JaMarcus Russell

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Online
User avatar
Leroy
a bad penny always turns up
Posts: 25229
Joined: April 17 06, 12:27 pm
Location: Hanging out with my redneck, white socks and Blue Ribbon beer.
Contact:

Re: JaMarcus Russell

Post by Leroy »

I'm glad for JaMarcus though as well. He can now be free to go on his quest of being a champion sumo wrestler.

User avatar
Lesson
Grandmaster Flashchat
Posts: 6630
Joined: February 4 10, 4:35 pm

Re: JaMarcus Russell

Post by Lesson »

StL Dan wrote:
cardslesson101 wrote:
StL Dan wrote:
cardslesson101 wrote:
Michael wrote:I wouldn't give back a dime.

:D True, he probably won't but when a team invests that much into you and you don't even last your full contract as well as not leading your team to a winning season, you should pay back every cent. Once the salary cap is back in place, it may financially cripple(if that offends anyone, I apologize in advance) for a few years.
Russell worked his rear end off to put himself into the position to be rewarded with #1 draft pick. So, he got bonused. BONUSED. He already earned that bonus by virtue of being the #1 pick.

If there is something he didn't "earn", it was the opportunity to sign an extension, much less earn the opportunity to play out his current contract.

So, they dumped him. Both sides are square.
You may be right about him playing his tail off to be in that position but he played at a very good football school with talent already in place. There are the Ricky Williams, Ryan Leaf's of the world when they could absolutely destroy your franchise when they don't perform or act at all like a #1 Overall pick should. If I was in the Raiders position in 2007, I would have absolutely taken Russell to be the 1st Overall pick. But when you weigh 300 pounds and don't perform at an all pro level for the amount of money he was payed for, you don't deserve that contract. In fact, I'd rather see the rest of Russell's contract go to charity or a portion of the money Russell earned go to charity. Look at Charles Rogers, the Lions were able to sue and get the bonus money back.
I think you are confused about why players get "bonus" money and "contract" money. They are paid for two different reasons.

Bonus money is automatic for any player chosen in the first round. It's not paid for services performed or to be performed. It's paid simply because of their high draft position.

Contract dollars are paid for performance on the field. To that extent, Jamarcus got what he "deserved" for being a #1 overall pick and, conversely, was fired by Oakland and will no longer be compensated for services performed. Contract terminated.

RE: Charles Rogers. Weren't there extentuating circumstances in that situation that allowed the Lions to get back some of his bonus unrelated to performance on the field?

True about Rogers, he had drug related problems. But, for some reason, I think Russell's contract is still in effect but not worth as much, so it is dead money.

User avatar
StL Dan
banned
Posts: 8159
Joined: June 14 06, 9:40 pm
Location: St. Louis in spirit

Re: JaMarcus Russell

Post by StL Dan »

cardslesson101 wrote:
StL Dan wrote:
cardslesson101 wrote:
StL Dan wrote:
cardslesson101 wrote:
Michael wrote:I wouldn't give back a dime.

:D True, he probably won't but when a team invests that much into you and you don't even last your full contract as well as not leading your team to a winning season, you should pay back every cent. Once the salary cap is back in place, it may financially cripple(if that offends anyone, I apologize in advance) for a few years.
Russell worked his rear end off to put himself into the position to be rewarded with #1 draft pick. So, he got bonused. BONUSED. He already earned that bonus by virtue of being the #1 pick.

If there is something he didn't "earn", it was the opportunity to sign an extension, much less earn the opportunity to play out his current contract.

