Freed Roger wrote:There are about 3 too many classes in MO -especially now with all the consolidations and changing demographics. Thus the colossal mismatches. In the lower classes - its pretty common to see a team blow out Barat Academy or Lift for Life (? sounds like home-schooled teams) then turn around and get blown away by Valle Catholic or Maplewood.
Maplewood has a ton of skill-position talent for a school its size.
Crazy stuff about that E St. Louis situation -forfeiting games for recruiting, then getting an injunction. on one hand -I've always pulled for ESL -its nice to see something positive come out of there... but damn... using what means?
The lad who got booted from playing for a MO HS because he committed armed robbery then shows up on ESL team...that's a bit over the top.
Lots of rumors of Maplewood using illegal aka out of district players too.
Freed Roger wrote:There are about 3 too many classes in MO -especially now with all the consolidations and changing demographics. Thus the colossal mismatches. In the lower classes - its pretty common to see a team blow out Barat Academy or Lift for Life (? sounds like home-schooled teams) then turn around and get blown away by Valle Catholic or Maplewood.
Maplewood has a ton of skill-position talent for a school its size.
Crazy stuff about that E St. Louis situation -forfeiting games for recruiting, then getting an injunction. on one hand -I've always pulled for ESL -its nice to see something positive come out of there... but damn... using what means?
The lad who got booted from playing for a MO HS because he committed armed robbery then shows up on ESL team...that's a bit over the top.
Lots of rumors of Maplewood using illegal aka out of district players too.
I wouldn't doubt it. A friend coaches HS football, and when I mentioned Maplewood being good he harumphed.
It can be tough to determine where kid's actually reside in this day in age. And I think if you live in an unaccredited school district, a nearby accredited school can use discretion* to let you in(I think a variation of this issue is in the courts now -attempt to make it mandatory for accredited schools to accept unaccredited school students).
*with the discretion -as far as I know our local HS does this-but the vast majority of city school children they accept go through the entire school system from kindergarten on; which if it is recruiting for sports - it is very generous and far-sighted.
I sense there is a small group of kids that have dads or uncles etc managing their HS sports careers and they cause a lot of problems.
I understand why MSHSAA and some area schools would want to expand the playoffs to include some of the district runner ups. There's some good teams left out of the playoffs. But those good teams finishing second in district are far outnumbered by those schools who have absolutely no business being in postseason play. A good example is in class 4. Cape Girardeau Central, ranked in the top 10 in state, finished second in districts, ending the season 9-1. They took on DeSoto last night and won 61-28. Two others that went 9-1 and finished second in districts (if I understand correctly), Bolivar and Carthage, are also both ranked in state. It's hard to say they didn't deserve to be there, although those two teams got beat last night.
But when you look at the scores after the first night, there are tons of blowouts. I watched Sikeston and Potosi last night. Sikeston's JV could have beated Potosi. It was just horrible to watch. Granted, the matchup next week of Cape vs Sikeston will be great. However, I just don't think Cape should even be in the playoffs. I'd love to see a breakdown of just how many number 2's actually won last night in all of the classes.
All the added round of games in Missouri means is another round of gate receipts for MSHSAA and some really hideous looking final scores. Very, very few of those district runners-up have any shot at hardware.
Correct thinkers also understand that the "playoffs" actually begin with week 1 of district play under Missouri's rules. Everyone from the likes of Rockhurst & Kearney to Lift For Life and NJROTC start from the same point as of week 8.
If you aren't good enough to win your own district, you're not good enough to win a state title. If that's the case, it's time to get out the basketballs.
So our finals are complete. My school played for the title for the third straight year. The first year we were undefeated going in but kind of got handled in the final, by a team that had beaten the other two nine man eventual champions. The next year we were heavily favored (and undefeated again), but had to squeak by after our second best player blew up his knee. This year we were undefeated again and were matched against a team that was in the largest nine man division last year and went 7-3. This year they too were undefeated, allowing only five touchdowns all year. I assumed we would lose this game. We did lose. 66-0. Holy crap what a squad our opponent was.
For my fellow WG alums, the Statesmen are playing Kirkwood in the state semis on Friday at Kirkwood. Webster should be a big favorite. First time ever for the teams to meet for a title shot. Only the second time they've met in the playoffs, I believe. In '83 we lost to the Pioneers in the quarterfinals at Busch 2 then lost again in the Turkey Day game.
lukethedrifter wrote:For my fellow WG alums, the Statesmen are playing Kirkwood in the state semis on Friday at Kirkwood. Webster should be a big favorite. First time ever for the teams to meet for a title shot. Only the second time they've met in the playoffs, I believe. In '83 we lost to the Pioneers in the quarterfinals at Busch 2 then lost again in the Turkey Day game.
My sister told me about this. Pretty exciting, although it means Turkey Day will be a JV game, right?
Watched my old HS lose at home in the quarterfinals to a good Rochester IL team.
I hadn't been to a game this season, so I was impressed by the level of play on both teams. I'm accustomed to watching the 2A level in MO which is nowhere near as consistent throughout the lineup. Very windy day last Saturday, and both still managed a passing game. Good tackling by both teams and yards didn't come cheap. Great atmosphere.
The thing that scares me about my alma mater is that they really haven't been challenged. Even in the quarters, they won 47-0 on the road. The starters didn't even play in the second half, and they still amassed 487 yards rushing. (QB also was 5 for 6 passing for 47 yards and 2 TDs.) They held the opposition to 87 total yards. Even the sectional game, against a top 10 ranked opponent, wasn't a challenge as they won 40-0.
This week won't be quite as easy, and I'm confident they'll win, but one or two breaks for the other team and I'm uneasy about how they'll deal with adversity.