Rave: Obama Making All the Right Moves

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: Rave: Obama Making All the Right Moves

Post by Arthur Dent »

G. Keenan wrote:
What do you think about that piece? It gives me serious pause.

The neofeudalism piece referenced in the introduction also makes me wonder whether this was a good thing to do. The idea of being forced to pay 8-9 % of my income to a private, for-profit, company troubles me deeply.

It seems like this will ultimately come down to whether or not these exchanges do what they're theorized to, through market competition reduce premiums and increase benefits.
This is a stinky plan that came about as a compromise between elite interests. I take it for granted that it will need to be fixed. The question for me is both one of policy and one of politics. There are important upsides to the plan. Many more people will get health care. It will be more difficult for insurers to deny care to the people who need it the most. These are real important benefits that I cannot dismiss because the plan doesn't fit my political preferences, and I realize most law is made as a result of stinky compromises. That said, the way this plan achieves these goals is incredibly lousy, a result of the need to serve the powerful interests that we allow to dominate policy. I don't see anything about this plan that moves us in the direction we really need to go the way people have been arguing happened with Medicare. We've validated and enhanced the power of private insurance, and this will surely be an obstacle in the future. On the other hand, the high profile of the public option debate brought this possibility into focus in a way that hasn't been seen in a long time. This is a hopeful sign. On the other hand, the low quality of the debate and tightness of the outcome may convince people that this is the best we can do.

In the end, would I have voted for the bill? I don't know, and I'm not sure that's the most important question for us. We need to figure out how to use this as an opportunity to get something better. I think the opportunities are there if we are smart enough and dedicated enough to take advantage of them. Whether we (meaning me) will do that remains to be seen. But it's our choice.

User avatar
New Pagodi
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 4219
Joined: April 18 06, 11:30 pm
Location: St. Louis
Contact:

Re: Rave: Obama Making All the Right Moves

Post by New Pagodi »

Arthur Dent wrote:This is a stinky plan that came about as a compromise between elite interests. I take it for granted that it will need to be fixed. The question for me is both one of policy and one of politics. There are important upsides to the plan. Many more people will get health care. It will be more difficult for insurers to deny care to the people who need it the most. These are real important benefits that I cannot dismiss because the plan doesn't fit my political preferences, and I realize most law is made as a result of stinky compromises. That said, the way this plan achieves these goals is incredibly lousy, a result of the need to serve the powerful interests that we allow to dominate policy. I don't see anything about this plan that moves us in the direction we really need to go the way people have been arguing happened with Medicare. We've validated and enhanced the power of private insurance, and this will surely be an obstacle in the future. On the other hand, the high profile of the public option debate brought this possibility into focus in a way that hasn't been seen in a long time. This is a hopeful sign. On the other hand, the low quality of the debate and tightness of the outcome may convince people that this is the best we can do.

In the end, would I have voted for the bill? I don't know, and I'm not sure that's the most important question for us. We need to figure out how to use this as an opportunity to get something better. I think the opportunities are there if we are smart enough and dedicated enough to take advantage of them. Whether we (meaning me) will do that remains to be seen. But it's our choice.
I think that summarizes my thoughts thoughts pretty well although I may be a little more positive about this bill. One thing to keep in mind is that some kind of public option could be added through a reconciliation bill and so would only need 51 votes in the senate instead of 60.

TimeForGuinness
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 20007
Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm

Re: Rave: Obama Making All the Right Moves

Post by TimeForGuinness »

New Pagodi wrote:
Arthur Dent wrote:This is a stinky plan that came about as a compromise between elite interests. I take it for granted that it will need to be fixed. The question for me is both one of policy and one of politics. There are important upsides to the plan. Many more people will get health care. It will be more difficult for insurers to deny care to the people who need it the most. These are real important benefits that I cannot dismiss because the plan doesn't fit my political preferences, and I realize most law is made as a result of stinky compromises. That said, the way this plan achieves these goals is incredibly lousy, a result of the need to serve the powerful interests that we allow to dominate policy. I don't see anything about this plan that moves us in the direction we really need to go the way people have been arguing happened with Medicare. We've validated and enhanced the power of private insurance, and this will surely be an obstacle in the future. On the other hand, the high profile of the public option debate brought this possibility into focus in a way that hasn't been seen in a long time. This is a hopeful sign. On the other hand, the low quality of the debate and tightness of the outcome may convince people that this is the best we can do.

In the end, would I have voted for the bill? I don't know, and I'm not sure that's the most important question for us. We need to figure out how to use this as an opportunity to get something better. I think the opportunities are there if we are smart enough and dedicated enough to take advantage of them. Whether we (meaning me) will do that remains to be seen. But it's our choice.
I think that summarizes my thoughts thoughts pretty well although I may be a little more positive about this bill. One thing to keep in mind is that some kind of public option could be added through a reconciliation bill and so would only need 51 votes in the senate instead of 60.
Both points are spot on, in my opinion.

