Rant- ACT and scores of that ilk.

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
User avatar
Maclowery
Child Pot Activist
Posts: 7742
Joined: June 15 06, 7:27 am
Location: NYC

Re: Rant- ACT and scores of that ilk.

Post by Maclowery »

Clearly we are all geniuses. But we are all misunderstood geniuses. What makes us misunderstood is that no one out there thinks were are geniuses.*


*All credit to Bill Watterson for my all-time favorite C+H panel.

User avatar
Cronos
In perpetuum
Posts: 34778
Joined: June 30 06, 7:49 am
Location: St. Louis

Re: Rant- ACT and scores of that ilk.

Post by Cronos »

I don't know too much about ACT or SAT scores and their accuracy, but after working in the field training in diagnostic testing (mainly with IQ tests) over the last year I can tell you that a lot of IQ testing is bunk. Anything less than an official IQ test is completely inaccurate, and even the "official" ones have severe limits and problems like practice effects, scores naturally rising in the population every 10 years, and far too much emphasis placed on one testing session. Also, most all IQ testing is grounded foremost in school-based knowledge.

Didn't know that Catherine the Great was the empress of Russia in the 18th century? You just lost a scaled score point or two of IQ.

Besides, as you probably know, one test in one testing session in any one day could be subject to all kinds of extraneous effects: how awake you are, how focused you are and how much attention you're paying to the questions, whether you're hungry, in pain or sick or something, etc. Also: there's a lot of debate in the community right now as to whether IQ can even be measured. A single IQ score is only used because it gives our educational system (and the insurance system) a cutoff point for various degrees of treatment or need-based financial allotment. IQ, IMO, cannot be measured by a single number as intelligence is best described in a number of different areas beyond just fluid and crystallized intelligence.

If anyone's thinking about getting their IQ tested anytime after you've passed high school, don't bother with it. It's not useful, and odds are you won't be happy with what you get no matter how high or low it happens to be. For those younger has all sorts of good and useful purposes, like figuring out special placement in order to help the kid learn in the best environment possible for them: determine giftedness/delay/disability/learning disability, etc.

User avatar
lukethedrifter
darjeeling sipping elite
Posts: 37260
Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
Location: Huis Clos

Re: Rant- ACT and scores of that ilk.

Post by lukethedrifter »

I thought I'd read that universities were de-emphasizing their reliance on SAT/ACT scores over the last few years.

User avatar
longhornbaseball
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 5527
Joined: April 18 06, 10:37 pm

Re: Rant- ACT and scores of that ilk.

Post by longhornbaseball »

JL21 wrote:But I encourage its use because I compensated for mediocre grades in HS with a very good ACT score.
Its like a get out of jail free card for smart, lazy people.

User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: Rant- ACT and scores of that ilk.

Post by vinsanity »

Cronos69 wrote:Also, most all IQ testing is grounded foremost in school-based knowledge.
...
IQ, IMO, cannot be measured by a single number as intelligence is best described in a number of different areas beyond just fluid and crystallized intelligence.
I'm pretty sure the IQ test I took (granted 15 years ago), and the idea behind them, are entirely based on your ability to reason, deduce and identify patterns. Basing IQ on school-based knowledge seems completely against the idea of 'IQ' anyway - though I suppose it could be different because...

IQ was a 'made' up thing used to try and quantify intelligence. It's kind of like 20-80 scale we use for baseball prospects. It stands for Intelligence Quotient - The numbers are the ratio of your mental 'age' to your physical age. I believe if you have an IQ of 200, it would mean you 'know' twice as much as the average person. So I suppose for an adult, certain amounts of 'school' knowledge are expected.

There are some basic assumptions as to what 'average' is for each age. So you can in theory be really quick to learn as a kid and everyone can catch up if you taper off.

Even the guys who developed this stuff pretty much agreed with your assertion that a lot goes in to 'true' intelligence, they were just trying to find a way to measure and scale people based on how well they learn and reason.

User avatar
Cronos
In perpetuum
Posts: 34778
Joined: June 30 06, 7:49 am
Location: St. Louis

Re: Rant- ACT and scores of that ilk.

