Update: Health Care Reform

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
User avatar
BW23
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12896
Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by BW23 »

ghostrunner wrote:
BW23 wrote:
ghostrunner wrote:The other option is to just pay the penalty (I'd call this a contribution to paying for emergency services you might benefit from) and pay outright for major medical services. I think the maximum penalty is 2.5% of income. We're struggling right now, but the maximum penalty is $2085, and I don't see any reason we couldn't afford that (it wouldn't be that high for us though).
ghost...is the max 2.5% or $2,085? Or do you mean yours would be around $2,085?
Well, now that I'm looking it up I'm confused. I thought 2085 was the cap, but maybe it's the greater of that OR 2.5%.

Even so, to pay more than $2085 you'd have to earn about $88000. If you're earning that much I don't see why you couldn't buy health insurance.
My household annual income isn't quite $88,000, but it's probably in the upper 1/4. Right now, I'm the only one of four insured. My wife lost her job a couple of years ago thereby losing good insurance (for her and the kids). We had the kids on a policy that recently expired, and we're shopping now for them.

Adding them to mine would be about $10,000/year. I can't pay that. I won't pay that. And I shouldn't be fined for refusing to overspend on health insurance.

User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30873
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by ghostrunner »

Arthur Dent wrote:
ghostrunner wrote:
Arthur Dent wrote:
ghostrunner wrote:I have many reservations about the government just outright paying for people's coverage. Not in principle, but in terms of adding to the budget. Which isn't to say I would mind cutting other things and paying for this - but there isn't the will or votes to do that.
This isn't what the public option is at all. Under the simplest version of it, you would have the option of getting Medicare by paying premiums. The bureaucracy to support it is already in place, and it would not add to the deficit.
I misstated it but any medical treatment covered by the plan would be paid for by the government, wouldn't it?
Sure. But you'd be paying premiums just like any other insurance policy. You wouldn't need to cut other programs to pay for it.
I don't know the figures well enough, but how certain is it that the premiums would be low enough to be enough to be a decent alternative and high enough to cover the treatment costs that would result?

Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by Arthur Dent »

TimeForGuinness wrote:
Arthur Dent wrote:
Fat Strat wrote:Why couldn't there have been a public option, again? And remember, I'm a republican.
There's really absolutely no good reason why not. Insurance companies don't want to compete with a more efficient alternative, and they effectively lobbied to block it, most critically getting TFG's boys the Blue Dogs on board.
I don't remember the vote coming to me, and I wasn't happy with them blockading the public option.
Just ribbing you. But this is why I don't like the Blue Dogs (the legislators not their voters). This is what they do.

Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by Arthur Dent »

ghostrunner wrote:
Arthur Dent wrote:
ghostrunner wrote:
Arthur Dent wrote:
ghostrunner wrote:I have many reservations about the government just outright paying for people's coverage. Not in principle, but in terms of adding to the budget. Which isn't to say I would mind cutting other things and paying for this - but there isn't the will or votes to do that.
This isn't what the public option is at all. Under the simplest version of it, you would have the option of getting Medicare by paying premiums. The bureaucracy to support it is already in place, and it would not add to the deficit.
I misstated it but any medical treatment covered by the plan would be paid for by the government, wouldn't it?
Sure. But you'd be paying premiums just like any other insurance policy. You wouldn't need to cut other programs to pay for it.
I don't know the figures well enough, but how certain is it that the premiums would be low enough to be enough to be a decent alternative and high enough to cover the treatment costs that would result?
If you didn't feel it was competitive, you wouldn't have to buy it. That's why it's an option. That said, there's every reason to believe it would be. That's the reason the insurance industry was so dead set against it.

TimeForGuinness
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 20007
Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by TimeForGuinness »

Arthur Dent wrote:
TimeForGuinness wrote:
Arthur Dent wrote:
Fat Strat wrote:Why couldn't there have been a public option, again? And remember, I'm a republican.
There's really absolutely no good reason why not. Insurance companies don't want to compete with a more efficient alternative, and they effectively lobbied to block it, most critically getting TFG's boys the Blue Dogs on board.
I don't remember the vote coming to me, and I wasn't happy with them blockading the public option.
Just ribbing you. But this is why I don't like the Blue Dogs (the legislators not their voters). This is what they do.
I can see that...their viewpoints looked good to me originally...but they haven't won me over yet. Trying to find a party/group that is fiscally efficient (I'll refrain from using the word conservative because efficiency is a better word) and socially liberal.

But then again, Obama just opened up off-shore drilling, so who really knows which party is which these days.