So, they dumped him. Both sides are square.
You may be right about him playing his tail off to be in that position but he played at a very good football school with talent already in place. There are the Ricky Williams, Ryan Leaf's of the world when they could absolutely destroy your franchise when they don't perform or act at all like a #1 Overall pick should. If I was in the Raiders position in 2007, I would have absolutely taken Russell to be the 1st Overall pick. But when you weigh 300 pounds and don't perform at an all pro level for the amount of money he was payed for, you don't deserve that contract. In fact, I'd rather see the rest of Russell's contract go to charity or a portion of the money Russell earned go to charity. Look at Charles Rogers, the Lions were able to sue and get the bonus money back.
I think you are confused about why players get "bonus" money and "contract" money. They are paid for two different reasons.

Bonus money is automatic for any player chosen in the first round. It's not paid for services performed or to be performed. It's paid simply because of their high draft position.

Contract dollars are paid for performance on the field. To that extent, Jamarcus got what he "deserved" for being a #1 overall pick and, conversely, was fired by Oakland and will no longer be compensated for services performed. Contract terminated.

RE: Charles Rogers. Weren't there extentuating circumstances in that situation that allowed the Lions to get back some of his bonus unrelated to performance on the field?

True about Rogers, he had drug related problems. But, for some reason, I think Russell's contract is still in effect but not worth as much, so it is dead money.
read my edit above....Rogers defaulted on his contract because of narcotics abuse. Russell, to my knowledge, merely sucked. That isn't a crime. The only crime here is Oakland's gross inability to draft the best available talent in the NFL draft, then reward a sub par player with an ungodly amount of cash.

User avatar
Lesson
Grandmaster Flashchat
Posts: 6630
Joined: February 4 10, 4:35 pm

Re: JaMarcus Russell

Post by Lesson »

StL Dan wrote:
cardslesson101 wrote:
StL Dan wrote:
cardslesson101 wrote:
StL Dan wrote:
cardslesson101 wrote:
Michael wrote:I wouldn't give back a dime.

:D True, he probably won't but when a team invests that much into you and you don't even last your full contract as well as not leading your team to a winning season, you should pay back every cent. Once the salary cap is back in place, it may financially cripple(if that offends anyone, I apologize in advance) for a few years.
Russell worked his rear end off to put himself into the position to be rewarded with #1 draft pick. So, he got bonused. BONUSED. He already earned that bonus by virtue of being the #1 pick.

If there is something he didn't "earn", it was the opportunity to sign an extension, much less earn the opportunity to play out his current contract.

So, they dumped him. Both sides are square.
You may be right about him playing his tail off to be in that position but he played at a very good football school with talent already in place. There are the Ricky Williams, Ryan Leaf's of the world when they could absolutely destroy your franchise when they don't perform or act at all like a #1 Overall pick should. If I was in the Raiders position in 2007, I would have absolutely taken Russell to be the 1st Overall pick. But when you weigh 300 pounds and don't perform at an all pro level for the amount of money he was payed for, you don't deserve that contract. In fact, I'd rather see the rest of Russell's contract go to charity or a portion of the money Russell earned go to charity. Look at Charles Rogers, the Lions were able to sue and get the bonus money back.
I think you are confused about why players get "bonus" money and "contract" money. They are paid for two different reasons.

Bonus money is automatic for any player chosen in the first round. It's not paid for services performed or to be performed. It's paid simply because of their high draft position.

Contract dollars are paid for performance on the field. To that extent, Jamarcus got what he "deserved" for being a #1 overall pick and, conversely, was fired by Oakland and will no longer be compensated for services performed. Contract terminated.

RE: Charles Rogers. Weren't there extentuating circumstances in that situation that allowed the Lions to get back some of his bonus unrelated to performance on the field?

True about Rogers, he had drug related problems. But, for some reason, I think Russell's contract is still in effect but not worth as much, so it is dead money.
read my edit above....Rogers defaulted on his contract because of narcotics abuse. Russell, to my knowledge, merely sucked. That isn't a crime. The only crime here is Oakland's gross inability to draft the best available talent in the NFL draft, then reward a sub par player with an ungodly amount of cash.

True, but my point is when you play that badly and you are guaranteed that much money, there is no reason that you shouldn't give back the community or the team.