Hopefully this is a stepping stone to something better, but I'm doubtful that I'll see that something better in my lifetime.

User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30871
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: Rave: Obama Making All the Right Moves

Post by ghostrunner »

How much likelihood was there for a public option, though? There's a Democratic majority but it's not overwhelming, and it's pretty fragile. Johnson and Roosevelt had huge majorities for their programs, and I think it's fair to say those were much more "socialist" or radical than this one, which isn't. There was more Republican help in those days too, but there's a difference between being a 48% minority that stands to gain a lot by foiling the other party's plans and being a 30% minority that's irrelevant.

User avatar
Joe Shlabotnik
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 24292
Joined: October 12 06, 2:21 pm
Location: Baseball Ref Bullpen
Contact:

Re: Rave: Obama Making All the Right Moves

Post by Joe Shlabotnik »

"With all the punditry, all the lobbying, all the game-playing that passes for governing here in Washington, it's been easy at times to doubt our ability to do such a big thing, such a complicated thing, to wonder if there are limits to what we as a people can still achieve. We are not a nation that scales back its aspirations. We are not a nation that falls prey to doubt or mistrust. We don't fall prey to fear. We are not a nation that does what's easy. That's not who we are. That's not how we got here."
This kind of rhetoric coupled with action. That's the change I voted for. I had my doubts about Barry until last week. Well done Mr. President!

User avatar
cardsfansince82
is shooing asian children away from his fridge.
Posts: 27776
Joined: May 17 06, 10:23 pm
Location: at the gettin' place

Re: Rave: Obama Making All the Right Moves

Post by cardsfansince82 »

Pretty slick, imo.
[SHOW]
Image

User avatar
letsgocards89
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 3654
Joined: April 17 06, 7:35 pm
Location: Too close for missiles, switching to guns

Re: Rave: Obama Making All the Right Moves

Post by letsgocards89 »

Joe Shlabotnik wrote:
"With all the punditry, all the lobbying, all the game-playing that passes for governing here in Washington, it's been easy at times to doubt our ability to do such a big thing, such a complicated thing, to wonder if there are limits to what we as a people can still achieve. We are not a nation that scales back its aspirations. We are not a nation that falls prey to doubt or mistrust. We don't fall prey to fear. We are not a nation that does what's easy. That's not who we are. That's not how we got here."
This kind of rhetoric coupled with action. That's the change I voted for. I had my doubts about Barry until last week. Well done Mr. President!
All that kool-aid is hard on your kidneys.

User avatar
clevername
Bringer of FRBG
Posts: 10380
Joined: April 16 06, 7:13 pm
Location: Alabama

Re: Rave: Obama Making All the Right Moves

Post by clevername »

Joe Shlabotnik wrote:
"With all the punditry, all the lobbying, all the game-playing that passes for governing here in Washington, it's been easy at times to doubt our ability to do such a big thing, such a complicated thing, to wonder if there are limits to what we as a people can still achieve. We are not a nation that scales back its aspirations. We are not a nation that falls prey to doubt or mistrust. We don't fall prey to fear. We are not a nation that does what's easy. That's not who we are. That's not how we got here."
This kind of rhetoric coupled with action. That's the change I voted for. I had my doubts about Barry until last week. Well done Mr. President!
I could get behind that quote without this part: "We are not a nation that scales back its aspirations." It feels like that is exactly what we just saw the democratic party do to itself with what this final bill ended up being.

User avatar
Joe Shlabotnik
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 24292
Joined: October 12 06, 2:21 pm
Location: Baseball Ref Bullpen
Contact:

Re: Rave: Obama Making All the Right Moves

Post by Joe Shlabotnik »

letsgocards89 wrote: All that kool-aid is hard on your kidneys.
:D

AWvsCBsteeeerike3
"I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
Posts: 27578
Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
Location: Thinking of the Children

Re: Rave: Obama Making All the Right Moves

Post by AWvsCBsteeeerike3 »

JackofDiamonds wrote:
AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:
Thanks for the link AD. I'll admit I've avoided politics for the past couple years because my involvement does nothing but cause my bp to rise. After reading that, I'm reminded why I don't follow anything.

Joe/JoD/anyone else....what is it that you all see that makes you happy?
There has been a lot of criticism of this bill, and certainly some of it has been deserved. But be careful of the facts getting in the way of ideas.

The idea that this will cost money assumes that not doing anything doesn't cost money. But the long-term cost savings of this bill are grounded in the fact that doing nothing is in fact a more costly alternative for the average taxpayer than doing something.

Look at the way this bill is paid for. A medicare tax on unearned income, like dividends, for individuals making over $200k per year. An excise tax on Cadillac plans. And a 10% tax on indoor tanning.

