Joe Shlabotnik wrote:BW23 wrote:Joe...I had a long response to your quoted parts, but my browser froze. I'll try to get back to it later. Short answer is that nothing you quoted at all went against what I've said.
As for the last line you quoted, I don't think you understand why you quoted that. Private loans aren't the same as the loans private lenders won't be able to do anymore. If you knew that already, and I apologize if so because I don't think that's the case, then I'll need even more explanation as to why that was bolded since I've said that same thing already.
Sorry if I misunderstood you. I had read the last page only and it looked like you're point was basically "its government, its bad." So my post was basically a response to that thesis. The points I was trying to make:
- This will save money. Money they plan or paying for some of the health care changes with. And other they will pay for the Pell Grants with. Unlike other mandates, this one is not unfunded.
- This reorg gets rid of a layer of beaurocracy - in private enterprise it would be hailed as a smart business move. Why isn't it a good move now?
- the servicers are going to be evaluated on their customer service and they are not planning on using overseas help. Sounds like Lou Dobbs and Glenn Beck ought to be all over that.
- These loans will be on better terms and better interest rates than what the private issuers did or could. Sounds like a good deal to me.
- And in fact, I am old enough to have gotten pell grants and low cost loans from the government back in the day. They worked fine for me. And i applaud the effort to get back to them.
If you agree with most or all of this, I apologize for misreading your points. Maybe I wasn't following who quoted who well enough.
I admitted that they'd pay other things off with the money they'd make on this. In fact, I think that's the main thing behind this....the money. And that's my problem with it. I was going to quoted one of the congressmen from one of the linked stories that talked about why they're doing this, but it comes down to the money. It's not about what's best for students.
Yes, it will help fund Pell. The changes to Pell this year created more money being allocated to Pell, but they didn't anticipate the problem the change would bring. Yes, more people are going to school because of the economy. But college graduates that have been laid off don't qualify for Pell if they go back to school. And the fact that some students can double the amount of Pell (from the max of the $5,350) in one year is contributing greatly to the shortfall.
Yes, they'll add customer service. That's what I was talking about when I said they'd have to add many more jobs in Washington and expand the Dept of Ed. I hope it improves. It needs to. But I have a hard time believing that it will be better than what is currently available, particularly in Missouri....unless they set up shop all over the state. That's doubtful.
As for the interest rates....the government caps the rate. Right now, it's 6.8. A private lender can not make a borrower pay back a loan at a higher interest rate than 6.8 on a federal Stafford loan. In fact, most ever private lender and servicer has/had programs to get those interest rates much lower than the 6.8 (or whatever it was that academic year as it changes every July 1). The feds are the ones that don't come down off of that. You're confusing the private loans that was bolded in that article by you with the federal Stafford loans that private lenders issued (as part of the FFEL program). BIG difference, and it's confusing to those outside of the industry I would guess, particularly when they keep referencing it in these articles.
The Pell grant can work very well. I see it work well all the time. I also see students who do their best to abuse it. Schools do, too. But I'm not that upset with how Pell fits into this other than how the foresight wasn't there to see the upcoming shortfall with it.
Thanks for the heads up on adding these. I might have skipped over them after you added them.