Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
-
MrSaigon
Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
Most of these are 'of all time' lists.
500 Greatest Songs: Smells Like Teen Spirit-9
100 Greatest Pop Songs: Smells Like Teen Spirit-3
100 Greatest Guitarists: Kurt Cobain-12
500 Greatest Albums: Nevermind-17
100 Greatest Artists: Nirvana-27
100 Greatest Singers: Kurt Cobain-45
I believe these lists do get revised from time to time, so some of these may not be right anymore. Also, please no Radiohead fans in this discussion. I know what all your lists look like (j/k, sort of).
500 Greatest Songs: Smells Like Teen Spirit-9
100 Greatest Pop Songs: Smells Like Teen Spirit-3
100 Greatest Guitarists: Kurt Cobain-12
500 Greatest Albums: Nevermind-17
100 Greatest Artists: Nirvana-27
100 Greatest Singers: Kurt Cobain-45
I believe these lists do get revised from time to time, so some of these may not be right anymore. Also, please no Radiohead fans in this discussion. I know what all your lists look like (j/k, sort of).
Online
- Popeye_Card
- GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
- Posts: 31097
- Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
So is your point that Rolling Stone perpetually overrates them? If so, I am in agreement. I like Nirvana and all, but come on. The guitarist ranking is especially bad, but then again that whole list is just awful.
Nirvana had some great music, but more than anything they were just in the right place at the right time.
Nirvana had some great music, but more than anything they were just in the right place at the right time.
- thrill
- bronoun enthusiast
- Posts: 30539
- Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
- Location: barely online
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
Nirvana is one of the most boring bands of all time. If that's the list, #27 is a fair ranking.
- Cronos
- In perpetuum
- Posts: 34778
- Joined: June 30 06, 7:49 am
- Location: St. Louis
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
MrSaigon wrote:Also, please no Radiohead fans in this discussion. I know what all your lists look like (j/k, sort of).
- ghostrunner
- GOAT
- Posts: 30873
- Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
++Popeye_Card wrote:So is your point that Rolling Stone perpetually overrates them? If so, I am in agreement. I like Nirvana and all, but come on. The guitarist ranking is especially bad, but then again that whole list is just awful.
Nirvana had some great music, but more than anything they were just in the right place at the right time.
Also Jack White (i'm a fan) and almost any blues guitarist from before 1960. I had a subscription when I was in high school, and ANY blues guitarist box set or re-release got 5 stars every time. I used to think to myself there has to be some scale of quality for blues music, doesn't there?
- TheoSqua
- Next Gen Wart
- Posts: 8951
- Joined: April 22 06, 6:53 pm
- Location: St. Louis
- Contact:
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
Kurt Cobain was a phenominal song writer. Smells Like Teen Sprit is a great song and is well written. So i guess it depends on your definition of greatness in guitar playing.
You absolutely cannot compare him to some of the amazing technical guitarists, he would have never gotten an invite to G3. But when it comes to songwriting, in the vien of someone like Bob Dylan - whose musical talents are fairly limited from a technical standpoint but brilliant in that tons of people love listening to it - Kurt Cobain is easily one of the 100 most talented popular guitarists of the past decade.
You absolutely cannot compare him to some of the amazing technical guitarists, he would have never gotten an invite to G3. But when it comes to songwriting, in the vien of someone like Bob Dylan - whose musical talents are fairly limited from a technical standpoint but brilliant in that tons of people love listening to it - Kurt Cobain is easily one of the 100 most talented popular guitarists of the past decade.
- ghostrunner
- GOAT
- Posts: 30873
- Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
I think the "Smells Like Teen Spirit" praise is warranted. The guitar stuff - who cares. That's extremely subjective stuff, IMO. People like different styles, favor inventiveness over virtuosity and vice versa, etc....
These I think are way off:
500 Greatest Albums: Nevermind-17
100 Greatest Artists: Nirvana-27
100 Greatest Singers: Kurt Cobain-45
These I think are way off:
500 Greatest Albums: Nevermind-17
100 Greatest Artists: Nirvana-27
100 Greatest Singers: Kurt Cobain-45
- StatmanCrothers
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 6461
- Joined: April 17 06, 6:50 am
- Location: Boston burbs
- Contact:
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
substitute any reasonable alt-rock guitarist and any emoting similar-voiced alt-rock singer and Nirvana's songs would sound just as good.
Cobain's greatest talent was as a songwriter. Not that he wasn't entirely adequate to perform his own songs, its just that without those songs, Nirvana would have been just another noisy grunge band. Case in point, almost everything off their first album, besides "About A Girl" (if that's the song i'm thinking of).
"About a Girl", plus about half each of Nevermind and In Utero, and a small handful of the non-LP tracks from Incesticide and maybe something or two from Unplugged, and you have about a CD's worth of awesome.
Most good bands, it takes a few more albums to collect that much awesome. For a two album span, They were much better than good.
But as to their place in history... it is earned, not just a simple case of "right place right time." although they certainly were in the right place at the right time, it wasn't as simple for them as those that followed them. and certainly, there was a small but dedicated following ready for them based on bands they stood on the shoulders of. However...
