Rave: High School Football
- Radio_Bugtussle
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 3450
- Joined: July 26 06, 9:51 am
- Location: Searching for the perfect microbrew
Re: Rave: High School Football
Whatever system is used is going to result in the same people doing well in tournaments and the same people whining that it isn't "fair" and that they are getting shafted somehow.
-
jim
- Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
- Posts: 50393
- Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm
Re: Rave: High School Football
AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:I guess you just made my point right there. Yes. It is a better school.jim wrote:This particular private school that Mike is speaking of there are three reasons that I can think of.AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:Why do the most talented pay to play at a private school that is farther away than play at a free school that is closer?M1IRONMIKE wrote: With private schools it is allowed legally and then those schools get to compete against public schools who have already been raped of the most talented players by the private school.
One, it's a football factory and if a family thinks Junior has a chance to play big time college football (which is basically every parent whose kid shows even an iota of talent), then that is where you go. It's on the radar because of the players they have produced. Don't think for a second that a college won't take a player from school A over school B, even if talent is the same, if they know the reputation of school A.
The second reason is that it is academically the strongest school in that town. Even if football doesn't work out, you probably aren't making a bad choice to go there if college is in your future regardless of sports.
Third, they give money. This is very much under the table, but it's widely believed that some of the very best players (who aren't Catholic by the way), get sometimes what amounts to a full ride. While I applaud a wealthy Catholic school like this giving need based awards to deserving students - especially minorities - I differ on what I call deserving and what they call deserving. Running a 4.7/40 in 8th grade should not factor in you getting financial aid. Either it does to this school, or there is some weird correlation between running really fast or being really big and being smart that exists nowhere else in the world except Central Illinois.
So, who cares? Kids that may not otherwise have had the opportunity get a better education. I never expected to hear anyone complain about that.
A bunch of people come off as whiners. So and so school is better so we need to kick them out of our league. They have more people to recruit from. They also have a tuition. Get over it.
If that made your point then I guess it's pointless to tell you that in my opinion, a HS basing any decision at all on it's sports program is flawed. The by product of a kid that didn't otherwise have the opportunity to get a better education is that another kid, more deserving on an academic and financial basis, did not get that opportunity.
Who cares that they have in their own playoff system? Who cares that there is a multiplier? They should stop whining, and get over it.
-
Freed Roger
- Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
- Posts: 26073
- Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
- Location: St. Louis
Re: Rave: High School Football
the private schools that you assume to have this "boo hoo unfair advantage" are predominantly in urban areas. Schools in more rural areas can't easily recruit out of their region. So therefore the assumption is cheaters are in urban areas.BW23 wrote:
Just a fan of discriminatory means to create inequity then?
As for the inequity, I don't believe my argument was ever about cheating. Ever.
I really don't know how this is about some ignorant rural/urban divide, but I'd be interested in hearing more.
I saw this play out when my daughter was a freshman at JFK a private catholic school. They were definitely the have-nots of private school sports -in fact were struggling to get boys to go to school there. Yet they were managing a good boys basketball season. Some rural town beat them in the playoffs in a close game. The town's fans had signs and cheers about Public schools over private implicating that they were beating the elitist cheating rich kids from the big city. That is the ignorant rural/urban divide.
Fact is -there is a multiplier. My old HS-private - can't recruit players since its 100 miles from sizeable towns, and frankly loses more players to the public school in town because of the economics. Yet each student gets counted as 1.6. But that's ok, they are still competitive and dealing with it without too much fuss. But should they put it together one year and win, someone like BW will fuss that they are a bunch of cheaters.
Parents and administrators need to quit [expletive] up competitive sports for kids. Let city teams play rural teams, private play public, catholic schools play public schools - thats what sportsmanship is about.
Peace out -I'll check back in March Madness time.
- lukethedrifter
- darjeeling sipping elite
- Posts: 37260
- Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
- Location: Huis Clos
Re: Rave: High School Football
I have a friend that spent a season or two as an assistant bball coach at JFK. I still have the tshirt which reads JFK basketball Striving to Get Better.Freed Roger wrote:the private schools that you assume to have this "boo hoo unfair advantage" are predominantly in urban areas. Schools in more rural areas can't easily recruit out of their region. So therefore the assumption is cheaters are in urban areas.BW23 wrote:
Just a fan of discriminatory means to create inequity then?
As for the inequity, I don't believe my argument was ever about cheating. Ever.
I really don't know how this is about some ignorant rural/urban divide, but I'd be interested in hearing more.
I saw this play out when my daughter was a freshman at JFK a private catholic school. They were definitely the have-nots of private school sports -in fact were struggling to get boys to go to school there. Yet they were managing a good boys basketball season. Some rural town beat them in the playoffs in a close game. The town's fans had signs and cheers about Public schools over private implicating that they were beating the elitist cheating rich kids from the big city. That is the ignorant rural/urban divide.
Fact is -there is a multiplier. My old HS-private - can't recruit players since its 100 miles from sizeable towns, and frankly loses more players to the public school in town because of the economics. Yet each student gets counted as 1.6. But that's ok, they are still competitive and dealing with it without too much fuss. But should they put it together one year and win, someone like BW will fuss that they are a bunch of cheaters.
