Rave: High School Football

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
User avatar
BW23
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12896
Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by BW23 »

Freed Roger wrote:Don't many school districts give free choice? where you can go to whichever public high school you wish. So in a town like Peoria - football kids migrate to the football school, or the basketball school etc.

And I'm told that public schools do plenty of their own recruiting.

With a separate championship for public schools, in short time one would find plenty of inequities and things for parents to complain about.
I can't speak for the urban areas about free choice, but it certainly doesn't exist outside of those areas. Not at all. Residency requirement rule.

I'm sure plenty of public schools do recruit. Residency requirements, however, do exist. There have been numerous instances of kids in schools in my area where kids have moved in that are great athletes. Most often, they take up residence in that school district. Sometimes it's a little shady, but the residency requirements still rule.

But at least you finally admit there is inequity.

M1IRONMIKE
Well hello, pilgrim
Posts: 4129
Joined: October 7 06, 7:23 am
Location: springfield illinois

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by M1IRONMIKE »

BW23 wrote:
Freed Roger wrote:Don't many school districts give free choice? where you can go to whichever public high school you wish. So in a town like Peoria - football kids migrate to the football school, or the basketball school etc.

And I'm told that public schools do plenty of their own recruiting.

With a separate championship for public schools, in short time one would find plenty of inequities and things for parents to complain about.
I can't speak for the urban areas about free choice, but it certainly doesn't exist outside of those areas. Not at all. Residency requirement rule.

I'm sure plenty of public schools do recruit. Residency requirements, however, do exist. There have been numerous instances of kids in schools in my area where kids have moved in that are great athletes. Most often, they take up residence in that school district. Sometimes it's a little shady, but the residency requirements still rule.

But at least you finally admit there is inequity.
There is no free choice in my hometown however transfers are allowed under certain academic or hardship circumstances and the school district here had gotten way to lax in allowing them which has also caused problems within the 3 public high schools here. They are now in the process of tightening up these rules. The recruiting may go on in the public schools but at least they are subject to discipline if they are caught. We had a local high school coach terminated for this very reason a few years ago. With private schools it is allowed legally and then those schools get to compete against public schools who have already been raped of the most talented players by the private school.

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by Freed Roger »

BW23 wrote:
Freed Roger wrote:Don't many school districts give free choice? where you can go to whichever public high school you wish. So in a town like Peoria - football kids migrate to the football school, or the basketball school etc.

And I'm told that public schools do plenty of their own recruiting.

With a separate championship for public schools, in short time one would find plenty of inequities and things for parents to complain about.
I can't speak for the urban areas about free choice, but it certainly doesn't exist outside of those areas. Not at all. Residency requirement rule.

I'm sure plenty of public schools do recruit. Residency requirements, however, do exist. There have been numerous instances of kids in schools in my area where kids have moved in that are great athletes. Most often, they take up residence in that school district. Sometimes it's a little shady, but the residency requirements still rule.

But at least you finally admit there is inequity.
I've always admitted there is an inequity. But not a fan of discriminatory means to creating this elusive "equity". And the inequity is not always as a result of cheating.

Maybe this argument is more about this ignorant rural/urban divide in MO and IL. a shame.

AWvsCBsteeeerike3
"I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
Posts: 27578
Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
Location: Thinking of the Children

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by AWvsCBsteeeerike3 »

M1IRONMIKE wrote: With private schools it is allowed legally and then those schools get to compete against public schools who have already been raped of the most talented players by the private school.
Why do the most talented pay to play at a private school that is farther away than play at a free school that is closer?

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by jim »

AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:
M1IRONMIKE wrote: With private schools it is allowed legally and then those schools get to compete against public schools who have already been raped of the most talented players by the private school.
Why do the most talented pay to play at a private school that is farther away than play at a free school that is closer?
This particular private school that Mike is speaking of there are three reasons that I can think of.

One, it's a football factory and if a family thinks Junior has a chance to play big time college football (which is basically every parent whose kid shows even an iota of talent), then that is where you go. It's on the radar because of the players they have produced. Don't think for a second that a college won't take a player from school A over school B, even if talent is the same, if they know the reputation of school A.

The second reason is that it is academically the strongest school in that town. Even if football doesn't work out, you probably aren't making a bad choice to go there if college is in your future regardless of sports.

Third, they give money. This is very much under the table, but it's widely believed that some of the very best players (who aren't Catholic by the way), get sometimes what amounts to a full ride. While I applaud a wealthy Catholic school like this giving need based awards to deserving students - especially minorities - I differ on what I call deserving and what they call deserving. Running a 4.7/40 in 8th grade should not factor in you getting financial aid. Either it does to this school, or there is some weird correlation between running really fast or being really big and being smart that exists nowhere else in the world except Central Illinois.

My two nieces went to that school, their parents were very much stretching the budget to send them, and didn't get a dime.

Honestly that school that Mike speaks of should be ashamed of themselves for the environment they have created. It's disgusting, the complete antithesis of what high school sports are supposed to be about, and the complete antithesis of what I imagine a church involved in educating children should be about. Football and other sports should be at most an activity to supplement their education.

This school does provide a good education, however I have a serious problem giving as much "need based" money that they give to kids that just happen to be great football players.

User avatar
BW23
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12896
Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by BW23 »

AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:
M1IRONMIKE wrote: With private schools it is allowed legally and then those schools get to compete against public schools who have already been raped of the most talented players by the private school.
Why do the most talented pay to play at a private school that is farther away than play at a free school that is closer?
I'm sure there are many reasons why. That's not really part of the discussion as to whether there should be separate playoff systems though.

User avatar
BW23
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12896
Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by BW23 »

Freed Roger wrote:
BW23 wrote:
Freed Roger wrote:Don't many school districts give free choice? where you can go to whichever public high school you wish. So in a town like Peoria - football kids migrate to the football school, or the basketball school etc.

