Rant: Glenn Beck

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: Rant: Glenn Beck

Post by Arthur Dent »

ghostrunner wrote:Forgot to mention this the other day. Flipping around the radio and caught a bit of his show mid-rant - which he concluded by saying this country lost it's way around the time of:
[SHOW]
Andrew Jackson
I dunno. As far as Beck stuff goes, this doesn't seems too bad. There's a lot not to like about both Andrew Jackson and Manifest Destiny. I suppose the funny thing is the belief that America has a divine purpose imbued by the founders that we have since fallen away from. But lots of people believe that.

User avatar
sighyoung
Mayor of GRB
Posts: 38643
Joined: April 17 06, 7:42 pm
Location: Louisville

Re: Rant: Glenn Beck

Post by sighyoung »

Arthur Dent wrote:
ghostrunner wrote:Forgot to mention this the other day. Flipping around the radio and caught a bit of his show mid-rant - which he concluded by saying this country lost it's way around the time of:
[SHOW]
Andrew Jackson
I dunno. As far as Beck stuff goes, this doesn't seems too bad. There's a lot not to like about both Andrew Jackson and Manifest Destiny. I suppose the funny thing is the belief that America has a divine purpose imbued by the founders that we have since fallen away from. But lots of people believe that.
Yep. Slavery was chugging along nicely until Andrew Jackson came along. What did Beck oppose, exactly? Jackson's assertion that Southern states couldn't secede? The seizure of Native American lands? Did Jackson do something to Mormons that angered Beck?

But since Jackson opposed a central bank, you'd think Beck would be happy.

User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30873
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: Rant: Glenn Beck

Post by ghostrunner »

Arthur Dent wrote:
ghostrunner wrote:Forgot to mention this the other day. Flipping around the radio and caught a bit of his show mid-rant - which he concluded by saying this country lost it's way around the time of:
[SHOW]
Andrew Jackson
I dunno. As far as Beck stuff goes, this doesn't seems too bad. There's a lot not to like about both Andrew Jackson and Manifest Destiny. I suppose the funny thing is the belief that America has a divine purpose imbued by the founders that we have since fallen away from. But lots of people believe that.
I guess what's funny to me is the typical conservative yearning always seems to be for the Eisenhower/Post WWII era. "When we grew up, etc.." Beck has to go back another 120 years. He's also got this whole anti-Woodrow Wilson thing. In this same rant he accused Teddy Roosevelt of favoring eugenics, citing it as evidence of progressivism's early stages. Not sure if it's in the video version or not, as I haven't watched it. Basically the thinking is that the country hasn't been right since before pretty much anyone alive was born.

User avatar
sighyoung
Mayor of GRB
Posts: 38643
Joined: April 17 06, 7:42 pm
Location: Louisville

Re: Rant: Glenn Beck

Post by sighyoung »

Now the popular thesis is that Progressivism=some form of Fascism= anti-Americanism.

Actually, I dislike Wilson intensely, too, but probably for different reasons.

If he's complaining about Teddy Roosevelt and eugenics, what does he think Southern Democratic representatives and senators happened to favor?
Last edited by sighyoung on August 29 10, 7:38 pm, edited 1 time in total.

Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: Rant: Glenn Beck

Post by Arthur Dent »

G. Keenan wrote:IMO, anyone with a radio show or a cable show, whatever their politics, is simply an entertainer whose opinions should be irrelevant to actual political discussion. Fortunately, as much influence as these entertainers like to think they have, and as much as their political opposites fear they have, they really are mostly irrelevant to actual policy making.
They have an effect the extent that they impact popular political discussion, and to the extent that popular discussion impacts policy. I'd say the impact on public discussion is substantial. Popular arguments are often direct copies of those distributed though these channels. It's true that elected officials mostly pay lip service to this kind of thing while crafting policy based on other influences, but I wouldn't say that the impact is negligible at all (take immigration, for example).

I do think it's foolish and self-destructive that liberals spend so much time fixating on nuts on the other side. Remember when Bush was in office and conservative media still spent 90% of its breath going on about how awful liberals are? It's equally stupid when liberals engage in the same behavior even with their party enjoying outsized control of government. It's a kind of defeatism when you insist that you are paralyzed by opposition and won't use the power you have. Perhaps the common element is the belief that being morally correct is more important than actually winning policy changes.

User avatar
Joe Shlabotnik
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 24292
Joined: October 12 06, 2:21 pm
Location: Baseball Ref Bullpen
Contact:

Re: Rant: Glenn Beck

Post by Joe Shlabotnik »

redbirdjazzz wrote:
ghostrunner wrote:Forgot to mention this the other day. Flipping around the radio and caught a bit of his show mid-rant - which he concluded by saying this country lost it's way around the time of:
[SHOW]
Andrew Jackson


No clip of the audio, but I guess he does the same topic on his TV show:

http://www.thepoliticalcarnival.net/201 ... ent-wrong/
Wow. The person that created the Democratic party is the person who made us lose our way; I never would've guessed. Never mind that James Monroe was the one who popularized the idea of Manifest Destiny, not Jackson.
Although I don't know why he'd have a problem with Manifest Destiny since the LDS basically turned white American male manifest destiny into a religion.

Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: Rant: Glenn Beck

Post by Arthur Dent »

ghostrunner wrote:I guess what's funny to me is the typical conservative yearning always seems to be for the Eisenhower/Post WWII era. "When we grew up, etc.." Beck has to go back another 120 years. He's also got this whole anti-Woodrow Wilson thing. In this same rant he accused Teddy Roosevelt of favoring eugenics, citing it as evidence of progressivism's early stages. Not sure if it's in the video version or not, as I haven't watched it. Basically the thinking is that the country hasn't been right since before pretty much anyone alive was born.
Marginally related to this, I thought this Charlie Stross comment on the origin of utopianism was interesting:

"Conservative politicians in the US — and elsewhere — get a lot of mileage from appeals to false nostalgia, to a yearning for a time when things were simpler, everyone was sturdily self-sufficient or knew their place (or both), and government was small (sometimes small enough to drown in a bathtub). Nostalgia trips manifest themselves in all sorts of curious places. In SF (the literary field I know most about) we have the perennial libertarian/space colonization nexus.We have Ayn Rand, and her wish-fulfilment nerd fantasy of a world sustained by a tiny, overworked minority of geniuses who, if only they could demand a level of rewards corresponding to their work, would be rich beyond dreams of avarice (and able to make the trains run on time). Outside it, we have the peculiarly rustic aspirations of the green fringe, who'd like to see a world of five million or so pre-industrial humans living in harmony with nature. In the Republican party of the United States we see rhetoric couched in hatred for "big government", and among the UK's conservatives we see an almost masochistic addiction to cuts in public spending framed with calls for a big society in which many current government services will be delivered by voluntary citizens groups instead.

"I think these ideas are mostly delusional because they rely on a fundamental misapprehension about the world around us — namely that we live in a society that can be made simple enough to comprehend."
http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-st ... -data.html

User avatar
doe_boy
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 10738
Joined: April 25 06, 9:48 am
Location: Appleton, WI

Re: Rant: Glenn Beck

Post by doe_boy »

So, I hope this Lincoln Memorial get together doesn't turn into a regular thing. It could get creepy.

I know this is violating Godwin's Law, but, he (Beck) does it all the time.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuremberg_Rally
1936 - 8th Party Congress; "Rally of Honour" (Reichsparteitag der Ehre): The invasion of the demilitarized Rhineland, in the eyes of the NSDAP leadership, constituted the restoration of German honour. The film Festliches Nürnberg incorporated footage made at this rally, as well as the rally of 1937.
The last one, the 'Rally of Peace', was cancelled since Germany began it's invasion of Poland the day before it was scheduled to be held.

User avatar
Cronos
In perpetuum
Posts: 34778
Joined: June 30 06, 7:49 am
Location: St. Louis

Re: Rant: Glenn Beck

Post by Cronos »

Arthur Dent wrote:
G. Keenan wrote:IMO, anyone with a radio show or a cable show, whatever their politics, is simply an entertainer whose opinions should be irrelevant to actual political discussion. Fortunately, as much influence as these entertainers like to think they have, and as much as their political opposites fear they have, they really are mostly irrelevant to actual policy making.
They have an effect the extent that they impact popular political discussion, and to the extent that popular discussion impacts policy. I'd say the impact on public discussion is substantial. Popular arguments are often direct copies of those distributed though these channels. It's true that elected officials mostly pay lip service to this kind of thing while crafting policy based on other influences, but I wouldn't say that the impact is negligible at all (take immigration, for example).
Agreed, saying the nuts (on both sides) on the radio and TV have little effect is just silly. People swear by them.

Of course they don't impact actual political figures' opinions, but they certainly impact popular vote.

User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: Rant: Glenn Beck

Post by vinsanity »

Cronos69 wrote:
Arthur Dent wrote:
G. Keenan wrote:IMO, anyone with a radio show or a cable show, whatever their politics, is simply an entertainer whose opinions should be irrelevant to actual political discussion. Fortunately, as much influence as these entertainers like to think they have, and as much as their political opposites fear they have, they really are mostly irrelevant to actual policy making.
They have an effect the extent that they impact popular political discussion, and to the extent that popular discussion impacts policy. I'd say the impact on public discussion is substantial. Popular arguments are often direct copies of those distributed though these channels. It's true that elected officials mostly pay lip service to this kind of thing while crafting policy based on other influences, but I wouldn't say that the impact is negligible at all (take immigration, for example).
Agreed, saying the nuts (on both sides) on the radio and TV have little effect is just silly. People swear by them.

Of course they don't impact actual political figures' opinions, but they certainly impact popular vote.
But when you're that extreme you're going to draw an audience that would likely agree with you anyway. I've read where they say 80% of the country will vote essentially a straight ticket regardless of the issues. Those 40% listen to the Al Franken's and Glenn Beck's to hear what they want to hear. Sometimes, those who are glutton for punishment, like myself will listen to the opposite side for a good laugh (Dr. Michael Savage - a Ph.D. in nutritional ethnomedicine - frequently states it's a fact that Obama is an unapologetic Marxist).

The middle 20% is probably fairly split on which side they listen to and are probably fairly evenly split on whether or not the like what they hear or are repulsed. I'm convinced all those millions spent in a campaign have more to do with the 4-5% of the population - a small few who actually walk in to an election some what objective and actually unsure.

Post Reply