Socnorb11 wrote:If you don't think that program strength comes into play every year, then I think you're a little naive. Oklahoma gets bonus points "because they're Oklahoma", until proven otherwise. Same has held true for other strong programs.
Ok, but what does that have to do with Boise St. beating TCU ONE [expletive] TIME? And Boise beat them by a touchdown. It's not even like they blew them out.
TCU is 63-11 in their last five plus seasons (five and then 10 games this year). Boise is 66-8. And that's with TCU playing a far tougher schedule that includes games against teams like Oklahoma, Virginia, Clemson, Texas... They didn't have to be cajoled by the national media to add serious competition to their schedule because it was already there.
Socnorb11 wrote:I understand. Missouri fans are a little grouchy this week. No offense taken
Yeah, yeah. So you seriously don't see how incredibly [expletive] stupid an idea it is to compare two teams in 2010 based on what happened in 2009? Seriously?
The last time Iowa played Texas, Texas won. I guess Texas is a better football team in 2010.
The last time Alabama played Auburn, less than a year ago, Alabama won. So they're obviously the better team this season. That's the deciding factor for me.
The last time Kansas played Iowa State, they won, and it was just last year. They're the better team in 2010.
And on and on and on.
The difference is, all other things are not equal in those comparisons. Auburn is 10-0, Alabama is 7-2. Kansas is 3-6, Iowa State 5-5. Texas is 4-5, Iowa 7-2.
Boise St. and TCU are both unbeaten.
I didn't say anything should be the ONLY factor. I just suggested that it may be the difference-maker for me. I didn't intend to offend anyone.
Socnorb11 wrote:If you don't think that program strength comes into play every year, then I think you're a little naive. Oklahoma gets bonus points "because they're Oklahoma", until proven otherwise. Same has held true for other strong programs.
Ok, but what does that have to do with Boise St. beating TCU ONE [expletive] TIME? And Boise beat them by a touchdown. It's not even like they blew them out.
TCU is 63-11 in their last five plus seasons (five and then 10 games this year). Boise is 66-8. And that's with TCU playing a far tougher schedule that includes games against teams like Oklahoma, Virginia, Clemson, Texas... They didn't have to be cajoled by the national media to add serious competition to their schedule because it was already there.
That's a reasonable argument in favor of TCU.
I'm just saying, I think that Boise State proved last year that they are not a "fluke" program. TCU clearly isn't either. It's a tough call, in my opinion.
Plus...it's one game. Many a time over the course of history the team that wasn't better has won.
So many games revolve around 2-3 HUGE plays like redzone turnovers, amazing catches, goal etc that relying on the same thing to happen every time is silly.
Popeye_Card wrote:Clearly they're going to fall out of the top 10 now, but was there any argument going in?
Let's say they're just a top 25 team--has any team beaten a ranked opponent on the road by 40? Still the most impressive win by any team this year.
I guess the point I'm trying to make isn't so much that they shouldn't have been ranked that high (I think we can all agree that rankings are little more than an indication of record), but that no they aren't one of the ten best teams in the nation. And, either TCU is really underrated or Utah was really overrated, and I'd lean towards the later.
More on that rankings are little more than an indication of record.....
Last week, I tried to suggest Mizzou and Arkansas were very similar teams though Arkansas was staring 6-3 in the face with Mizzou looking to go to 8-1. I think only 1 person agreed with me that the two teams were similar and the majority looked at the suggested outcomes of the games last weekend and wouldn't buy it.
Now, they have the same record and people probably would agree with me that the two teams match up well/at least more than they did last week. While a record shows what happened in the past obviously, I think we too often rely on it to tell us how good a team is and what is going to happen in the future.
Obviously, it has to be considered and is important, but just alone saying a team is 9-0 doesn't really give a very good picture of what their true talent level is, especially if they are playing teams that would lose to a good DII program.
AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:More on that rankings are little more than an indication of record.....
Last week, I tried to suggest Mizzou and Arkansas were very similar teams though Arkansas was staring 6-3 in the face with Mizzou looking to go to 8-1. I think only 1 person agreed with me that the two teams were similar and the majority looked at the suggested outcomes of the games last weekend and wouldn't buy it.
Now, they have the same record and people probably would agree with me that the two teams match up well/at least more than they did last week. While a record shows what happened in the past obviously, I think we too often rely on it to tell us how good a team is and what is going to happen in the future.
Obviously, it has to be considered and is important, but just alone saying a team is 9-0 doesn't really give a very good picture of what their true talent level is, especially if they are playing teams that would lose to a good DII program.
Yeah, I owe you one on that, AW. I completely disagreed with you last week, but it looks like you weren't far off. Good call.
Last edited by Socnorb11 on November 8 10, 7:01 pm, edited 1 time in total.