The problem with Voyager is the great premise and the terrible execution. The whole ship suffered way too few casualties and the ship arrived home in far better condition then it left. The Year of Hell should have been what Voyager was like on a much slower scale. A good amount of the crew shouldn't have returned home and the ship should have been a hodgepodge of repairs, alien technology, and battledamage. They also shouldn't have lost 17 shuttles throughout the series. FWIW the NX-01 in Enterprise went through a third of the Third season and the beginning of the Fourth looking like this with no reset.redbirdjazzz wrote:TNG>>DS9>>>VOY>>>>>>>>>TOS, I never saw enough of ENT to get a good feel for it, but I suspect that at least the first two seasons would be way above TOS for me. I never understood the Voyager hate.AdmiralKird wrote:DS9>>>TNG>ENT>>>>TOS>>>>>>>>>>VOY
If you're going somewhere incredibly unknown you don't come back unscathed, even if your technology vastly outperforms other species (which in Voyager's case, it didn't). Look at Ferdinand Magellan's voyage. He left Spain with three of the best ships and crew of the time. Magellan was brutally stabbed to death, only around eleven of them made it back on only one ship several years later. And their technology obliterated anything they went up against, they didn't have the equivalent of the Borg. It just didn't do justice to the franchise and space travel in general.















