. In 8th grade he had a hairline fracture in his leg near his knee . He kept playing ignoring the pain and when the season was over he finally told us that it still bothered him somewhat. We took him in and the doctor told us he had fractured it and the the muscles in and around his knee held it in place and that the reason he still had pain was because he had never got off of it. They put him in an air cast and on crutches. Then his freshman year he sustained a minor knee injury (slight tear of the meniiscus)that shut him down for the last 3 games and required some off season surgery. He has an incredible tolerance to pain but this stinger or pinched nerve or whatever it is brings him to tears. He never cries so I can't even imagine how painful it is. Thing is an hour after it happens he feels fine. Hopefully rest is all he will need.

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: rant...football injuries

Post by phins »

Football injuries are tough...sorry to hear about your boy Mike.

User avatar
Hungary Jack
Mother Earth
Posts: 19536
Joined: July 24 06, 6:03 am
Location: In Cognito

Re: rant...football injuries

Post by Hungary Jack »

haltz wrote:I snapped my tibia in the first game of the season my junior year of high school. The tendons pulled the top up over my knee like opening an envelope. I had to wear this ridiculous knee brace in basketball that year and my quad is a little smaller on that side to this day. Finding out at 16 that you aren't invincible isn't fun. I wish I'd never played.
Good grief. That's horrible. 16 year-olds should not have to experience that.

A few years ago I met a young woman at DePaul who was rehabbing her knee. She had a huge zipper because she was running hurdles in high school, came down off a jump, and blew her ACL, PCL, and MCL. Her knee just folded--in the wrong direction.

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: rant...football injuries

Post by jim »

Hungary Jack wrote:
haltz wrote:I snapped my tibia in the first game of the season my junior year of high school. The tendons pulled the top up over my knee like opening an envelope. I had to wear this ridiculous knee brace in basketball that year and my quad is a little smaller on that side to this day. Finding out at 16 that you aren't invincible isn't fun. I wish I'd never played.
Good grief. That's horrible. 16 year-olds should not have to experience that.

A few years ago I met a young woman at DePaul who was rehabbing her knee. She had a huge zipper because she was running hurdles in high school, came down off a jump, and blew her ACL, PCL, and MCL. Her knee just folded--in the wrong direction.
MacGahee (U Miami and later with the Bills) did that. You can look it up on youtube if you want to make yourself sick, even though I'm sure I've misspelled his name. When you tear your PCL with the ACL it's pretty catastrophic.

User avatar
Hungary Jack
Mother Earth
Posts: 19536
Joined: July 24 06, 6:03 am
Location: In Cognito

Re: rant...football injuries

Post by Hungary Jack »

jim wrote:
Hungary Jack wrote:
haltz wrote:I snapped my tibia in the first game of the season my junior year of high school. The tendons pulled the top up over my knee like opening an envelope. I had to wear this ridiculous knee brace in basketball that year and my quad is a little smaller on that side to this day. Finding out at 16 that you aren't invincible isn't fun. I wish I'd never played.
Good grief. That's horrible. 16 year-olds should not have to experience that.

A few years ago I met a young woman at DePaul who was rehabbing her knee. She had a huge zipper because she was running hurdles in high school, came down off a jump, and blew her ACL, PCL, and MCL. Her knee just folded--in the wrong direction.
MacGahee (U Miami and later with the Bills) did that. You can look it up on youtube if you want to make yourself sick, even though I'm sure I've misspelled his name. When you tear your PCL with the ACL it's pretty catastrophic.
IIRC, against Ohio State in the championship game.

There was a defensive back from South Carolina (I think) who got hit on the side of his knee as his leg was planted while sprinting laterally. It was gruesome, but I believe he came back to play.

Post Reply