And I'm told that public schools do plenty of their own recruiting.

With a separate championship for public schools, in short time one would find plenty of inequities and things for parents to complain about.
I can't speak for the urban areas about free choice, but it certainly doesn't exist outside of those areas. Not at all. Residency requirement rule.

I'm sure plenty of public schools do recruit. Residency requirements, however, do exist. There have been numerous instances of kids in schools in my area where kids have moved in that are great athletes. Most often, they take up residence in that school district. Sometimes it's a little shady, but the residency requirements still rule.

But at least you finally admit there is inequity.
I've always admitted there is an inequity. But not a fan of discriminatory means to creating this elusive "equity". And the inequity is not always as a result of cheating.

Maybe this argument is more about this ignorant rural/urban divide in MO and IL. a shame.
Just a fan of discriminatory means to create inequity then?

As for the inequity, I don't believe my argument was ever about cheating. Ever.

I really don't know how this is about some ignorant rural/urban divide, but I'd be interested in hearing more.

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by jim »

I think either use the multiplier or put them in their own private league championships. If they don't like it .... well life isn't always fair. Deal with it.

AWvsCBsteeeerike3
"I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
Posts: 27578
Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
Location: Thinking of the Children

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by AWvsCBsteeeerike3 »

jim wrote:
AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:
M1IRONMIKE wrote: With private schools it is allowed legally and then those schools get to compete against public schools who have already been raped of the most talented players by the private school.
Why do the most talented pay to play at a private school that is farther away than play at a free school that is closer?
This particular private school that Mike is speaking of there are three reasons that I can think of.

One, it's a football factory and if a family thinks Junior has a chance to play big time college football (which is basically every parent whose kid shows even an iota of talent), then that is where you go. It's on the radar because of the players they have produced. Don't think for a second that a college won't take a player from school A over school B, even if talent is the same, if they know the reputation of school A.

The second reason is that it is academically the strongest school in that town. Even if football doesn't work out, you probably aren't making a bad choice to go there if college is in your future regardless of sports.

Third, they give money. This is very much under the table, but it's widely believed that some of the very best players (who aren't Catholic by the way), get sometimes what amounts to a full ride. While I applaud a wealthy Catholic school like this giving need based awards to deserving students - especially minorities - I differ on what I call deserving and what they call deserving. Running a 4.7/40 in 8th grade should not factor in you getting financial aid. Either it does to this school, or there is some weird correlation between running really fast or being really big and being smart that exists nowhere else in the world except Central Illinois.
I guess you just made my point right there. Yes. It is a better school.

So, who cares? Kids that may not otherwise have had the opportunity get a better education. I never expected to hear anyone complain about that.

A bunch of people come off as whiners. So and so school is better so we need to kick them out of our league. They have more people to recruit from. They also have a tuition. Get over it.

User avatar
BW23
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12896
Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by BW23 »

AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:
jim wrote:
AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:
M1IRONMIKE wrote: With private schools it is allowed legally and then those schools get to compete against public schools who have already been raped of the most talented players by the private school.
Why do the most talented pay to play at a private school that is farther away than play at a free school that is closer?
This particular private school that Mike is speaking of there are three reasons that I can think of.

One, it's a football factory and if a family thinks Junior has a chance to play big time college football (which is basically every parent whose kid shows even an iota of talent), then that is where you go. It's on the radar because of the players they have produced. Don't think for a second that a college won't take a player from school A over school B, even if talent is the same, if they know the reputation of school A.

The second reason is that it is academically the strongest school in that town. Even if football doesn't work out, you probably aren't making a bad choice to go there if college is in your future regardless of sports.

Third, they give money. This is very much under the table, but it's widely believed that some of the very best players (who aren't Catholic by the way), get sometimes what amounts to a full ride. While I applaud a wealthy Catholic school like this giving need based awards to deserving students - especially minorities - I differ on what I call deserving and what they call deserving. Running a 4.7/40 in 8th grade should not factor in you getting financial aid. Either it does to this school, or there is some weird correlation between running really fast or being really big and being smart that exists nowhere else in the world except Central Illinois.
I guess you just made my point right there. Yes. It is a better school.

So, who cares? Kids that may not otherwise have had the opportunity get a better education. I never expected to hear anyone complain about that.

A bunch of people come off as whiners. So and so school is better so we need to kick them out of our league. They have more people to recruit from. They also have a tuition. Get over it.
My local school has had a pretty good basketball program over the last four years. They'll be down a little this year, but they should win districts over their rival from the private ranks. There are two neighboring schools, one eight miles away, another about 18 miles away. My local team needs a true point guard, and they could use some size. I could use two players from the school eight miles away. One is a true 1, the other is a good 4/5. The other school has a big man as well that would fit in nicely.

Now, my local school is easily the better school. There's no doubt that the three students would get a better education here. In fact, the cousin(s) of two of those kids played here specifically for the education and not the basketball after having been at the same school those two are at. The other kid desperately wanted to play here both as a frosh and as a sophomore.

None of these families can afford to pay our school's tuition. I say my local school waive the tuition. Sure, we won't get any money from the state for these three, but that's okay. We're providing a much better education than what those two schools offer.

Think any schools would complain when this team would cruise to the state championship? I bet the three or four private schools they'd beat along the way would have a problem. So would MSHSAA. So would DESE. As would all other public schools in the state. I bet that just adding these three would make them the best team in the state no matter what class they would play in (they're class 4, FWIW).

In the case of all three of these students, they all live closer to my local high school than the school they attend. The lines are drawn so tight, though, that you can't go more than 3 miles in any direction and be inside the school district.

Now, our school would never do this, but nothing else said within this is false.

Post Reply