The Metric System

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: The Metric System

Post by Arthur Dent »

cards2468 wrote:of course it's easy to shift between meters, kilometers, centimeters, nanometers, etc... but if you stick to pounds and inches in technical drawings, it makes no difference with math. If it's 2551235.656256 lbs or 1157221.03 kg, it doesn't matter, they're both [expletive] numbers. And the [expletive] who feel the need to change this to 1157.22103 megagrams can go [expletive] themselves
You and your primitive savage customs of metrology.
cards2468 wrote:Pretty much the point is that industry can't afford to make the conversion, so whatever you choose to do with dumb road signs doesn't matter. Look at the Gimli Glider for example. That's why the aerospace industry is afraid to stray from english.
Of course it can. It just doesn't want to. And retaining these ridiculous units leads to failures as well, like the one that destroyed the Mars Climate Orbiter.

Jocephus
99% conan clips
Posts: 64992
Joined: April 18 06, 5:14 pm

Re: The Metric System

Post by Jocephus »

gimli cannot glide...hes a dwarf

User avatar
cards2468
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 14745
Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT

Re: The Metric System

Post by cards2468 »

Arthur Dent wrote:
cards2468 wrote:of course it's easy to shift between meters, kilometers, centimeters, nanometers, etc... but if you stick to pounds and inches in technical drawings, it makes no difference with math. If it's 2551235.656256 lbs or 1157221.03 kg, it doesn't matter, they're both [expletive] numbers. And the [expletive] who feel the need to change this to 1157.22103 megagrams can go [expletive] themselves
You and your primitive savage customs of metrology.
cards2468 wrote:Pretty much the point is that industry can't afford to make the conversion, so whatever you choose to do with dumb road signs doesn't matter. Look at the Gimli Glider for example. That's why the aerospace industry is afraid to stray from english.
Of course it can. It just doesn't want to. And retaining these ridiculous units leads to failures as well, like the one that destroyed the Mars Climate Orbiter.
No, they can't. I'm sitting above tooling that's more than 50 years old and based on the english system. No way they replace everything down there and all the technical drawings to transition to metric. And it's not as easy as just saying "Design the next plane using the metric system and phase out older planes". Aircraft builders go to a small handful of manufacturers to have parts made, and these companies work off of interoperability with tooling so they can manufacture parts for aircraft ranging from Boeing 767's to Sikorsky CH53K's. And then you get into the fastener industry that can't produce product fast enough to keep up with the aerospace industry. Force them to switch all their products to metric and the aerospace industry would come to a complete halt.

Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: The Metric System

Post by Arthur Dent »

Nomination for hilarious group of the day.

Active Resistance to Metrication (in the UK)

Posing with a victory:
Image

Fur den Wehrmacht? An ARM activist discovered this military sign near to Dereham in Norfolk. We didnt want to make it too easy for any invading forces from the continent so we blotted out the metric speed.
Image

Image

User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: The Metric System

Post by vinsanity »

cards2468 wrote:No, they can't. I'm sitting above tooling that's more than 50 years old and based on the english system. No way they replace everything down there and all the technical drawings to transition to metric. And it's not as easy as just saying "Design the next plane using the metric system and phase out older planes". Aircraft builders go to a small handful of manufacturers to have parts made, and these companies work off of interoperability with tooling so they can manufacture parts for aircraft ranging from Boeing 767's to Sikorsky CH53K's. And then you get into the fastener industry that can't produce product fast enough to keep up with the aerospace industry. Force them to switch all their products to metric and the aerospace industry would come to a complete halt.
That's why you do it in phases. It doesn't have to be done over-night. New companies can be created to serve consumers who want to buy metric parts.

Actually they say war is the best way to get out of a depression/recession (WWII, but I'd say the last 10 years may have bunked this one) because of the heavy influx of government spending domestically on privately created goods/services, right? So wouldn't major government subsidizations on Imperial to Metric be a boon for the economy? Companies could try and expand output, slowly shifting some output to metric fasteners to build a store, so in a few years they'd have enough product to ship out as it's phased in, and start producing all metric. Surely some manufacturers would continue to produce imperial measurement parts for older mechanical pieces (cars, planes, machines etc) for repair. Subsidize all of this with some government money (not to mention the increase in spending by the government on their updates, new road signs and toolings) and we could have a huge injection of money in to the economy.

Even so, no one's saying private companies/industries can't keep their systems in tact - it'd just be a little outdated. There's no reason road signs can't switch to metric KM instead of miles, speed limits in KM/H, temperature gauges switch to C. No one tells soda companies they can't make 2 Liter's of soda - why would they tell aerospace they have to convert?

User avatar
cards2468
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 14745
Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT

Re: The Metric System

Post by cards2468 »

vinsanity wrote:
cards2468 wrote:No, they can't. I'm sitting above tooling that's more than 50 years old and based on the english system. No way they replace everything down there and all the technical drawings to transition to metric. And it's not as easy as just saying "Design the next plane using the metric system and phase out older planes". Aircraft builders go to a small handful of manufacturers to have parts made, and these companies work off of interoperability with tooling so they can manufacture parts for aircraft ranging from Boeing 767's to Sikorsky CH53K's. And then you get into the fastener industry that can't produce product fast enough to keep up with the aerospace industry. Force them to switch all their products to metric and the aerospace industry would come to a complete halt.
That's why you do it in phases. It doesn't have to be done over-night. New companies can be created to serve consumers who want to buy metric parts.

