That's where I think you'll end up. Keep me posted.jim wrote:I was hoping you were going to chime in. Sounds like a plan. Nice thing about Carmax is there is a baseline to work with. If I ended up at a 4-4.5K difference I would pull the trigger.Fat_Bulldog wrote:Jim,jim wrote:Help me out here GRB, what's a fair price to offer? Here is the scenario.
I still can't sleep from my test drive of a 2007 Mustang GT the other day. Actually went out to a Carmax to get a trade value for my truck just to see, and also inquire about a 2007 GT they had at another location that looked pretty sweet. Carmax came back with a trade value of 17,000 even for my truck, a little lower then I thought (I figured 18) but not bad. So I have kind of a baseline for what a trade would be worth (I've also used autotrader to get an online bid which came in at 18 and change).
So Carmax talked me into transferring a car from that other location, it should be here Saturday. Just giving the details that are pertinent for comparison, this car at Carmax is essentially the same car that I am going to describe below with 2 additions:
- 18" wheels vs 17"
- 5K on the odometer vs 15K.
The price on the Carmax car is 22,499, and with a trade of 17 I am looking at a difference of 5.5K. So that's the basepoint.
Now, here is the "other" car that I drove that is a Ford Certified Pre-Owned(CPO)
http://fordcpo.autotrader.com/dealerdir ... _year=2007
21,988, and it is a certified car which means I get an extended warranty. I can buy an extended warranty on the Carmax car, to equal what I get with the CPO it's going to be worth about $600.
So, summary:
Carmax: 22,499 + 600 (extended warranty) = 22,999 - 17,000 trade= $6K.
Ford CPO: 21,988 - ? trade = ?
For a grand less before even negotiating on the Ford CPO car, the Carmax car has 10K less on the odometer and 18" wheels - and a color that I think I will like a litte better in person (red). Inside it's a cream/black leather which looks sharp as hell in the pics, but I really like the charcoal gray on the Ford CPO car as well. Looks wise the silver with the black/stripe is very nice, but I think I might think the red is a tad sharper. But for 1,000 difference before negotiations even start, I just can't see why I would go the Carmax route.
Maybe the dealer will really screw me over on the trade, but if he comes in at the 17K and can knock anything off the price I think I would do it. Or if he screws me on the trade at 16 and knocks 1,000 off ... I think I would still do it as well. In other words, if the diff between trade and car is more than 1.5K I think I would be better off skipping the 18" wheels and not worrying about 10K on the odometer, no? It's not like 15K on the odometer is a worn out car, hell that's barely broke in.
So what do you say? How much do you shoot for off of the sticker on a 22,000 used car?
I would start out at a ridiculous difference figure in your negotiations.
I would agree to make the deal at a difference figure of $2,000.00 to $2,500.00. From there, you will probably end up at about a $4,000.00 to $4,500.00 difference figure. Or better....
(However you want to look at lower the difference figure: dealer is lowering price to get closer to your number or dealer is putting more money into your trade
The car thread.
- Fat_Bulldog
- likes to grate his own cheese
- Posts: 12880
- Joined: May 9 06, 12:41 pm
- Location: Drunk
Re: The car thread.
-
jim
- Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
- Posts: 50393
- Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm
Re: The car thread.
Oh damn it to hell, I went to go look at the Carmax car that was $500 more tonight. Well, didn't realize it had the special "California Trim". Two tone leather, 18" performance tires, upgraded brakes, leather steering wheel ... all sorts of trim upgrades, 4,099 miles on the odometer .... red... getting weak ... test drive ... getting weaker .... can't resist ... bought car. Most beautiful "used" Mustang you could ever imagine. Records showed 1 owner, who must have taken it out on 75 degree days with no clouds only.
Made it home alive and without tickets, so that's good.
I'll post some pics soon.
Made it home alive and without tickets, so that's good.
I'll post some pics soon.
- PujolJunkie
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 10370
- Joined: March 22 07, 4:54 pm
- Location: north county, stl
- Contact:
Re: The car thread.
Not much help here, but my lord I love my Mustang, jim. 2004 40th Anniversary Edition. It's my baby.

That picture is my car exactly, except for the hood. Can't say I've ever had any major issues with it ever.

