Update: Health Care Reform

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
TimeForGuinness
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 20007
Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by TimeForGuinness »

BW23 wrote:
Eephus Speed wrote:
BW23 wrote:Public education has been reduced to teaching to the test (and will be forced to do so even more very soon) because the federal government has been corrupted.
ftfy

Just as food, a necessity, can be healthy when it isn't spoiled or loaded with unhealthy ingredients, government can do and has done many wonderful things.

The FDA is a necessity, but it's been corrupted and watered down. That's not a sign that government is bad. It's a sign of bad government. It says we've allowed corporations to dictate policy. It says deregulation and privatization have become the norm.

Schools are having to teach to the test and curricula are being manipulated, because test-making is big business and because it's been determined by some influential folks (e.g. Don McLeroy in Texas) that critical thinking is dangerous. Not because government=bad.
Thanks, but I don't need you to fix anything for me. If NCLB was because of corruption, just wait until you see what the Chicago mob will do. The expansion of government in education will continue. Education is about to get really bad.
What is the Chicago mob going to do?

tscards
Veteran Player
Posts: 1233
Joined: April 20 06, 6:28 pm
Location: Sioux Falls, SD

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by tscards »

another healthcare vote on the way after Republicans found some violations in the bill.....

Now dems are complaining about repubs for obstructing just as repubs complained about dems forcing the bill through with sweetheart side deals.....blah blah blah

All differences aside, at least we all here can agree the Redbirds are the best team ever and we hate all other teams!!!
:D
Last edited by tscards on March 25 10, 8:07 am, edited 2 times in total.

User avatar
BW23
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12896
Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by BW23 »

TimeForGuinness wrote:
BW23 wrote:
Eephus Speed wrote:
BW23 wrote:Public education has been reduced to teaching to the test (and will be forced to do so even more very soon) because the federal government has been corrupted.
ftfy

Just as food, a necessity, can be healthy when it isn't spoiled or loaded with unhealthy ingredients, government can do and has done many wonderful things.

The FDA is a necessity, but it's been corrupted and watered down. That's not a sign that government is bad. It's a sign of bad government. It says we've allowed corporations to dictate policy. It says deregulation and privatization have become the norm.

Schools are having to teach to the test and curricula are being manipulated, because test-making is big business and because it's been determined by some influential folks (e.g. Don McLeroy in Texas) that critical thinking is dangerous. Not because government=bad.
Thanks, but I don't need you to fix anything for me. If NCLB was because of corruption, just wait until you see what the Chicago mob will do. The expansion of government in education will continue. Education is about to get really bad.
What is the Chicago mob going to do?
They've already started it. Race to the Top is going to be the new NCLB. As a superintendent (one of the most Liberal people I've met) I know said recently, "If you've been in education very long, this will scare the *&^% out of you."

One of the more unsettling things is that it won't just be that it won't just be school monies that are tied to test scores but actual teacher pay.

TimeForGuinness
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 20007
Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by TimeForGuinness »

BW23 wrote:
TimeForGuinness wrote:
BW23 wrote:Thanks, but I don't need you to fix anything for me. If NCLB was because of corruption, just wait until you see what the Chicago mob will do. The expansion of government in education will continue. Education is about to get really bad.
What is the Chicago mob going to do?
They've already started it. Race to the Top is going to be the new NCLB. As a superintendent (one of the most Liberal people I've met) I know said recently, "If you've been in education very long, this will scare the *&^% out of you."

One of the more unsettling things is that it won't just be that it won't just be school monies that are tied to test scores but actual teacher pay.
My wife is a public school teacher (ELL teacher), and I'm betting that she would flip a lid to this (as will the unions). Both of our thoughts from NCLB to present day are that teachers aren't able to teach anymore. Public education has been overrun by necessity of high test scores, and that an actual education has been decapitated.

Education is not an assembly line, there are social variables, language barriers, cultural values, and different levels of family involvement that are out of the school system's power. My thoughts are that K-6 grades wouldn't have mandatory testing, they should focus on creativity and learning (wild thought, I know). Let the more established students (grades 7-12) focus on school work and testing.

I also think that by the time you get to 8th grade...your body of work to that point should determine whether you're directed/chosen to attend a college-prep high school, regular high school, military, or a trade school. While I applaud the effort to direct more kids towards a higher education (and I think that everyone should strive for higher education), I've come to realize that the university isn't for everyone and the sooner that kids realize that there are other options (farming, community college, trade, military), the less time will be wasted trying to educate kids that want to strive for different goals.

User avatar
BW23
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12896
Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by BW23 »

TFG....very, very good points. Can I use decapitated? Great word for describing how it's become.

I'm so torn on how education should move, but I'm not against big reform...even what I believe is called competency-based education. I just need to do more research on that.

And you're right...teacher unions and teachers in general will flip a lid. I think you're about to see a mass exodus from public education by some extremely good, seasoned teachers that will likely retire early...not just because of RTTT but budgets as well.