Parents and administrators need to quit [expletive] up competitive sports for kids. Let city teams play rural teams, private play public, catholic schools play public schools - thats what sportsmanship is about.
Peace out -I'll check back in March Madness time.
God I love that shirt. Not striving for excellence just a bit of improvement.
-
jim
- Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
- Posts: 50393
- Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm
Re: Rave: High School Football
When I was a little kid it was completely fair. No multiplier, and no classes. I remember well when I was a kid, not sure of the exact year, but my HS which is usually has strong basketball teams (Kevin Gamble and Andre Igwadala are alumns) beat Virden HS in the opening round of the Regional tournament 99-36. I forgot what the score was at the half, but Virden was still in single digits. 60-9 or something like that.
So sometimes these adjustments are actually good for everyone. I don't hear anyone complaining about the multiplier in Illinois, this past weekend the private schools were very well represented.
So sometimes these adjustments are actually good for everyone. I don't hear anyone complaining about the multiplier in Illinois, this past weekend the private schools were very well represented.
Last edited by jim on November 30 09, 4:22 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- BW23
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12896
- Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm
Re: Rave: High School Football
Just forget it. It's not even worth trying to talk about this with someone like you. You clearly haven't read anything I've written. You're a private school apologist that has tried to paint things I've said into something completely different. But I expected as much. I see it a lot with the students and parents that attend the school I'm most familiar with. Just one more reason I'll never send my kid to one.Freed Roger wrote:the private schools that you assume to have this "boo hoo unfair advantage" are predominantly in urban areas. Schools in more rural areas can't easily recruit out of their region. So therefore the assumption is cheaters are in urban areas.BW23 wrote:
Just a fan of discriminatory means to create inequity then?
As for the inequity, I don't believe my argument was ever about cheating. Ever.
I really don't know how this is about some ignorant rural/urban divide, but I'd be interested in hearing more.
I saw this play out when my daughter was a freshman at JFK a private catholic school. They were definitely the have-nots of private school sports -in fact were struggling to get boys to go to school there. Yet they were managing a good boys basketball season. Some rural town beat them in the playoffs in a close game. The town's fans had signs and cheers about Public schools over private implicating that they were beating the elitist cheating rich kids from the big city. That is the ignorant rural/urban divide.
Fact is -there is a multiplier. My old HS-private - can't recruit players since its 100 miles from sizeable towns, and frankly loses more players to the public school in town because of the economics. Yet each student gets counted as 1.6. But that's ok, they are still competitive and dealing with it without too much fuss. But should they put it together one year and win, someone like BW will fuss that they are a bunch of cheaters.
Parents and administrators need to quit [expletive] up competitive sports for kids. Let city teams play rural teams, private play public, catholic schools play public schools - thats what sportsmanship is about.
Peace out -I'll check back in March Madness time.
I've never said one word about them cheating. Never. Ever. The funny thing is, the private school I'm most familiar with is indeed a "rural" team that pulls from 75-100 miles from any direction.
Peace out indeed. You're not worth talking about this any further.
-
AWvsCBsteeeerike3
- "I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
- Posts: 27578
- Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
- Location: Thinking of the Children
Re: Rave: High School Football
Would it make everyone feel better if public schools weren't bound by such strict boundaries and could 'recruit' from anywhere in the state? I've always thought forcing kids to go to a certain school if they went the public route was silly.
-
jim
- Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
- Posts: 50393
- Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm
Re: Rave: High School Football
Public schools are funded in large part by local property taxes (especially my district where I pay ~10K per year - a much higher rate then neighboring towns.). These local property taxes can fluctuate wildly from town to town. The incentive for people to stay in towns with high property taxes is often because of the good schools. If I could send my kids to any school I wanted, I would move to another town to pay the lower taxes and send them to the good school being funded by other people. Of course, it wouldn't be funded by those people, because there would be no reason to stay and they would all move out, and then I'm not sure what happens - chaos basically without an overhaul of school funding at the state level.AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:Would it make everyone feel better if public schools weren't bound by such strict boundaries and could 'recruit' from anywhere in the state? I've always thought forcing kids to go to a certain school if they went the public route was silly.
- TGantz
- R-E-S-P-E-C-T...What Dr Pepper Means to Me
- Posts: 6698
- Joined: July 27 06, 11:59 pm
- Location: The Lou
Re: Rave: High School Football
Can't the same be said to the people complaining about recruiting? It's a flawed system, just like the BCS in college football. Or even on a bigger scale, with parts of governments.jim wrote:If they don't like it .... well life isn't always fair. Deal with it.
-
jim
- Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
- Posts: 50393
- Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm
Re: Rave: High School Football
I think it's an empty comment that can be applied just about to anything you want to apply it to.Gantz57 wrote:Can't the same be said to the people complaining about recruiting? It's a flawed system, just like the BCS in college football. Or even on a bigger scale, with parts of governments.jim wrote:If they don't like it .... well life isn't always fair. Deal with it.