That picture is my car exactly, except for the hood. Can't say I've ever had any major issues with it ever.
- cards2468
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 14745
- Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
- Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT
Re: The car thread.
Congrats Jim, you won't be disappointedjim wrote:Oh damn it to hell, I went to go look at the Carmax car that was $500 more tonight. Well, didn't realize it had the special "California Trim". Two tone leather, 18" performance tires, upgraded brakes, leather steering wheel ... all sorts of trim upgrades, 4,099 miles on the odometer .... red... getting weak ... test drive ... getting weaker .... can't resist ... bought car. Most beautiful "used" Mustang you could ever imagine. Records showed 1 owner, who must have taken it out on 75 degree days with no clouds only.
Made it home alive and without tickets, so that's good.
I'll post some pics soon.
- lukethedrifter
- darjeeling sipping elite
- Posts: 37260
- Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
- Location: Huis Clos
Re: The car thread.
So you live in your parents' basement?PujolJunkie wrote:Not much help here, but my lord I love my Mustang, jim. 2004 40th Anniversary Edition. It's my baby.
That picture is my car exactly, except for the hood. Can't say I've ever had any major issues with it ever.
-
jim
- Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
- Posts: 50393
- Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm
Re: The car thread.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Special_Mustang
The picture in the 2007-2009 section is the exact color of my car. Only difference is that mine does not have the hood scoop, but it does have the door scoop. The two tone interior is really sharp (mine is black/ivory) along with the trim. I don't know how to describe the dash trim inside, but the other car I looked at was a smooth piece of metal on the dash where this has raised bumps and isn't as shiny. I'm almost going to feel guilty about driving this in bad weather. The only functional piece that was added was the 18" tires - although this means come November I'm off to the tire store getting a pair of 17" snow tires.
The plan last night was just to see the car for a comparison and then head to the other dealer today and see how low I could get him. After the test drive, the sales guy just left my wife and I in the car to sit and talk. We probably were in there for 15 minutes, most of it her telling me to just get it. They had the car on hold as it was a transfer, but they said policy was to put it back on the lot after the customer drove it. It was what they call their "Last Chance" vehicle, which just means they had dropped the price on it. I was monitoring this car and noticed last week it went down $500 and saw that it had a symbol highlighting this price drop. My wife, who really isn't a car person, was so mesmerized by the car that she was just telling me to get it. We were sitting by a door where there was alot of foot traffic and she just said for me to watch peoples reactions as they walked by - and it was true. Every person that walked by just couldn't take their eyes off of it. That convinced me that there was a reasonable chance this car was going to be gone soon, and I kind of had that "Ah you only live once" thought.
So initially I didn't think that was going to be a great deal, and I still don't know if I got a great deal. But after finding out that it basically had an $1800 option that I didn't realize, I think I got a very good deal, and I'll have to say that the buying experience is definitely different at a fixed price place like Carmax. I didn't miss the b-s and games you have to play at a dealer. Other interesting minor tidbit was that Carmax listed the car as 5K miles. I figured, 5,998 or something. But it had 4,090 miles on it before the test drive, they said they round everything up just so that if it gets test driven a few times customers don't think they are pulling a fast one on them. Not that 1k miles are going to make a difference, but in my case the car had 20% fewer miles than advertised.
pj ... is that your daily driver?
The picture in the 2007-2009 section is the exact color of my car. Only difference is that mine does not have the hood scoop, but it does have the door scoop. The two tone interior is really sharp (mine is black/ivory) along with the trim. I don't know how to describe the dash trim inside, but the other car I looked at was a smooth piece of metal on the dash where this has raised bumps and isn't as shiny. I'm almost going to feel guilty about driving this in bad weather. The only functional piece that was added was the 18" tires - although this means come November I'm off to the tire store getting a pair of 17" snow tires.
The plan last night was just to see the car for a comparison and then head to the other dealer today and see how low I could get him. After the test drive, the sales guy just left my wife and I in the car to sit and talk. We probably were in there for 15 minutes, most of it her telling me to just get it. They had the car on hold as it was a transfer, but they said policy was to put it back on the lot after the customer drove it. It was what they call their "Last Chance" vehicle, which just means they had dropped the price on it. I was monitoring this car and noticed last week it went down $500 and saw that it had a symbol highlighting this price drop. My wife, who really isn't a car person, was so mesmerized by the car that she was just telling me to get it. We were sitting by a door where there was alot of foot traffic and she just said for me to watch peoples reactions as they walked by - and it was true. Every person that walked by just couldn't take their eyes off of it. That convinced me that there was a reasonable chance this car was going to be gone soon, and I kind of had that "Ah you only live once" thought.
So initially I didn't think that was going to be a great deal, and I still don't know if I got a great deal. But after finding out that it basically had an $1800 option that I didn't realize, I think I got a very good deal, and I'll have to say that the buying experience is definitely different at a fixed price place like Carmax. I didn't miss the b-s and games you have to play at a dealer. Other interesting minor tidbit was that Carmax listed the car as 5K miles. I figured, 5,998 or something. But it had 4,090 miles on it before the test drive, they said they round everything up just so that if it gets test driven a few times customers don't think they are pulling a fast one on them. Not that 1k miles are going to make a difference, but in my case the car had 20% fewer miles than advertised.
pj ... is that your daily driver?
-
Michael
- GRB Founder
- Posts: 35304
- Joined: December 31 69, 6:00 pm
- Location: Chicago, IL
- Contact:
Re: The car thread.
Wow, this car looks amazing, jim.


- PujolJunkie
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 10370
- Joined: March 22 07, 4:54 pm
- Location: north county, stl
- Contact:
Re: The car thread.
The garage isn't the same as the basement, [expletive].lukethedrifter wrote:So you live in your parents' basement?PujolJunkie wrote:Not much help here, but my lord I love my Mustang, jim. 2004 40th Anniversary Edition. It's my baby.
That picture is my car exactly, except for the hood. Can't say I've ever had any major issues with it ever.
Yeah, it is jim. I will say there's only two complaints I've ever had about it. 1) It isn't spacious at all, but in the post-04 models, that's a problem I think they more or less solved. And 2) It's not the smoothest ride in the world at times. Really bumpy streets can be really, really annoying.jim wrote: pj ... is that your daily driver?
-
jim
- Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
- Posts: 50393
- Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm
Re: The car thread.
What tires are you running on it? Spacious in terms of driver or passenger? Because the 2005- don't have much room for passengers either, but the cockpit area is very ergo friendly.PujolJunkie wrote:The garage isn't the same as the basement, [expletive].lukethedrifter wrote:So you live in your parents' basement?PujolJunkie wrote:Not much help here, but my lord I love my Mustang, jim. 2004 40th Anniversary Edition. It's my baby.
That picture is my car exactly, except for the hood. Can't say I've ever had any major issues with it ever.
Yeah, it is jim. I will say there's only two complaints I've ever had about it. 1) It isn't spacious at all, but in the post-04 models, that's a problem I think they more or less solved. And 2) It's not the smoothest ride in the world at times. Really bumpy streets can be really, really annoying.jim wrote: pj ... is that your daily driver?
What engine do you have in it?