I wasn't a big fan of "Bleach" when it came out, to me they were just another Sub Pop "I wanna be Mudhoney" band... I became a real fan starting with the "Gramma take me home" song from the Sub Pop EP that came out in between Bleach and Never Mind... the song is on Incesticide but the name of the song escapes me.. a one word title i think?
anyway, I was already a fan, and an alt-rock grungin' hipster (before it was cool, baby) by night hangin on short Vine in Cincy when Geffen Records threw a record release party at Chilly's for Nirvana "Never Mind" ... the band wasn't there, just a promo deal, but... (to be contnued)
Cobain's greatest talent was as a songwriter. Not that he wasn't entirely adequate to perform his own songs, its just that without those songs, Nirvana would have been just another noisy grunge band. Case in point, almost everything off their first album, besides "About A Girl" (if that's the song i'm thinking of).
"About a Girl", plus about half each of Nevermind and In Utero, and a small handful of the non-LP tracks from Incesticide and maybe something or two from Unplugged, and you have about a CD's worth of awesome.
Most good bands, it takes a few more albums to collect that much awesome. For a two album span, They were much better than good.
But as to their place in history... it is earned, not just a simple case of "right place right time." although they certainly were in the right place at the right time, it wasn't as simple for them as those that followed them. and certainly, there was a small but dedicated following ready for them based on bands they stood on the shoulders of. However...
I wasn't a big fan of "Bleach" when it came out, to me they were just another Sub Pop "I wanna be Mudhoney" band... I became a real fan starting with the "Gramma take me home" song from the Sub Pop EP that came out in between Bleach and Never Mind... the song is on Incesticide but the name of the song escapes me.. a one word title i think?
anyway, I was already a fan, and an alt-rock grungin' hipster (before it was cool, baby) by night hangin on short Vine in Cincy when Geffen Records threw a record release party at Chilly's for Nirvana "Never Mind" ... the band wasn't there, just a promo deal, but... (to be contnued)
Last edited by StatmanCrothers on July 23 10, 10:59 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
MrSaigon
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
When I listen to the Unplugged album it sounds like Cobain couldn't even fret the strings. I'm sure that was just a style thing, because he really is a good guitarist (if not the 12th best ever). That's always bothered me though.TheoSqua wrote:Kurt Cobain was a phenominal song writer. Smells Like Teen Sprit is a great song and is well written. So i guess it depends on your definition of greatness in guitar playing.
You absolutely cannot compare him to some of the amazing technical guitarists, he would have never gotten an invite to G3. But when it comes to songwriting, in the vien of someone like Bob Dylan - whose musical talents are fairly limited from a technical standpoint but brilliant in that tons of people love listening to it - Kurt Cobain is easily one of the 100 most talented popular guitarists of the past decade.
About Dylan, did he play the most intricate guitar pieces on his early albums? I know his guitar playing was largely shot after the motorcycle accident. But he could pick it pretty good when he was a kid. Did he play guitar on 'Girl from the North Country'? That's a brilliant guitar song.
- StatmanCrothers
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 6461
- Joined: April 17 06, 6:50 am
- Location: Boston burbs
- Contact:
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
... but i was already a fan of "Smells Like Teen Spirit" their new single which I'd taped off the 2-hour "Gridloxx" underground alternative show on 97X (Bam! The Future of Rock and Roll) ...
attendees got to hear the entire new CD and received a free CD single of Smells Like Teen Spirit.
Now note, at this time, there were very few alternative rock radio stations at all. 97X was a bellwether for the few that were out there, but mainstream rock radio was hair metal and if you were lucky you'd get to hear something like REM or U2 or Smithereens. Replacements finally had a minor radio hit with "I'll Be You."
Even on 97X, the regular stuff was along these lines, with "the Manchester sound" of the Happy Mondays, Stone Roses, Inspiral Carpets, Charlatan UK, etc, being the norm.
Rough guitar based stuff like Nirvana or anything on indie labels like Sub Pop, Touch & Go, etc was still "college rock" and even on 97X it only got played on the special 2 hour Gridloxx program (midnight to 2 am... Sunday night only!) , or on the low power college FM stations.
So here you had Nirvana's "Smells Like Teen Spirit" starting out only getting play on the most progressive alternative rock station in the country, and only after midnight on Sunday night.
(contnued...)
attendees got to hear the entire new CD and received a free CD single of Smells Like Teen Spirit.
Now note, at this time, there were very few alternative rock radio stations at all. 97X was a bellwether for the few that were out there, but mainstream rock radio was hair metal and if you were lucky you'd get to hear something like REM or U2 or Smithereens. Replacements finally had a minor radio hit with "I'll Be You."
Even on 97X, the regular stuff was along these lines, with "the Manchester sound" of the Happy Mondays, Stone Roses, Inspiral Carpets, Charlatan UK, etc, being the norm.
Rough guitar based stuff like Nirvana or anything on indie labels like Sub Pop, Touch & Go, etc was still "college rock" and even on 97X it only got played on the special 2 hour Gridloxx program (midnight to 2 am... Sunday night only!) , or on the low power college FM stations.
So here you had Nirvana's "Smells Like Teen Spirit" starting out only getting play on the most progressive alternative rock station in the country, and only after midnight on Sunday night.
(contnued...)