If you want to tell me that dividends and indoor tanning are the last refuge of the American workingman, be my guest. But I doubt you'll convince many folks of your point.

We already pay for other people's healthcare in the form of ER visits and other unnecessary acute care. I say unnecessary because such care can often be prevented for less money with preventative care. But preventative care is passed up because people don't have insurance.

The mandate, coupled with a subsidy system, is a way to ensure that the risk pool is even. Health insurance spreads risk. It doesn't work when the healthiest don't buy in and the sickest can't buy in. Furthermore, a healthy person today is one severe accident away from being a very sick person. If they are without insurance, you and I pay for his or her care after the accident. You can call this a question of responsibility, but millions of young people take this gamble every day.

I think part of the problem with healthcare is that it doesn't fit in with our moral conception of "responsibility" very well. Sure, you can be responsible for your own bad (or good) health. But sometimes it's just random. My friend was diagnosed with Diabetes when he was 6. He would be uninsurable in most states, but for this bill, if he had to buy insurance on his own. So, under this construction, this bill allows people like him to do the right and responsible thing by buying health insurance so that he can afford to take care of himself.

For a easy-to-read economic breakdown of the pro-reform side, read here.
Thanks for taking the time to write that. I've read around a little bit more and looked at the bill.

I am pretty conservative, fiscally speaking at least, but I for one would rather have a full out government run health care system than this.

Like you're friend, I'm diabetic. So...I have to get insulin/test strips/syringes etc every month and have become all too familiar with the health care system. And, am of the opinion that the health insurers are nothing better than pedophiles and murderes. It's taken about 5 years of having insurance to realize that's it's about the same price as having none whatsoever and a pain in the ass to boot. Seriously, if you don't have to monthly deal with a doctor-pharmacist-insurance-claim consider yourself lucky. But, having to deal with them, I couldn't be any more disgusted with the entire system really, but mainly the insurance companies.

When I was diagnosed, surprise surprise the premiums just went through the roof to the point my parents could no longer afford to cover me. So, I was without insurance. Luckily, I was introduced to the endocrinolgy staff, sans insurance, at Childrens Hospital in the Lou and worked with the finest staff in America. They, the doctors and entire staff really, taught me so much in 1 month that I've never listened to or paid any heed to another doctor since then. They were amazing. Seriously...one of the lone bright spots. (And 12 years later I'm still in excellent control of my life)

They gave me discounted prices iirc, free insulin, free test strips, free whatever they had around when I went in. I just got on a payment plan and saw them twice a year as opposed to 4 times which they usually require because I was doing so well and didn't have insurance.

Anyway, then I got a job, got insurance and started going to doctors away from Childrens b/c they were so far away. The doctors required every 3 months though the checkups do little other than draw blood and check my vitals. The insulin/strips are cheaper by about half now...which is nice, but co-payments rise every year as does the cost of going to see a doctor (which is about the same with insurance as it was without having to go twice as often). And...all the while, I'm paying for insurance through work. And....all the while, I have to make sure I've jumped through every [expletive] hoop (doctor visit, presciption filled out, correct number of refills, correct dosage, correct dates) before I can get the main benefit insurance offers (lower prescription costs). If one of the hoops hasn't been jumped through...too [expletive] bad for me.

Here's an actual conversation I had with a pharmacist:

Me: Hi blah blah blah I need a refill on prescription # XXXXX
Pharm: Okay, it will be ready in 1 hour.
Me: See ya then.

(1 hour later)

Me: Hi, I'm here to pick up my presciption...
Pharm: Here you go!
Me: This isn't enough (strips). It should be 200, not 25.
Pharm: Well, let's see here, the prescription was entered as "6 times".
Me: No, look, I have the prescription right here (because I carry them with me at all times when I go to the pharmacy because they [expletive] up so often).
*Show them a prescription that read: Up to 6 times or as necessary)*
Pharm: Yeah, we had to interpret that as 6 times per month for insurance reasons.
Me: Okay, well it's obvious what it means (6 times daily) and it has been that way for 2 years now. Don't you think they'll understand?
Pharm: No. They will only pay us for the lower amount.
Me: Okay, well I need them now, when I have the doctor call in and say it's 6 times daily, can I come pick up the other 175 for free?
Pharm: Sure, no problem.

So, that happens and I go to pick up the rest and because of some 'gliche' in insurance policy they wouldn't allow me to do that. So, i had to go the rest of the month paying full price for strips b/c of that.

And these are the thieving bastards we just forced everyone to buy insurance from. They're thieiving bastards and I for one couldn't be more skeptical that they will find ways to bend everyone over. Furthermore, I fully believe they will make more money now than they did before.....and that to me is what makes this bill horrible.

Thieving [expletive] bastards. As I type this i get so pissed I start to shake. These guys are scum of the [expletive] earth and I hope whoever runs the companies and makes it such a pain in the ass rots in hell. [expletive] them.

Post Reply