User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30873
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by ghostrunner »

BW23 wrote:
ghostrunner wrote:
BW23 wrote:
ghostrunner wrote:The other option is to just pay the penalty (I'd call this a contribution to paying for emergency services you might benefit from) and pay outright for major medical services. I think the maximum penalty is 2.5% of income. We're struggling right now, but the maximum penalty is $2085, and I don't see any reason we couldn't afford that (it wouldn't be that high for us though).
ghost...is the max 2.5% or $2,085? Or do you mean yours would be around $2,085?
Well, now that I'm looking it up I'm confused. I thought 2085 was the cap, but maybe it's the greater of that OR 2.5%.

Even so, to pay more than $2085 you'd have to earn about $88000. If you're earning that much I don't see why you couldn't buy health insurance.
My household annual income isn't quite $88,000, but it's probably in the upper 1/4. Right now, I'm the only one of four insured. My wife lost her job a couple of years ago thereby losing good insurance (for her and the kids). We had the kids on a policy that recently expired, and we're shopping now for them.

Adding them to mine would be about $10,000/year. I can't pay that. I won't pay that. And I shouldn't be fined for refusing to overspend on health insurance.
The way I see it, it's a fine for not having any way to cover emergency costs should you need them. You may be able to pay them, but the government has no idea if that's the case and to me it's a sensible way to help make sure those costs are covered. I'm not sure if that's the thinking behind it, but that's how I view it.

User avatar
BW23
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12896
Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by BW23 »

Arthur Dent wrote:
ghostrunner wrote:
Arthur Dent wrote:
ghostrunner wrote:
Arthur Dent wrote:
ghostrunner wrote:I have many reservations about the government just outright paying for people's coverage. Not in principle, but in terms of adding to the budget. Which isn't to say I would mind cutting other things and paying for this - but there isn't the will or votes to do that.
This isn't what the public option is at all. Under the simplest version of it, you would have the option of getting Medicare by paying premiums. The bureaucracy to support it is already in place, and it would not add to the deficit.
I misstated it but any medical treatment covered by the plan would be paid for by the government, wouldn't it?
Sure. But you'd be paying premiums just like any other insurance policy. You wouldn't need to cut other programs to pay for it.
I don't know the figures well enough, but how certain is it that the premiums would be low enough to be enough to be a decent alternative and high enough to cover the treatment costs that would result?
If you didn't feel it was competitive, you wouldn't have to buy it. That's why it's an option. That said, there's every reason to believe it would be. That's the reason the insurance industry was so dead set against it.

AD...since you've set up shot as the resident expert on this, let me ask you this. My feeling, which is completely uninformed, is that little has been done to curb insurance prices with the insurance companies. There's hope that with more getting insurance that the cost for consumers down, but I have my doubts.

Was there anything required of the insurance companies that will drive prices down? I don't consider them the only evil in all of this by any means, but they certainly play a key role in that.

User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30873
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by ghostrunner »

Arthur Dent wrote:
ghostrunner wrote:
Arthur Dent wrote:
ghostrunner wrote:
Arthur Dent wrote:
ghostrunner wrote:I have many reservations about the government just outright paying for people's coverage. Not in principle, but in terms of adding to the budget. Which isn't to say I would mind cutting other things and paying for this - but there isn't the will or votes to do that.
This isn't what the public option is at all. Under the simplest version of it, you would have the option of getting Medicare by paying premiums. The bureaucracy to support it is already in place, and it would not add to the deficit.
I misstated it but any medical treatment covered by the plan would be paid for by the government, wouldn't it?
Sure. But you'd be paying premiums just like any other insurance policy. You wouldn't need to cut other programs to pay for it.
I don't know the figures well enough, but how certain is it that the premiums would be low enough to be enough to be a decent alternative and high enough to cover the treatment costs that would result?
If you didn't feel it was competitive, you wouldn't have to buy it. That's why it's an option. That said, there's every reason to believe it would be. That's the reason the insurance industry was so dead set against it.
I don't mean for me. I mean in general. How does the math work out in terms of what all people would be paying in, and what the government would be paying for all services? That's what my concern is.

Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by Arthur Dent »

BW23 wrote:My household annual income isn't quite $88,000, but it's probably in the upper 1/4. Right now, I'm the only one of four insured. My wife lost her job a couple of years ago thereby losing good insurance (for her and the kids). We had the kids on a policy that recently expired, and we're shopping now for them.

Adding them to mine would be about $10,000/year. I can't pay that. I won't pay that. And I shouldn't be fined for refusing to overspend on health insurance.
The bill also caps how much you can be charged for insurance based on your income on a sliding scale but at 9.5% at 400% of the federal poverty level (currently $88,000 for a family of 4).

User avatar
BW23
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12896
Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by BW23 »

Per person or family?

Post Reply