User avatar
InvincibleCakeEater
GRB's obsessive compulsive baseball poster
Posts: 28275
Joined: October 12 07, 12:28 pm
Location: Raptured

Re: JaMarcus Russell

Post by InvincibleCakeEater »

cardslesson101 wrote: True, but my point is when you play that badly and you are guaranteed that much money, there is no reason that you shouldn't give back the community or the team.
Image

User avatar
StL Dan
banned
Posts: 8159
Joined: June 14 06, 9:40 pm
Location: St. Louis in spirit

Re: JaMarcus Russell

Post by StL Dan »

cardslesson101 wrote:
StL Dan wrote:
cardslesson101 wrote:
StL Dan wrote:
cardslesson101 wrote:
StL Dan wrote:
cardslesson101 wrote:
Michael wrote:I wouldn't give back a dime.

:D True, he probably won't but when a team invests that much into you and you don't even last your full contract as well as not leading your team to a winning season, you should pay back every cent. Once the salary cap is back in place, it may financially cripple(if that offends anyone, I apologize in advance) for a few years.
Russell worked his rear end off to put himself into the position to be rewarded with #1 draft pick. So, he got bonused. BONUSED. He already earned that bonus by virtue of being the #1 pick.

If there is something he didn't "earn", it was the opportunity to sign an extension, much less earn the opportunity to play out his current contract.

So, they dumped him. Both sides are square.
You may be right about him playing his tail off to be in that position but he played at a very good football school with talent already in place. There are the Ricky Williams, Ryan Leaf's of the world when they could absolutely destroy your franchise when they don't perform or act at all like a #1 Overall pick should. If I was in the Raiders position in 2007, I would have absolutely taken Russell to be the 1st Overall pick. But when you weigh 300 pounds and don't perform at an all pro level for the amount of money he was payed for, you don't deserve that contract. In fact, I'd rather see the rest of Russell's contract go to charity or a portion of the money Russell earned go to charity. Look at Charles Rogers, the Lions were able to sue and get the bonus money back.
I think you are confused about why players get "bonus" money and "contract" money. They are paid for two different reasons.

Bonus money is automatic for any player chosen in the first round. It's not paid for services performed or to be performed. It's paid simply because of their high draft position.

Contract dollars are paid for performance on the field. To that extent, Jamarcus got what he "deserved" for being a #1 overall pick and, conversely, was fired by Oakland and will no longer be compensated for services performed. Contract terminated.

RE: Charles Rogers. Weren't there extentuating circumstances in that situation that allowed the Lions to get back some of his bonus unrelated to performance on the field?

True about Rogers, he had drug related problems. But, for some reason, I think Russell's contract is still in effect but not worth as much, so it is dead money.
read my edit above....Rogers defaulted on his contract because of narcotics abuse. Russell, to my knowledge, merely sucked. That isn't a crime. The only crime here is Oakland's gross inability to draft the best available talent in the NFL draft, then reward a sub par player with an ungodly amount of cash.

True, but my point is when you play that badly and you are guaranteed that much money, there is no reason that you shouldn't give back the community or the team.
What is the point of calling it "guaranteed" money if the possibility existed that one would want to take all or or a portion of it back? It would no longer be called "guaranteed" if it were given back, no?

User avatar
Lesson
Grandmaster Flashchat
Posts: 6630
Joined: February 4 10, 4:35 pm

Re: JaMarcus Russell

Post by Lesson »

StL Dan wrote:
cardslesson101 wrote:
StL Dan wrote:
cardslesson101 wrote:
StL Dan wrote:
cardslesson101 wrote:
StL Dan wrote:
cardslesson101 wrote:
Michael wrote:I wouldn't give back a dime.

