Rave: High School Football

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
User avatar
Sutter'sBeard
is the oscar meyer weiner kid
Posts: 3140
Joined: July 25 06, 1:02 pm
Location: Decatur, IL

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by Sutter'sBeard »

M1IRONMIKE wrote:Let me clarify my complaint with these schools. I have no problem with parents taking advantage of whatever inducements given to them to get their kids in these schools. I have no problem with these schools being foootball powerhouses. My problems lies with the fact that these schools hand out the need based aid for these students (in our local case football players) to come to the school and in a lot of cases a tremendously large amount of aid and then these schools get to compete against public schools who are bound by the rules of boundaries and are subject to the IHSA slamming their asses if they go out an actively recruit students from outside the boundaries. The playing field is ridiculously uneven. The State playoff series needs to be separated by public schools and private schools. Lets these powerhouses play each other and let public schools who abide by the equal and fair set of rules play each other.
I agree with a lot you are saying but I think it would be real tough to have two seperate playoffs. You could only fill a few brackets out with winning teams in each state. In Illinois, for the most part, private schools only exist in metro areas of around 50,000 people or more. There aren't that many metros and then you would have smaller private schools with enrollments of 300 playing larger private schools. I like the multiplier system and the state organizations should do what they can to keep recruitment down.

User avatar
Cheddar Tom
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 5885
Joined: May 13 09, 2:55 pm

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by Cheddar Tom »

as i recall...the idea of having separate playoff systems is not a new one and is a better idea than allowing the district runner up into the tournament.
lukethedrifter wrote:Why not just go to a Bowl system where every school gets to play and every kid gets a trophy?
i'm not sure this is what he's arguing...resenting private schools is something i understand. the private school i'm thinking of is a traditional powerhouse at volleyball and basketball...prob. because their scholarships go toward those best players. private schools have the best facilities and the best opportunities after a kid graduates so in that regard it really isn't fair. if my kid goes to Bland Public School A and westminster wants him to play baseball i'd be stupid not to encourage my kid to take that opportunity.

when it comes to hs sports, the playing field should be evened out. this is why we don't have rockhurst playing in the same class as blair oaks.

User avatar
BW23
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12896
Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by BW23 »

Radio_Bugtussle wrote:
BW23 wrote:
Freed Roger wrote:The irony. Penalizing schools that are successful in sports. Making the playing field level and "Fair" for everyone.

Thats not how the real world rolls.
How is creating a separate playoff system for private schools penalizing? Claiming that is penalizing is ridiculous. If the playing field shouldn't be level, then lets get rid of all rules. Or is there some need to keep some rules? The real world doesn't really work by many rules. What other rules should we get rid of? I'd really love to know.

That would constitute fixing something that isn't broken. Wasted time and wasted effort.
Different rules that substantially help private schools means that it is broken, even if you somehow try to rationalize that it isn't (not that you've even attempted to try and say how it is fair...and not that you could, so I don't blame you for not going out on that limb).

User avatar
BW23
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12896
Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by BW23 »

lukethedrifter wrote:The public HS that I went to is going for its 4th State Championship in the last 30 years tomorrow. That's not too bad.


BW, you want a totally separate playoff system for private schools? This is Missouri not California or Texas. Why not just go to a Bowl system where every school gets to play and every kid gets a trophy?
I want a totally different playoff system for those who get to play by a different set of rules. What I'm suggesting is that you add two state champions (or really one if you want to get down to specifics since removing the private schools would decrease the need for one class among publics). I'm not sure how that is comparable to every kid getting a trophy.

Do you think it would be fair for public schools to go with 11 men on the field at the time and private schools only use 10? To me, it's the pretty much the same. Different rules.

User avatar
BW23
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12896
Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by BW23 »

Cheddar Tom wrote:as i recall...the idea of having separate playoff systems is not a new one and is a better idea than allowing the district runner up into the tournament.
lukethedrifter wrote:Why not just go to a Bowl system where every school gets to play and every kid gets a trophy?
i'm not sure this is what he's arguing...resenting private schools is something i understand. the private school i'm thinking of is a traditional powerhouse at volleyball and basketball...prob. because their scholarships go toward those best players. private schools have the best facilities and the best opportunities after a kid graduates so in that regard it really isn't fair. if my kid goes to Bland Public School A and westminster wants him to play baseball i'd be stupid not to encourage my kid to take that opportunity.

when it comes to hs sports, the playing field should be evened out. this is why we don't have rockhurst playing in the same class as blair oaks.
The idea of allowing district runner ups is just ridiculous. It's an attempt to help some big name programs that choke or aren't quite as good get a second chance. It makes the first round of playoffs a joke. Just look at the scores in the first week...scores that could have been much worse in most cases if not for teams having a running clock in the second half with their second and third string players playing.

User avatar
Cheddar Tom
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 5885
Joined: May 13 09, 2:55 pm

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by Cheddar Tom »

yes...it was a terrible idea and one that mshsaa will prob. continue with when they vote on it in 2 yrs.

User avatar
BW23
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12896
Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by BW23 »

My local team played a team in the first round that was one of the worst teams they faced all year. Then they had to play a team in the second round they had beaten two weeks prior, and it wasn't close at all. Not that I should really be complaining about blowout wins, I guess, especially with the way the season ended.

User avatar
Cheddar Tom
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 5885
Joined: May 13 09, 2:55 pm

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by Cheddar Tom »

no...you should be complaining. teams that win their districts are punished by having to play runner ups. imagine if a serious injury had occurred during that game...all that hard work and district championship would go for nothing just b/c mshsaa is trying to soothe the hurt feelings of teams that compete in tough districts.

User avatar
lukethedrifter
darjeeling sipping elite
Posts: 37260
Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
Location: Huis Clos

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by lukethedrifter »

Tough game, Freed.

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by Freed Roger »

lukethedrifter wrote:Tough game, Freed.
yeah they just couldn't get it going. If only they had one play to spark them early on and........they probably would have still lost. but been competitive. Brentwood has some players, but if they double team the right guys, well, there you go.

Maryville was a stout team and their no nonsense offense-old school running is what won the day.

with football over now Brentwood can have enough guys for the Bball team - at least 4 of their starting 5 on BBall play football.

Still, a lot of fun. Rallied the community. Grade school and middle school kids saw something to get excited about and build towards. lots of tailgating and nobody regretted making the effort. Consolation, 3 to 4 of those kids played themselves into college scholarships this playoff run (no not D1).

on the way out, I told off the Helias folk coming in - what a bunch of undeserving private school aristocrats

Good luck to Hazlewood and Webster.

Post Reply