User avatar
Eephus Speed
All-Star
Posts: 1642
Joined: August 28 09, 5:33 pm

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by Eephus Speed »

It does seem like Arne Duncan and Co. are going to expand NCLB. Merit pay for teachers is a horrible idea given the incredible inequity between schools. It's yet another example, along with the lack of a push for single payer health care, of the Obama Administration following the right wing path.

Folks that can't distinguish between bad government and "gov'ment=bad" kinda scare me. It's a pretty simple concept.

Anyway, I've more or less left the teaching profession. In recent years, I've taught at a juvenile detention center on behalf of an alternative school so as to avoid having to deal with testing nonsense. After having taught in South Chicago prior to that. Currently, I'm subbing and debating whether or not I want to work for a nonprofit or find another job in alternative education or go back to school for my PhD. Even the alternative schools, though, as well as what are called democratic schools, are subject to testing requirements.

TimeForGuinness
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 20007
Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by TimeForGuinness »

BW23 wrote:TFG....very, very good points. Can I use decapitated? Great word for describing how it's become.

I'm so torn on how education should move, but I'm not against big reform...even what I believe is called competency-based education. I just need to do more research on that.

And you're right...teacher unions and teachers in general will flip a lid. I think you're about to see a mass exodus from public education by some extremely good, seasoned teachers that will likely retire early...not just because of RTTT but budgets as well.
Competency-based education is very tricky, and would need to be done correctly so that every path is valued equally. I think that its more of a philosophical shift for our society than for the education system. That's tough.

Budgets are scary right now. Many families that can't afford private schools (job losses/housing prices) are moving their kids to the public school system mid-semester. Classroom sizes are swelling and budgets are being cut due to the recession, which leads to additional problems. I'm sure this isn't the first time this has happened, but it isn't fair to the school districts that have to deal with this interruption and increased cost.

My wife, who is an amazing teacher (her reviews back it up), is leaving the teaching world to stay home and raise our 1st child (and hopefully more). I keep telling her that while we didn't plan it to happen, this might be the best opportunity to leave the public school system for awhile.

TimeForGuinness
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 20007
Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by TimeForGuinness »

...and feel free to use decapitated...because apparently they don't want you to use your brain anymore.

User avatar
BW23
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12896
Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by BW23 »

TimeForGuinness wrote:Competency-based education is very tricky, and would need to be done correctly so that every path is valued equally. I think that its more of a philosophical shift for our society than for the education system. That's tough.

Budgets are scary right now. Many families that can't afford private schools (job losses/housing prices) are moving their kids to the public school system mid-semester. Classroom sizes are swelling and budgets are being cut due to the recession, which leads to additional problems. I'm sure this isn't the first time this has happened, but it isn't fair to the school districts that have to deal with this interruption and increased cost.

My wife, who is an amazing teacher (her reviews back it up), is leaving the teaching world to stay home and raise our 1st child (and hopefully more). I keep telling her that while we didn't plan it to happen, this might be the best opportunity to leave the public school system for awhile.
It would be tough, no doubt. And I'm torn on it big time. From a selfish standpoint, I'd like my kids to have something like that. I feel like some programs, at least locally (at the lower grades), are ignoring the top kids to bring up the lower ones. It's also tough when you think about maturity.

I'm also torn because I'm such a proponent of career and technical education, and I think that schools put too much of a focus on preparing kids for "college" when you get to those higher grades when a smaller percentage of kids move on to these "colleges" than those that don't.

Good luck to you and your wife. It might be the best thing for your child, her and even you.

TimeForGuinness
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 20007
Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by TimeForGuinness »

BW23 wrote:
TimeForGuinness wrote:Competency-based education is very tricky, and would need to be done correctly so that every path is valued equally. I think that its more of a philosophical shift for our society than for the education system. That's tough.

Budgets are scary right now. Many families that can't afford private schools (job losses/housing prices) are moving their kids to the public school system mid-semester. Classroom sizes are swelling and budgets are being cut due to the recession, which leads to additional problems. I'm sure this isn't the first time this has happened, but it isn't fair to the school districts that have to deal with this interruption and increased cost.

My wife, who is an amazing teacher (her reviews back it up), is leaving the teaching world to stay home and raise our 1st child (and hopefully more). I keep telling her that while we didn't plan it to happen, this might be the best opportunity to leave the public school system for awhile.
It would be tough, no doubt. And I'm torn on it big time. From a selfish standpoint, I'd like my kids to have something like that. I feel like some programs, at least locally (at the lower grades), are ignoring the top kids to bring up the lower ones. It's also tough when you think about maturity.

I'm also torn because I'm such a proponent of career and technical education, and I think that schools put too much of a focus on preparing kids for "college" when you get to those higher grades when a smaller percentage of kids move on to these "colleges" than those that don't.

Good luck to you and your wife. It might be the best thing for your child, her and even you.
I agree with everything you've said here and thanks for the well wishes. I hope your kids aren't wearing you down on the Nintendo Wii...it's a serious business! :)

Post Reply