:D True, he probably won't but when a team invests that much into you and you don't even last your full contract as well as not leading your team to a winning season, you should pay back every cent. Once the salary cap is back in place, it may financially cripple(if that offends anyone, I apologize in advance) for a few years.
Russell worked his rear end off to put himself into the position to be rewarded with #1 draft pick. So, he got bonused. BONUSED. He already earned that bonus by virtue of being the #1 pick.

If there is something he didn't "earn", it was the opportunity to sign an extension, much less earn the opportunity to play out his current contract.

So, they dumped him. Both sides are square.
You may be right about him playing his tail off to be in that position but he played at a very good football school with talent already in place. There are the Ricky Williams, Ryan Leaf's of the world when they could absolutely destroy your franchise when they don't perform or act at all like a #1 Overall pick should. If I was in the Raiders position in 2007, I would have absolutely taken Russell to be the 1st Overall pick. But when you weigh 300 pounds and don't perform at an all pro level for the amount of money he was payed for, you don't deserve that contract. In fact, I'd rather see the rest of Russell's contract go to charity or a portion of the money Russell earned go to charity. Look at Charles Rogers, the Lions were able to sue and get the bonus money back.
I think you are confused about why players get "bonus" money and "contract" money. They are paid for two different reasons.

Bonus money is automatic for any player chosen in the first round. It's not paid for services performed or to be performed. It's paid simply because of their high draft position.

Contract dollars are paid for performance on the field. To that extent, Jamarcus got what he "deserved" for being a #1 overall pick and, conversely, was fired by Oakland and will no longer be compensated for services performed. Contract terminated.

RE: Charles Rogers. Weren't there extentuating circumstances in that situation that allowed the Lions to get back some of his bonus unrelated to performance on the field?

True about Rogers, he had drug related problems. But, for some reason, I think Russell's contract is still in effect but not worth as much, so it is dead money.
read my edit above....Rogers defaulted on his contract because of narcotics abuse. Russell, to my knowledge, merely sucked. That isn't a crime. The only crime here is Oakland's gross inability to draft the best available talent in the NFL draft, then reward a sub par player with an ungodly amount of cash.

True, but my point is when you play that badly and you are guaranteed that much money, there is no reason that you shouldn't give back the community or the team.
What is the point of one giving "guaranteed" money if the possibility existed that one would want to take all or or a portion of it back?
You're right, the Raiders paid him and he *earned* the guaranteed money. But in a perfect world, some of that money should be used on other things.

User avatar
G. Keenan
Sucking on the Rally Nipple
Posts: 23719
Joined: April 16 06, 6:03 pm
Location: Chicago

Re: JaMarcus Russell

Post by G. Keenan »

I have no sympathy for billionaires, as a rule. Russell doesn't owe the Raider's squat. He did very well at football for the first 20 something years of his life and then got a big payday. Just because he's good at football doesn't mean he loves it, or that it's his passion. If I was doing a job that I only sort of liked and my employer gave me $31 million there is no way I'd be doing it much longer.

User avatar
Lesson
Grandmaster Flashchat
Posts: 6630
Joined: February 4 10, 4:35 pm

Re: JaMarcus Russell

Post by Lesson »

G. Keenan wrote:I have no sympathy for billionaires, as a rule. Russell doesn't owe the Raider's squat. He did very well at football for the first 20 something years of his life and then got a big payday. Just because he's good at football doesn't mean he loves it, or that it's his passion. If I was doing a job that I only sort of liked and my employer gave me $31 million there is no way I'd be doing it much longer.

He could have at least shown some passion. Look at Sam Bradford, if he gets paid $45 million in guaranteed money and performs well and shows passion, I will be perfectly fine with him making that much.

User avatar
Hungary Jack
Mother Earth
Posts: 19536
Joined: July 24 06, 6:03 am
Location: In Cognito

Re: JaMarcus Russell

Post by Hungary Jack »

Leroy wrote:I'm glad for JaMarcus though as well. He can now be free to go on his quest of being a champion sumo wrestler.
I was thinking MMA.

Post Reply