Post by Cronos »

vinsanity wrote:
Cronos69 wrote:Also, most all IQ testing is grounded foremost in school-based knowledge.
...
IQ, IMO, cannot be measured by a single number as intelligence is best described in a number of different areas beyond just fluid and crystallized intelligence.
I'm pretty sure the IQ test I took (granted 15 years ago), and the idea behind them, are entirely based on your ability to reason, deduce and identify patterns. Basing IQ on school-based knowledge seems completely against the idea of 'IQ' anyway
Most of the popular "Intelligence" tests rely a lot on school-based knowledge, including the entire Wechsler system of tests. The Stanford-Binet system uses more of what you're talking about, and in general I like that set of intelligence tests better.
IQ was a 'made' up thing used to try and quantify intelligence. It's kind of like 20-80 scale we use for baseball prospects. It stands for Intelligence Quotient - The numbers are the ratio of your mental 'age' to your physical age. I believe if you have an IQ of 200, it would mean you 'know' twice as much as the average person. So I suppose for an adult, certain amounts of 'school' knowledge are expected.

There are some basic assumptions as to what 'average' is for each age. So you can in theory be really quick to learn as a kid and everyone can catch up if you taper off.
Well, intelligence in the population lies on a normal curve; unless you're dealing with kids, an average for each age isn't really helpful. There are different scoring norms for different age groups, sure, but the average intelligence is 100, and most everyone is within a standard deviation of that (80-120).

User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: Rant- ACT and scores of that ilk.

Post by vinsanity »

Cronos69 wrote:
IQ was a 'made' up thing used to try and quantify intelligence. It's kind of like 20-80 scale we use for baseball prospects. It stands for Intelligence Quotient - The numbers are the ratio of your mental 'age' to your physical age. I believe if you have an IQ of 200, it would mean you 'know' twice as much as the average person. So I suppose for an adult, certain amounts of 'school' knowledge are expected.

There are some basic assumptions as to what 'average' is for each age. So you can in theory be really quick to learn as a kid and everyone can catch up if you taper off.
Well, intelligence in the population lies on a normal curve; unless you're dealing with kids, an average for each age isn't really helpful. There are different scoring norms for different age groups, sure, but the average intelligence is 100, and most everyone is within a standard deviation of that (80-120).
I guess what I was getting at was that you can be a really smart 5 year old with a 150 IQ, but you don't always maintain that separation and slide back in to the group. It's not like you 'points' for every question you get right, it's a ratio of what you know to how much you should know or spatial/pattern awareness/recognition what have you. That's where the Quotient part comes in. So you're score can change.

Just for example, say the exam is 100 questions. And everyone in your class gets 30 questions right. And they are expected to get 30 questions right they have an IQ of 100 (30/30 * 100). But you get 45 questions right, you were only expected to get 30 right so you have an IQ of 150 (45/30 * 100). But that expected score number changes with each grade/physical year, so the following year everyone might catch up and you don't learn anything to put yourself ahead of them and everyone gets 45, including you, and your IQ goes to 100.

Edit - It sounds like you have a good Psych background and pretty well versed in this. Most of this is what I remember from high school Pysch almost 10 years ago, so it's my rudimentary understanding and can be (probably is) pretty rough or totally wrong.

TimeForGuinness
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 20007
Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm

Re: Rant- ACT and scores of that ilk.

Post by TimeForGuinness »

In all standardized tests (ACT, SAT, GRE), I've always scored poorly on the reading/comprehension...but have aced/nearly-aced the math sections. My composite score was always above average (26-28 ACT, 1250-1310 SAT) but it was so lopsided (ie: 780 Math, 450 Verbal).

My GRE:
Quantitative Math: 800/800
Qualitative Math: 790/800
Verbal/Reading: 480/800

No wonder I became an engineer.

User avatar
cards2468
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 14745
Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT

Re: Rant- ACT and scores of that ilk.

Post by cards2468 »

TimeForGuinness wrote:In all standardized tests (ACT, SAT, GRE), I've always scored poorly on the reading/comprehension...but have aced/nearly-aced the math sections. My composite score was always above average (26-28 ACT, 1250-1310 SAT) but it was so lopsided (ie: 780 Math, 450 Verbal).

My GRE:
Quantitative Math: 800/800
Qualitative Math: 790/800
Verbal/Reading: 480/800

No wonder I became an engineer.
quite similar to me

I'm taking the GRE monday, so I can report that back later, but on the ACT I scored nearly perfect in math and science then [expletive] in everything else

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: Rant- ACT and scores of that ilk.

Post by jim »

I'm not sure why but the average ACT test score when I took it was 18, and now it's more like 22. I wonder if that's just in general more preperation going on for the test in the classrooms.

BTW - neighboor kid direclty across from me aced it last year. 36. And he's dumb as a [expletive] rock in life as far as I can tell.

Post Reply