Arthur Dent wrote:There's nothing ambiguous or misleading about it. What you said doesn't contest those numbers at all. You're just trying to argue that though you're sending texts during class, it's ok that you do so. And are you really trying to argue that the 43% of teens with phones who text in class everyday are just sending responses to remind people that they are in class five days a week?
You're right, poor choice of words -- I'm not contesting the numbers, I'm contesting the significance of them. I'm also contesting the logic behind lumping the 3000-texts-a-month club in with people who are sending two or three texts through the course of the day into the same group. Yes, that is misleading. Or at the very least, disingenuous. For the latter group, the effect is almost certainly negligible. Or if nothing else, it's insignificant relative to the effect the other group feels.
How about this: let's say we hypothesized that employees working "desk jobs" were less productive if they abused their internet access and used it for non-work-related purposes. That's something that would be tough to argue. But where do you draw the line? Where is it actually going to start showing a tangible effect?
When I started my job (I do web development, so I write code and thus am in an office environment), my boss explicitly told me, "you know, if you wander a little bit and check your personal email or whatever now and then, we don't have a problem. It's when they're spending 30 minutes reading Slashdot articles that it becomes an issue." If he wanted to gauge how out-of-control recreational internet usage was and conducted a poll (promising anonymity), he's not going to ask, "do you use the internet for recreational use on a daily basis?" He's going to ask something with substance to it, like, "how many minutes a day would you estimate you use the internet for personal use?" That first question -- similar to those those bolded statistics -- encompasses so much that you make whatever you want of it.
Jim wrote:I think you are better off just turning it off and giving full attention in class - especially HS. I worry about comments like "incredibly harmless" etc., because I don't think it is harmless but I can see how you can be kind of tricked into thinking of it as harmless. I think the best policy is just to concentrate on the lecture 100%.
I agree completely that concentrating 100% is the best strategy. Unfortunately, life is not as simple as saying, "I'm going to go to class today and give me undivided attention for seven hours." Even if you genuinely go in with that mindset, your brain is probably going to wander and you're going to shift your focus to something else. Maybe it's on the view outside your classroom window. Maybe it's on your cell phone. Maybe it's on the picture you're drawing on the margins of your paper. Maybe it's on the sexual fantasy you're concocting in your head. We can scapegoat those objects/scenarios all we want, but they're a non-issue unless they have a wandering mind to make use of them in the first place. If you strip people of cell phones, the other things don't suddenly become a non-issue.
And for the record, I think texting in class is an incredibly rude thing to do. I can't believe some people have the audacity to just whip our their phone in broad daylight and text incessantly throughout a class period. I had least made an effort to do it covertly, and tried to do it when the teacher was facing the board or something.
I don't know. I'm curious as to what the other college-attending minds think; I would think if anything, texting in class during college would be worse than high school, because there are less restrictions and it would be easier to abuse the freedom. But honestly, in my experiences classmates that text to the point that it's a major distraction to them are very few and very far between. As in, maybe one or two people in your typical class of 25. Otherwise though, it's at a very casual pace, and no more distracting than any of those other things I listed.