Is that what the public option would have been? I was thinking along the lines of a public plan, like an Obama "group" that individuals who needed private insurance could opt for and it could provide competition for the insurance companies and help keep costs down.I have many reservations about the government just outright paying for people's coverage
Update: Health Care Reform
-
Fat Strat
- Official GRB Sponsor of Larry Bigbie
- Posts: 28010
- Joined: April 17 06, 9:16 pm
- Location: No. 16 on the Cards Top 15 Prospect List
Re: Update: Health Care Reform
- JackofDiamonds
- Bringer of Boston Baked Blue Balls
- Posts: 15010
- Joined: April 16 06, 9:15 pm
Re: Update: Health Care Reform
1 - Please cite a few examples. I consider myself politically informed, and I can not remember a scenario like this at all, not in the last 20 years anyway. Besides, the Democrats have never done anything effectively, so that's your first problem.Fat Strat wrote:When you control the House, the Senate, the White House, and the national media (wink wink) you have as big a megaphone as you need.They need a better megaphone.
That was the problem and the Republicans suffered from the same syndrom when they had the power.Knowing the democrats, they'd still be speaking into the wrong end of it.
The only reason Republicans are up in arms about this is because it's an issue they can use to raise havoc against the Dems and gain more seats back -- possibly even the White House. (1) The Dems did the same thing throughout G.W.'s terms, and at times did it just as effectively as the Rep's are now.the Dems out-Republicaned the Republicans.
It's all party politics played in the media by appealing to the public's fears.
That said, though, most of my friends who are republicans and have brains, simply don't think it was a very good bill. I definitely don't. (2) I think a lot of Democrats feel that way as well. In the name of compromise to get something through, the Dems might have legitimately shot off not only their foot, but both legs, too. We'll see how it all plays out, though. A lot of time left between now and 2012.
2 - Current public polling shows that a (slight) majority are in favor of the reform, though 27% wish the bill would have gone further. It depends on who you are reading/listening to as to whether they count those 27% on the oppose or support side of reform.
- ghostrunner
- GOAT
- Posts: 30873
- Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm
Re: Update: Health Care Reform
You're right. I shouldn't have phrased it that way.Fat Strat wrote:Is that what the public option would have been? I was thinking along the lines of a public plan, like an Obama "group" that individuals who needed private insurance could opt for and it could provide competition for the insurance companies and help keep costs down.I have many reservations about the government just outright paying for people's coverage
-
Arthur Dent
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12542
- Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
- Location: Austin
Re: Update: Health Care Reform
There's really absolutely no good reason why not. Insurance companies don't want to compete with a more efficient alternative, and they effectively lobbied to block it, most critically getting TFG's boys the Blue Dogs on board.Fat Strat wrote:Why couldn't there have been a public option, again? And remember, I'm a republican.
Well, that's dumb. Why wouldn't you factor in the tax credits? They're a integral part of the plan.Beginning in 2014, most Americans will be required to buy insurance or pay a tax penalty. That's when premiums for young adults seeking coverage on the individual market would likely climb by 17 percent on average, or roughly $42 a month, according to an analysis of the plan conducted for The Associated Press. The analysis did not factor in tax credits to help offset the increase.
Remember, the whole point of any insurance system (public or private) is to create a mechanism whereby the healthy pay for the sick. As such, it makes sense that younger healthier people should subsidize older sicker people. The bill still allows a age discrimination in premiums of 3 to 1, but at least in terms of fairness I don't know why people of all ages shouldn't share the cost burden equally.At issue is the insurance industry's practice of charging more for older customers, who are the costliest to insure. The new law restricts how much insurers can raise premium costs based on age alone.
Insurers typically charge six or seven times as much to older customers as to younger ones in states with no restrictions. The new law limits the ratio to 3-to-1, meaning a 50-year-old could be charged only three times as much as a 20-year-old.
Last edited by Arthur Dent on March 31 10, 10:54 am, edited 1 time in total.
- BW23
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12896
- Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm
Re: Update: Health Care Reform
ghost...is the max 2.5% or $2,085? Or do you mean yours would be around $2,085?ghostrunner wrote:The other option is to just pay the penalty (I'd call this a contribution to paying for emergency services you might benefit from) and pay outright for major medical services. I think the maximum penalty is 2.5% of income. We're struggling right now, but the maximum penalty is $2085, and I don't see any reason we couldn't afford that (it wouldn't be that high for us though).
-
Arthur Dent
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12542
- Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
- Location: Austin
Re: Update: Health Care Reform
This isn't what the public option is at all. Under the simplest version of it, you would have the option of getting Medicare by paying premiums. The bureaucracy to support it is already in place, and it would not add to the deficit.ghostrunner wrote:I have many reservations about the government just outright paying for people's coverage. Not in principle, but in terms of adding to the budget. Which isn't to say I would mind cutting other things and paying for this - but there isn't the will or votes to do that.
- ghostrunner
- GOAT
- Posts: 30873
- Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm
Re: Update: Health Care Reform
Well, now that I'm looking it up I'm confused. I thought 2085 was the cap, but maybe it's the greater of that OR 2.5%.BW23 wrote:ghost...is the max 2.5% or $2,085? Or do you mean yours would be around $2,085?ghostrunner wrote:The other option is to just pay the penalty (I'd call this a contribution to paying for emergency services you might benefit from) and pay outright for major medical services. I think the maximum penalty is 2.5% of income. We're struggling right now, but the maximum penalty is $2085, and I don't see any reason we couldn't afford that (it wouldn't be that high for us though).
Even so, to pay more than $2085 you'd have to earn about $88000. If you're earning that much I don't see why you couldn't buy health insurance.
- ghostrunner
- GOAT
- Posts: 30873
- Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm
Re: Update: Health Care Reform
I misstated it ( i didn't mean coverage) but any medical treatment covered by the plan would be paid for by the government, wouldn't it?Arthur Dent wrote:This isn't what the public option is at all. Under the simplest version of it, you would have the option of getting Medicare by paying premiums. The bureaucracy to support it is already in place, and it would not add to the deficit.ghostrunner wrote:I have many reservations about the government just outright paying for people's coverage. Not in principle, but in terms of adding to the budget. Which isn't to say I would mind cutting other things and paying for this - but there isn't the will or votes to do that.
-
TimeForGuinness
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 20007
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm
Re: Update: Health Care Reform
I don't remember the vote coming to me, and I wasn't happy with them blockading the public option.Arthur Dent wrote:There's really absolutely no good reason why not. Insurance companies don't want to compete with a more efficient alternative, and they effectively lobbied to block it, most critically getting TFG's boys the Blue Dogs on board.Fat Strat wrote:Why couldn't there have been a public option, again? And remember, I'm a republican.
-
Arthur Dent
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12542
- Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
- Location: Austin
Re: Update: Health Care Reform
Sure. But you'd be paying premiums just like any other insurance policy. You wouldn't need to cut other programs to pay for it.ghostrunner wrote:I misstated it but any medical treatment covered by the plan would be paid for by the government, wouldn't it?Arthur Dent wrote:This isn't what the public option is at all. Under the simplest version of it, you would have the option of getting Medicare by paying premiums. The bureaucracy to support it is already in place, and it would not add to the deficit.ghostrunner wrote:I have many reservations about the government just outright paying for people's coverage. Not in principle, but in terms of adding to the budget. Which isn't to say I would mind cutting other things and paying for this - but there isn't the will or votes to do that.

