Rave: High School Football

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
User avatar
lukethedrifter
darjeeling sipping elite
Posts: 37260
Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
Location: Huis Clos

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by lukethedrifter »

BW23 wrote:
Radio_Bugtussle wrote:
Sutter'sBeard wrote:
I don't know the history of states other than Illinois but I think the multiplier is a good idea. Take a look at the state champions of the past in Illinois and I bet at least a third of them are private schools. Mt. Carmel (Chicago) is(or at least used to be) an all boys school. With having your whole student body as possible players, it gives you an unfair advantage over similar sized schools with half girls.
No multiplier in the real world. There is no rational reason for having one in the educational world--where we allegedly prepare kids for the real world.

The whole multiplier is a crutch. Only cripples need crutches.
What lesson about the real world does it teach? That certain people get advantages in life that most don't? I guess that's a fair one.

The rules are different. Nobody can deny that. Let everyone play by the same rules or group them apart from each other.
Or better yet make it like the Bowl system where every team gets to play in one and they all get trophies.

Maybe they should all have a Turkey Day game like Kirkwood and WG. No joke that it's basically a bowl game and a pretty nice consolation game for non state title years.

User avatar
Radio_Bugtussle
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 3450
Joined: July 26 06, 9:51 am
Location: Searching for the perfect microbrew

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by Radio_Bugtussle »

BW23 wrote: What lesson about the real world does it teach? That certain people get advantages in life that most don't? I guess that's a fair one.

The rules are different. Nobody can deny that. Let everyone play by the same rules or group them apart from each other.
Life isn't fair. Deal with it. A HS German teacher I had was rather fond of the phrase. Of course he'd probably get fired for daring to vocalize something so truthful now.

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by Freed Roger »

I will say non coed school should have multiplier.

But coed Private schools in jeff city breese or quincy aren't in metro areas and effectively have the same geograpahical constraints bringing in player
as the public schools there. So why should they be multiplied. ?

My elder girl went to private coed school before going to public. The private school had about 3 times as many girls as guys because of CBC being popular.. Then to hit that school with a multiplier -talk about unfair. Nevertheless-fans of the public school that knocked them out of boys bb playoffs had signs and chants about the "public schools over private"... I kid you not.



As for
Separate championships for private and public- haven't they watered down championships enough with all the classes? Back in the day-just getting to state was huge in BB. In FB, just making the playoffs was an accomplishment in IL

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by phins »

Radio_Bugtussle wrote:
Sutter'sBeard wrote:
I don't know the history of states other than Illinois but I think the multiplier is a good idea. Take a look at the state champions of the past in Illinois and I bet at least a third of them are private schools. Mt. Carmel (Chicago) is(or at least used to be) an all boys school. With having your whole student body as possible players, it gives you an unfair advantage over similar sized schools with half girls.
No multiplier in the real world. There is no rational reason for having one in the educational world--where we allegedly prepare kids for the real world.

The whole multiplier is a crutch. Only cripples need crutches.
You seem dead set on the issue, but I too, like the multiplier.

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by jim »

Radio_Bugtussle wrote:
Sutter'sBeard wrote:
I don't know the history of states other than Illinois but I think the multiplier is a good idea. Take a look at the state champions of the past in Illinois and I bet at least a third of them are private schools. Mt. Carmel (Chicago) is(or at least used to be) an all boys school. With having your whole student body as possible players, it gives you an unfair advantage over similar sized schools with half girls.
No multiplier in the real world. There is no rational reason for having one in the educational world--where we allegedly prepare kids for the real world.

The whole multiplier is a crutch. Only cripples need crutches.
There is no rational reason for having football, or any other sport, in the educational world either --- but we do.

User avatar
Sutter'sBeard
is the oscar meyer weiner kid
Posts: 3140
Joined: July 25 06, 1:02 pm
Location: Decatur, IL

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by Sutter'sBeard »

Radio_Bugtussle wrote:
BW23 wrote: What lesson about the real world does it teach? That certain people get advantages in life that most don't? I guess that's a fair one.

The rules are different. Nobody can deny that. Let everyone play by the same rules or group them apart from each other.
Life isn't fair. Deal with it. A HS German teacher I had was rather fond of the phrase. Of course he'd probably get fired for daring to vocalize something so truthful now.
But when we have opportunities to make it more fair, we should do so. The private schools are still doing fine with the multiplier. Last year, 4 of the 8 football Champs were private.

