cpebbles wrote:360 had a terrible problem with reliability, and it basically all traced back to some retard's idea of placing big X-shaped attachments for the heatsinks on it for branding purposes (You know, deep inside the machine where nobody will ever see it), which put pressure causing it to separate over time. Billion dollar mistake there. They've apparently fixed it since.
I thought it was because they used to use copper wiring or something.
No, the heatsink was/is the issue. As the machine gets used more and more the heatsink becomes seperated from the CPU (or GPU?, can't remember). This is why the towel trick works (wrapping the XBox360 up in a towel for 20min or so then restarting it). By heating the system up you cause the metal to expand again and make contact with the processor and the system boots. You can fix it yourself for about $14 by taking a drill, nuts, and bolts to the thing and anchoring that sucker down.
I once considered myself buying dead $50 XBox360's off ebay, fixing them myself, then selling them for $250. Alas though Microsoft has fixed my system twice so I haven't needed to do self repairs to it.
My son's original PS/3 had the exact same problem (leads seperating) as the XBox, so they aren't immune either. My son's XBox which is about 6 months old hasn't given him any trouble.
Also, on my son's other system that had the red ring of death problem, we tried doing a complete backup so that when it happened again (as it did - in fact 3 more times before we just stopped fixing it) we would be able to copy everything on to a new system. There was one corrupt sector on the disk that we couldn't remove, any the PS/3 app that creates the backup would trip over it every time. We called Sony and got the absolute worst technical service people you could possibly imagine - I'm pretty sure I made a little old lady cry because i jumped down her throat for reading a script that had nothing to do with our problem. It was very frustrating.
ive heard about far more problems with the xbox than the ps3...and i have an xbox...ive had mine for just under two years now and its about to go to crap...it still plays but i literally have to punch it to read the disc, clearly something is wrong with the laser...think i'll just wait until the slim comes out then i'll replace it...
edit: didn't realize the slim was out...hmm...to charge or to not to charge
Last edited by Jocephus on July 14 10, 10:05 am, edited 1 time in total.
I've had one xbox red ring on me and that was my launch 360 after 2 1/2 years. I had an elite after that that survived until I sold it last month and got the new slim model. I like the 360's interface and controller a ton more than the ps3's.
My ps3 only gets game time for exclusives like Metal Gear and Uncharted. Otherwise it is strictly a blu ray player for me and gets used very often for that purpose.
I believe the rate of 360 problems has decreased with time and the new version supposedly shouldn't have the problem that plagued the old version. That's not to say it won't have problems, because every piece of electronics does (look no further than jim's problems with the vaunted ps3 reliability).