Rant: Instant replay
- heyzeus
- Everday Unicorn
- Posts: 43335
- Joined: April 21 06, 10:14 am
- Location: Austin, TX
Re: Rant: Instant replay
I'm split on it. I mean, it infuriates me when calls are wrong. But I also change the channel whenever the inevitable 4 minute replay gets called in.
To flip the coin again, sometimes even after a replay it still appears the call is wrong, like with the Moats fumble in this weekend's Texans/Colts game
To flip the coin again, sometimes even after a replay it still appears the call is wrong, like with the Moats fumble in this weekend's Texans/Colts game
- brats&beer
- Veteran Player
- Posts: 744
- Joined: October 30 06, 10:53 am
Re: Rant: Instant replay
I say just fine the umps when they make a blatantly bad call. Don't break their banks, but you can find an amount that sufficiently hurts to discourage making bad calls. Just my two cents, and there's proly some major hole in the philosophy...
-
Socnorb11
- The Last Word
- Posts: 21909
- Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am
Re: Rant: Instant replay
How are you going to know if they make a bad call?brats&beer wrote:I say just fine the umps when they make a blatantly bad call. Don't break their banks, but you can find an amount that sufficiently hurts to discourage making bad calls. Just my two cents, and there's proly some major hole in the philosophy...
Replay?
Brilliant.
- brats&beer
- Veteran Player
- Posts: 744
- Joined: October 30 06, 10:53 am
Re: Rant: Instant replay
Not during the course of the game. If there's a questionable call (take the Yanks/Angels series for instance), it gets reviewed that night by MLB and they evaluate whether or not it was the correct call. Not balls and strikes mind you, but like the ball that was called foul and was fair by about five feet. You still get the human factor, you're not bogged down in waiting on an instant replay which affects crowd attention and the pitcher's arm, and the umps are more likely to make the correct call once they have been popped as they'll be more attentive to the situation.Socnorb11 wrote:How are you going to know if they make a bad call?brats&beer wrote:I say just fine the umps when they make a blatantly bad call. Don't break their banks, but you can find an amount that sufficiently hurts to discourage making bad calls. Just my two cents, and there's proly some major hole in the philosophy...
Replay?
Brilliant.
I think for the most part the quest tech (sp?) system that models the strike zone has done a lot to standardize the strike zone, but it doesn't influence the flow of the game. I'm just thinking that something along those lines could be done as an alternative to flat out instant replay.
-
TimeForGuinness
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 20007
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm
Re: Rant: Instant replay
I think they should play the game as is, then after the last out, replay the entire game on the jumbotron. The umpires can then correct every questionable call made during the game and the crowd can then rate the umpires. If an overturned call could affect the outcome of the game, then the umpires will upload the teams in diamond mind and simulate the outcome from that point on, based on the latest and greatest statistics. We're looking at about 8-10 hours of baseball per game, and the beer stands would be kept open until the 2nd 7th inning. I don't see why we're still arguing about this.
-
jim
- Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
- Posts: 50393
- Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm
Re: Rant: Instant replay
Because of this:I don't see why we're still arguing about this.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2009/11/1 ... 53374.html
Go to the 1:40 mark of the film to see what I am talking about, at the 2:00 mark you can see a section that I call "not interesting"... The call on the court was the shot was good and the Bulls win.
The point is, whether they called it basket or no basket, it kills the drama. When he made the shot I haven't scared the dog like that since Yadi homered in game 7 of the NLCS. But I will know better next time, when a freakishly weird thing happens on a sports field I won't let my emotions run with it. I'll know that we are going to have to sit there for who knows how long to find out whether or not I can really celebrate. I will keep my emotions in check, looking over my back to make sure there aren't any gotcha's.
I could make a sexual correlation involving transsexuals that I think fits perfectly, but that might offend someone so I won't.
But that's what instant replay is.
-
Socnorb11
- The Last Word
- Posts: 21909
- Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am
Re: Rant: Instant replay
jim wrote:Because of this:I don't see why we're still arguing about this.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2009/11/1 ... 53374.html
Go to the 1:40 mark of the film to see what I am talking about, at the 2:00 mark you can see a section that I call "not interesting"... The call on the court was the shot was good and the Bulls win.
The point is, whether they called it basket or no basket, it kills the drama. When he made the shot I haven't scared the dog like that since Yadi homered in game 7 of the NLCS. But I will know better next time, when a freakishly weird thing happens on a sports field I won't let my emotions run with it. I'll know that we are going to have to sit there for who knows how long to find out whether or not I can really celebrate. I will keep my emotions in check, looking over my back to make sure there aren't any gotcha's.
I could make a sexual correlation involving transsexuals that I think fits perfectly, but that might offend someone so I won't.
But that's what instant replay is.
The flip side is that Nuggets fans were able to celebrate, whereas they wouldn't have gotten to without replay. We went from devastation to anticipation to "YES!". I enjoyed it far more than I would have enjoyed the Bulls winning on a shot that shouldn't have counted anyway.
See....... it all evens out.
-
jim
- Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
- Posts: 50393
- Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm
Re: Rant: Instant replay
No they weren't. Their jaws probably dropped to the ground as the shot went in and was signaled good. Then wait, and wait, and wait, ..... and hope, and .... I'm bored I'll turn the TV off and read about it in the paper .... sleep .... wakeup .... pour cereal .... get paper out front .... open to sports .... NUGGETS WIN! .... take your morning dump .... off to work.Socnorb11 wrote:jim wrote:Because of this:I don't see why we're still arguing about this.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2009/11/1 ... 53374.html
Go to the 1:40 mark of the film to see what I am talking about, at the 2:00 mark you can see a section that I call "not interesting"... The call on the court was the shot was good and the Bulls win.
The point is, whether they called it basket or no basket, it kills the drama. When he made the shot I haven't scared the dog like that since Yadi homered in game 7 of the NLCS. But I will know better next time, when a freakishly weird thing happens on a sports field I won't let my emotions run with it. I'll know that we are going to have to sit there for who knows how long to find out whether or not I can really celebrate. I will keep my emotions in check, looking over my back to make sure there aren't any gotcha's.
I could make a sexual correlation involving transsexuals that I think fits perfectly, but that might offend someone so I won't.
But that's what instant replay is.
The flip side is that Nuggets fans were able to celebrate, whereas they wouldn't have gotten to without replay. We went from devastation to anticipation to "YES!". I enjoyed it far more than I would have enjoyed the Bulls winning on a shot that shouldn't have counted anyway.
See....... it all evens out.
It's not in the moment. Drama is lost. Sports are about drama ... not happiness or sadness. You lose some of that with IR.
-
Socnorb11
- The Last Word
- Posts: 21909
- Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am
Re: Rant: Instant replay
As a Nuggets fan, I did not enjoy the drama of the shot going in. I did enjoy the victory.jim wrote:
No they weren't. Their jaws probably dropped to the ground as the shot went in and was signaled good. Then wait, and wait, and wait, ..... and hope, and .... I'm bored I'll turn the TV off and read about it in the paper .... sleep .... wakeup .... pour cereal .... get paper out front .... open to sports .... NUGGETS WIN! .... take your morning dump .... off to work.
It's not in the moment. Drama is lost. Sports are about drama ... not happiness or sadness. You lose some of that with IR.
But I get your point. Disagree, but get your point.