User avatar
BW23
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12896
Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by BW23 »

Radio_Bugtussle wrote:
BW23 wrote: What lesson about the real world does it teach? That certain people get advantages in life that most don't? I guess that's a fair one.

The rules are different. Nobody can deny that. Let everyone play by the same rules or group them apart from each other.
Life isn't fair. Deal with it. A HS German teacher I had was rather fond of the phrase. Of course he'd probably get fired for daring to vocalize something so truthful now.
Private schools have the advantage. It's very, very clear. I am dealing with it quite well, thanks.

It's still wrong, and there's no getting around that. Only those that have some connection to a private school would think otherwise. That or stupid people....although a lot of times it's the same thing.

If we want to have true choice, then that's fine. I could have gone 20 miles in any direction from my home high school's campus, grabbed a handful of players, and won a state championship every time in basketball. Easily.

Or we could just keep it the way it is and allow privates to be the only ones that can do that.

User avatar
Hungary Jack
Mother Earth
Posts: 19536
Joined: July 24 06, 6:03 am
Location: In Cognito

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by Hungary Jack »

jim wrote:
Radio_Bugtussle wrote:
Sutter'sBeard wrote:
I don't know the history of states other than Illinois but I think the multiplier is a good idea. Take a look at the state champions of the past in Illinois and I bet at least a third of them are private schools. Mt. Carmel (Chicago) is(or at least used to be) an all boys school. With having your whole student body as possible players, it gives you an unfair advantage over similar sized schools with half girls.
No multiplier in the real world. There is no rational reason for having one in the educational world--where we allegedly prepare kids for the real world.

The whole multiplier is a crutch. Only cripples need crutches.
There is no rational reason for having football, or any other sport, in the educational world either --- but we do.
Are you arguing that there is no educational value in playing sports, or that sports simply do not belong as part of formal schooling?

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by jim »

Hungary Jack wrote:
jim wrote:
Radio_Bugtussle wrote:
Sutter'sBeard wrote:
I don't know the history of states other than Illinois but I think the multiplier is a good idea. Take a look at the state champions of the past in Illinois and I bet at least a third of them are private schools. Mt. Carmel (Chicago) is(or at least used to be) an all boys school. With having your whole student body as possible players, it gives you an unfair advantage over similar sized schools with half girls.
No multiplier in the real world. There is no rational reason for having one in the educational world--where we allegedly prepare kids for the real world.

The whole multiplier is a crutch. Only cripples need crutches.
There is no rational reason for having football, or any other sport, in the educational world either --- but we do.
Are you arguing that there is no educational value in playing sports, or that sports simply do not belong as part of formal schooling?
I'm suggesting that the latter could be up for discussion. I'm not 100% sure of where I stand to be honest.

I understand the benefits of sports, I think they can be a very important part of a person growing up. They were for me. I took full advantage of the system by not only participating in HS sports but earning an athletic scholarship. Not because of my grades, not because my parents needed the money, simply because I was an ok baseball player. For some reason that concept just seems weird to me right now.

I know of at least one very good coach that happens to be a very bad science teacher who isn't going anywhere simply because he's a good coach. He's not just a bad teacher, he's incompetently bad. My oldest boy had him as a coach, my youngest as a science teacher. As much respect as I had for the man when I only knew him as a coach, I lost every bit of it and then some when I found out what kind of teacher he was.

My youngest son didn't get a job at a HS last year because, he was told, they needed a basketball coach. Seriously, you are going to make your hiring decision on what needs coached? That seems kind of messed up to me.

I've also attended board meetings recently because of some issues with the budget. I don't know, I guess all these recent events have allowed me to wonder if they just shouldn't seperate them.

Just thinking out loud a little bit.

User avatar
Radio_Bugtussle
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 3450
Joined: July 26 06, 9:51 am
Location: Searching for the perfect microbrew

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by Radio_Bugtussle »

phinstd wrote:
You seem dead set on the issue, but I too, like the multiplier.
A fair statement.

No redeeming value at any level. Just a way accept less than top performance and effort. That's a very bad message to send students. Very bad.

Again,

"LIFE isn't fair". Just look around.

Success and happiness comes from accepting that and dealing with it.

Post Reply