Actually they say war is the best way to get out of a depression/recession (WWII, but I'd say the last 10 years may have bunked this one) because of the heavy influx of government spending domestically on privately created goods/services, right? So wouldn't major government subsidizations on Imperial to Metric be a boon for the economy? Companies could try and expand output, slowly shifting some output to metric fasteners to build a store, so in a few years they'd have enough product to ship out as it's phased in, and start producing all metric. Surely some manufacturers would continue to produce imperial measurement parts for older mechanical pieces (cars, planes, machines etc) for repair. Subsidize all of this with some government money (not to mention the increase in spending by the government on their updates, new road signs and toolings) and we could have a huge injection of money in to the economy.

Even so, no one's saying private companies/industries can't keep their systems in tact - it'd just be a little outdated. There's no reason road signs can't switch to metric KM instead of miles, speed limits in KM/H, temperature gauges switch to C. No one tells soda companies they can't make 2 Liter's of soda - why would they tell aerospace they have to convert?
It's so expensive to start up a company that fits these needs that nobody does it. There's really only 1 company capable of producing a vast majority of aerospace parts and this company is older than America. Enough of the government's money goes to this company that I don't see congress ever approving of sending more just so they use a different system of measuring.

And you're right, private companies can use whatever they want. But these aircraft land on government subsidized runways and government carriers that are all measured out in feet because of balanced field length calculations done on the aircraft that are designed in english units.

So go ahead and change all the road signs and gauges. You didn't really change anything at all, though I suppose smug Prius drivers can look at the road signs and say, "We're so worldly now".

User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: The Metric System

Post by vinsanity »

cards2468 wrote:So go ahead and change all the road signs and gauges. You didn't really change anything at all, though I suppose smug Prius drivers can look at the road signs and say, "We're so worldly now".
I hate to break it to you, but Aerospace isn't what drives unit measures.

As far as too expensive to start a new company? If congress passed a law that said in 20 years the metric system will be the US standard unit of measure, you don't think someone would see enough dollar signs to invest in these types of conversions? People start companies everyday, could it be no one wants to compete with an old company because they could never produce the product as quickly/cheaply as them? But if there was a new market, wouldn't that drive more competition? Especially with government subsidies? And who cares if they land on government owned/subsidized strips that are currently measured in feet? I'm sure you can buy a 2 liter of soda on military bases or a duty free, right? I don't buy that aerospace is wholly incapable of changing for any reason - Europe had to do it at some point - and the longer we wait the more difficult and costly it'll be.

But God forbid we declare that the metric system become the new standard and some things like automobiles and planes can keep their outdated confusing measures. We can measure buildings in meters instead of feet, instead of 12 ounces of soda you can get 300 ML or a half liter instead of a 20 oz soda. Set weight restrictions to grams instead of pounds. You'd be changing a lot, actually. It's about more than just being pretentious.

User avatar
cards2468
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 14745
Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT

Re: The Metric System

Post by cards2468 »

vinsanity wrote:
cards2468 wrote:So go ahead and change all the road signs and gauges. You didn't really change anything at all, though I suppose smug Prius drivers can look at the road signs and say, "We're so worldly now".
I hate to break it to you, but Aerospace isn't what drives unit measures.

As far as too expensive to start a new company? If congress passed a law that said in 20 years the metric system will be the US standard unit of measure, you don't think someone would see enough dollar signs to invest in these types of conversions? People start companies everyday, could it be no one wants to compete with an old company because they could never produce the product as quickly/cheaply as them? But if there was a new market, wouldn't that drive more competition? Especially with government subsidies? And who cares if they land on government owned/subsidized strips that are currently measured in feet? I'm sure you can buy a 2 liter of soda on military bases or a duty free, right? I don't buy that aerospace is wholly incapable of changing for any reason - Europe had to do it at some point - and the longer we wait the more difficult and costly it'll be.

But God forbid we declare that the metric system become the new standard and some things like automobiles and planes can keep their outdated confusing measures. We can measure buildings in meters instead of feet, instead of 12 ounces of soda you can get 300 ML or a half liter instead of a 20 oz soda. Set weight restrictions to grams instead of pounds. You'd be changing a lot, actually. It's about more than just being pretentious.
Well, the aerospace industry has been 1 of the main reasons the US has resisted converting.

And nobody starts companies to compete with this 1 because working with composites takes almost some sort of voodoo power. It's incredibly complicated and if you don't have the art mastered and the defense contracts to back it up, you will lose money like crazy.

Like I said, the tooling here is almost entirely government owned and expensive as hell. We're talking an excess of $100 million per facility.

And even the European aerospace industry still uses english units.

User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: The Metric System

Post by vinsanity »

cards2468 wrote:And even the European aerospace industry still uses english units.
Well there ya go.

So why can't we switch the national standard of measure to metric?

User avatar
cards2468
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 14745
Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT

Re: The Metric System

Post by cards2468 »

vinsanity wrote:
cards2468 wrote:And even the European aerospace industry still uses english units.
Well there ya go.

So why can't we switch the national standard of measure to metric?
go for it, I just don't see the benefit when really all we're changing is signs and labels. Just seems like a waste of money when industry won't change anyway (even outside the aerospace industry many companies won't pay for the conversion)

Post Reply