I do agree with you that the conference championship games help those conference teams when it comes to rankings. Personally, I think it can be fairly pointless, as well. Missouri beat Oklahoma. Why should they have to beat them again. And if Oklahoma wins the next time, then who is the "true" conference champion? It just muddles things, in my opinion.AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:Because being 12-1 in the SEC West is more deserving than being 12-0 in the Big X. Especially when they won't even play the best team in the conference.Socnorb11 wrote:
Why do you think that Alabama deserves to get in over the Big Ten champion, but not the Big XII champion?
Mizzou beating OU twice as well as Nebraska on the road is pretty impressive and it's tough to say the same (12-1 in the SEC > 13-0 in the Big XII).
The conf champion game is huge since it's guarateed to be against a top team, likely a team you've already played and have to beat again. Regardless, Alabama is going to be favored in all their games the rest of the season. So, if you truly believe that they're not the best team, then you'll have a good chance to maek some money as LSU and Auburn will likely both be about +180 on the moneyline.
And if the second best team in the Big XII (Oklahoma?) is just a mediocre team, then what have you proven by beating them twice? You've proven that you're better than Oklahoma...... sure. But why do you need to play them twice to prove that? As far as I'm concerned, the victory Saturday was conclusive. The reason they will (probably) play them again isn't to prove that they're better (again). It's about $$$. Wisconsin is pretty clearly the second best team in the Big 10 this year. Michigan State has already beat them. Why should they have to beat them again?
I don't think you can decisively say that the Big XII is better than the Big 10 this year. And so it doesn't make much sense to me to say that the Big XII champion deserves something that the Big 10 champion doesn't.
Personally, I think you're giving Alabama too much credit. As an example, Alabama beat Penn State by 21. Iowa (a Big 10 also-ran) also beat Penn State by 21. Heck, Illinois (who will finish in the middle of the Big 10) beat Penn State by 20, and that was at Penn State! I know that comparing scores can be stupid, but what else are going to use to measure up Alabama's credentials against other conferences?


