lukethedrifter wrote:The kid said he got a text from his Mom during math class. Then he said he excused himself to call her.
I'm sure he's a good kid and a fine student. I think it's a bad idea and likely disrespectful to the teacher.
I need more context here. I would never text my kid unless it was an emergency. I'm getting the impression it could have been since the kid excused himself to make the call.
If it's not an emergency, I wouldn't fully blame the kid since it's the parent who is teaching the kid that the teacher doesn't deserve respect and the parent who is demonstrating that an education is not important.
haltz wrote:The positive is that you can get ahold of someone. My friends and I had pagers and we had codes we'd send each other that you had to decrypt. I had to call my parents and say "pickmeup" as the name on the collect call when I was done with basketball practice. If it was important my mom would leave a message with the receptionist. Having text capable phones wouldve been awesome. Just don't abuse the privelege in class.
If you need to get in touch with your kid, call the office. My kid, like most, take their phone with them to school every day and use it to call me after practice or school. Works great, I love it. But from 7:30 to 2:45, it doesn't work because it's in his locker. If I need to get in touch with him, I call the office. No problem, because I can't ever remember one time needing to do that, but I can if I need to.
I have yet to here one even remotely beneficial thing. I think the "what's the big deal" attitude is a symptom. But it's easier to just call someone not progressive etc...
jim wrote:Schools job is to the best of it's ability provide an environment for learning. Our district (ranked 39th out of 842 in Illinois for standardized test scores), decided to just get rid of the distration as best as possible. I know the next town over has the same policy, and it too is a very high achieving districts.
What's the big deal?
I agree to an extent. I'm with Haltz if I ever meet a lady dumb enough to procreate with me, I'd want my kids to have a cell phone once they are 15 or 16 if they were driving any sort of distance to school, there's no reason for it not to stay in the car, however.
I don't have a problem with schools banning them and understand the measure. But I wouldn't blame phones for poor attention spans in class rooms, I'd rather have a bored/poor/bully student messing around on his iPhone on silent than throwin paper balls and shooting spitwads.
BW23 wrote:So, your kid has one, and he uses it to call you which you like. I guess the whole "some schools don't have lockers" doesn't matter????
We have lockers at the HS and MS, where the texting problems happen the most, so it's not an issue for us. But yes, if you have no lockers then it's a completely different story.
Many schools are doing away with lockers. I don't think you have a choice at that point.
My local high school has approximately 1100 students. They might have 1 or 2 violations a day. That pales in comparison to other discipline issues.
I don't have a big problem with it because it's part of the student. It's what they do...what they know. I think schools need to look ahead at possible ways to utilize mobile devices for learning purposes. Too often, we try to teach kids the same way we were taught. And that's usually not a good thing.
jim wrote:I have yet to here one even remotely beneficial thing. I think the "what's the big deal" attitude is a symptom. But it's easier to just call someone not progressive etc...
I was just tryin to call Haltz a hippie...wasn't a knock on you.
I disagree with your sentiment that 'what's the big deal' is part of the problem, because I don't see cell phones as the problem. The people who are easily distracted and going to be distracted by a phone are going to be distracted and not pay attention one way or the other. So the kids that can have them to call for rides/in case of a car accident or a change of plans is worth it IMO.
I think we agree then. No reason to have them out during class or the schoolday (lunch and study hall wouldn't bother me), but it's good for kids to have them on the premises. If it's on silent there's nothing stopping someone from having it in their pocket instead of their locker -- just don't get caught using it at the wrong time.
haltz wrote:I think we agree then. No reason to have them out during class or the schoolday (lunch and study hall wouldn't bother me), but it's good for kids to have them on the premises. If it's on silent there's nothing stopping someone from having it in their pocket instead of their locker -- just don't get caught using it at the wrong time.
I guess so, except I say there is absolutely no reason to have them in class at all - even if off (especially if off, because what good is it?) - when there are secure places to store it through the day (i.e. school lockers). The no school locker fad hasn't hit our area, I've never heard of it at the MS or HS level until this conversation.
Repeating myself. Sounds like it's completely out of control. If nearly half of teens with phones in school text during class every day, tolerance is way too high.
Arthur Dent wrote:How can you send 3000 texts a month if you don't write some of them during class?
* 12% of all students say they can have their phone at school at any time.
* 62% of all students say they can have their phone in school, just not in class.
* 24% of teens attend schools that ban all cell phones from school grounds. * Still, 65% of cell-owning teens at schools that completely ban phones bring their phones to school every day.
* 58% of cell-owning teens at schools that ban phones have sent a text message during class.
* 43% of all teens who take their phones to school say they text in class at least once a day or more.
* 64% of teens with cell phones have texted in class; 25% have made or received a call during class time.