BCS in the news

A forum for non-baseball sports
User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30874
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: BCS in the news

Post by ghostrunner »

Why does a smaller school deserve equal footing with the big schools? Nobody's forcing any of these schools to have a football program. They have these programs, I presume, because they make money for the school already. What entitles them to more? Even if you open up the field, it's a very small number of schools that are affected, with a lot of external factors affecting whether or not school X even has a shot at any money over the course of the next decade or two or three.

I don't get government involvement in it at all. It's just football. I don't care if it's unfair or not. Not to mention, just because a bowl game can't bill itself as the championship isn't going to have much effect on the perception, or what other people call it. I don't even remember many people calling these games "the national championship." Usually they still say the Rose Bowl or whatever.

User avatar
lukethedrifter
darjeeling sipping elite
Posts: 37260
Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
Location: Huis Clos

Re: BCS in the news

Post by lukethedrifter »

ghostrunner wrote:Why does a smaller school deserve equal footing with the big schools? Nobody's forcing any of these schools to have a football program. They have these programs, I presume, because they make money for the school already. What entitles them to more? Even if you open up the field, it's a very small number of schools that are affected, with a lot of external factors affecting whether or not school X even has a shot at any money over the course of the next decade or two or three.

I don't get government involvement in it at all. It's just football. I don't care if it's unfair or not. Not to mention, just because a bowl game can't bill itself as the championship isn't going to have much effect on the perception, or what other people call it. I don't even remember many people calling these games "the national championship." Usually they still say the Rose Bowl or whatever.
Toys are just toys, yet the government regulates the way those businesses operate and thru the CPSC is charged with ensuring they and other products don't pose unreasonable risks to Americans.

User avatar
clevername
Bringer of FRBG
Posts: 10380
Joined: April 16 06, 7:13 pm
Location: Alabama

Re: BCS in the news

Post by clevername »

ghostrunner wrote:Why does a smaller school deserve equal footing with the big schools? Nobody's forcing any of these schools to have a football program. They have these programs, I presume, because they make money for the school already. What entitles them to more? Even if you open up the field, it's a very small number of schools that are affected, with a lot of external factors affecting whether or not school X even has a shot at any money over the course of the next decade or two or three.
then those schools need to be split off into a separate division. They're currently in the same division as the big boys and in several games up against said big boys have won. The point of all this is competition and these smaller schools aren't being given a chance to prove themselves simply because they are in conferences that aren't considered "elite"...but they can't be considered elite unless they are given a chance to play the best and prove themselves.

There are two separate issues: the athletic competition (members of the NCAA deserve an equal opportunity to compete for a championship, otherwise why are they using that organization to govern their competition?) and the big money business side...
ghostrunner wrote:I don't get government involvement in it at all. It's just football. I don't care if it's unfair or not. Not to mention, just because a bowl game can't bill itself as the championship isn't going to have much effect on the perception, or what other people call it. I don't even remember many people calling these games "the national championship." Usually they still say the Rose Bowl or whatever.
it's BIG money and the big 6 conferences almost have a monopoly on it. The "championship" thing is just a way for congress to get their foot in the door to address the overall inequality in chances to get that big money. All the BCS has to do is change the name of their championship to the BCS Championship or whatever and leave out the National and all references to a presumed NCAA Division I championship, but they won't because that's the whole point of having that system in place.

Pujols is a God
Everyday Player
Posts: 179
Joined: April 17 06, 2:02 pm

Re: BCS in the news

Post by Pujols is a God »

The only problem with the 8 team playoff is where are the games going to be at. Most fans cant afford to travel 3 weeks in a row to see their team play should they keep winning. You could have it on the campus of the higher seed but that would be pretty unfair to the lower seeds.

albertmvpujols
All-Star
Posts: 1589
Joined: April 19 06, 7:03 am
Location: San Diego
Contact:

Re: BCS in the news

Post by albertmvpujols »

Pujols is a God wrote:The only problem with the 8 team playoff is where are the games going to be at. Most fans cant afford to travel 3 weeks in a row to see their team play should they keep winning. You could have it on the campus of the higher seed but that would be pretty unfair to the lower seeds.
While not on the campus of any of these teams, the last two years Florida played in Miami and LSU played in the Superdome. Two years before that, USC lost to Texas in the Rose bowl. Some of these teams have basically played at home in the national championship game anyway. The season would play out to where you played for seeds in the playoffs and it definitely beats the current system where these teams 3-8 don't have a shot at all at the NC. I do however agree with the travel aspect of it being problematic.

User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30874
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: BCS in the news

Post by ghostrunner »

lukethedrifter wrote:
ghostrunner wrote:Why does a smaller school deserve equal footing with the big schools? Nobody's forcing any of these schools to have a football program. They have these programs, I presume, because they make money for the school already. What entitles them to more? Even if you open up the field, it's a very small number of schools that are affected, with a lot of external factors affecting whether or not school X even has a shot at any money over the course of the next decade or two or three.

I don't get government involvement in it at all. It's just football. I don't care if it's unfair or not. Not to mention, just because a bowl game can't bill itself as the championship isn't going to have much effect on the perception, or what other people call it. I don't even remember many people calling these games "the national championship." Usually they still say the Rose Bowl or whatever.
Toys are just toys, yet the government regulates the way those businesses operate and thru the CPSC is charged with ensuring they and other products don't pose unreasonable risks to Americans.
I don't see a comparison. Some things should be regulated and some shouldn't. Toys have harmed kids and/or adults. I don't see how football has, or is. At least when it comes to voluntary spectators.

Suffice it to say there are times when I think the government gets it mitts in too many things, and this would be one of those.

MrSaigon

Re: BCS in the news

Post by MrSaigon »

This will never happen. Little Ceaser's funds way too many campaigns to see their bowl game lose meaning.

User avatar
Sutter'sBeard
is the oscar meyer weiner kid
Posts: 3140
Joined: July 25 06, 1:02 pm
Location: Decatur, IL

Re: BCS in the news

Post by Sutter'sBeard »

phinstd wrote:I say 8, none of this from other BCS talk, and G Tech won the ACC, not V Tech. If you're top 8 team, you're in. No, I don't believe Boise is better than Florida.
Yeah, but that is the price for not winning your conference. Florida might also be better than Texas but you have to have a formula. My favored system would leave teams 7 and 8 either non-major conference champions like BOise and TCU and/or teams like Florida or Texas from last year.

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: BCS in the news

Post by phins »

Sutter'sBeard wrote:
phinstd wrote:I say 8, none of this from other BCS talk, and G Tech won the ACC, not V Tech. If you're top 8 team, you're in. No, I don't believe Boise is better than Florida.
Yeah, but that is the price for not winning your conference. Florida might also be better than Texas but you have to have a formula. My favored system would leave teams 7 and 8 either non-major conference champions like BOise and TCU and/or teams like Florida or Texas from last year.
They play games against terrible teams, and only have to win really only one "tough" game a year to go unbeaten. I'm sorry, but Boise had to come from behind against the likes of Tulsa and UTEP type teams way too many times for them to qualify IMO. Florida loses, in a conference championship game no less, to an unbeaten SEC foe, and they are somehow not as worthy as Boise St?

I loathe Florida with every fiber of my being, but there is simply no chance it's equal footing in their seasons, and I wouldn't reward Boise like it is. I would make it 8 teams, and the best 8 get in. I'm not a "let's get mid-majors in" guy. They get their bowls, and unless they schedule teams at the top, and beat them (like TCU did), they don't deserve to be in. This isn't basketball, where we're letting 18-14 BCS teams in over non-BCS teams who've had great years.

Of course, this is what the BCS honks tell us all the time, that they really already have a playoff, just a season long one.

User avatar
Sutter'sBeard
is the oscar meyer weiner kid
Posts: 3140
Joined: July 25 06, 1:02 pm
Location: Decatur, IL

Re: BCS in the news

Post by Sutter'sBeard »

phinstd wrote:
Sutter'sBeard wrote:
phinstd wrote:I say 8, none of this from other BCS talk, and G Tech won the ACC, not V Tech. If you're top 8 team, you're in. No, I don't believe Boise is better than Florida.
Yeah, but that is the price for not winning your conference. Florida might also be better than Texas but you have to have a formula. My favored system would leave teams 7 and 8 either non-major conference champions like BOise and TCU and/or teams like Florida or Texas from last year.
They play games against terrible teams, and only have to win really only one "tough" game a year to go unbeaten. I'm sorry, but Boise had to come from behind against the likes of Tulsa and UTEP type teams way too many times for them to qualify IMO. Florida loses, in a conference championship game no less, to an unbeaten SEC foe, and they are somehow not as worthy as Boise St?

I loathe Florida with every fiber of my being, but there is simply no chance it's equal footing in their seasons, and I wouldn't reward Boise like it is. I would make it 8 teams, and the best 8 get in. I'm not a "let's get mid-majors in" guy. They get their bowls, and unless they schedule teams at the top, and beat them (like TCU did), they don't deserve to be in. This isn't basketball, where we're letting 18-14 BCS teams in over non-BCS teams who've had great years.

Of course, this is what the BCS honks tell us all the time, that they really already have a playoff, just a season long one.
Ideally they should place the Boise's, Utah, BYU's. TCU's, etc in better conferences but that won't be likely. Both Florida and Boise beat exactly only one ranked team though. I still think it is more fair to ask a team to win it's conference to play for a championship that to try and guess that Florida would whup Boise. Most years they would, but you never know. THis is what makes March Madness so fun.

Post Reply