NFL 2010 Divisonal Playoffs Week

A forum for non-baseball sports
Post Reply
Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: NFL 2010 Divisonal Playoffs Week

Post by Freed Roger »

Socnorb11 wrote:
Freed Roger wrote:
Socnorb11 wrote: Kyle Orton had 3 rookies starting on his offensive line this year, and possibly the worst running game in the league in Denver, and he still put up a better QB rating than Cutler.
That's what I like about the McDaniels hire. He seems to have had good production from Orton -who was generally woeful in Chicago. And he did well enough with Cassel in NE to fool the Chiefs. Rams won't have the "head coach" downside of McDaniels (personell decisions, sideline imcomposure).

( speculation on coordinators by casual fans like me is, um merely speculative.)
Yeah, I think he'd do well as a QB coach. I'm just wondering if he'll be able to keep his ego in check now that he's had HC experience.
I was thinking about that too. After Rams- Martz had to bounce around to a few teams to get his ego in check.

But Bernie Miklasz (of all people) makes a good point - McDaniels road back to becoming a HC requires him to be successful here. If in a couple years he's entertaining HC offers, that probably means the Rams will have accomplished something.

User avatar
thrill
bronoun enthusiast
Posts: 30539
Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
Location: barely online

Re: NFL 2010 Divisonal Playoffs Week

Post by thrill »

Socnorb11 wrote:
thrill wrote:
JL21 wrote:How in the hell are the Packers 3 point favorites? That's just nuts.
Gamblers read too much into week 17 because they think that because Cutler played they excuted a game plan and actually schemed when they didn't.
I've heard this on Chicago talk radio, as well. If the Bears weren't playing to win, their coach should be fired. Because Cutler was out there getting absolutely murdered, and there's no excuse to let that happen if you're not playing to win.

If Cutler had gotten seriously injured and unable to play in the playoffs, and they claimed that they were just going through the motions, I'd be livid as a Bears fan.
They played to win, they just didn't scheme for the Packers. They used it as an opportunity to try and run their offense without game planning for the opponent. There's a difference between mailing it in and trying to win without taking the opponents defensive strengths and weaknesses into account for exploitation. It obviously didn't work very well and I agree with you that Jay should not have played. The Bears coaches, Martz in particular, don't have a stellar track record for protecting QB's.
Socnorb11 wrote:I respectfully disagree. The 2008 Denver Broncos had one of the best offensive lines in football (Cutler was only sacked 11 times all year), terrific wide receivers, and an offensive mastermind for a coach. Cutler still only posted a paltry 86.0 QB rating, and threw 18 interceptions.

Great tools, maybe the best in the league. But virtually nothing between the ears. He's clueless at reading defenses and checking down.

Kyle Orton had 3 rookies starting on his offensive line this year, and possibly the worst running game in the league in Denver, and he still put up a better QB rating than Cutler.
A couple thoughts.

1. Cutler made the Pro Bowl in 2008, threw for 4,526 yards, threw 616 times and completed 384 passes. This is significant to your point for three reasons. First, those stats are all franchise records on a team that featured John Elway for 16 seasons. Calling that a "paltry" season is bad analysis. Second point, the more attempts you throw, the more chance for interceptions and incompletions, two stats that negatively skew Quarterback rating disproportionately the more volume you throw. It's a flawed stat the more attempts and deeper throws a QB attempts. Kyle Orton for example was rewarded by the QB Rating for completing a high volume of short passes in the McDaniels offense. Third, based on the fact that Denver's defense was ranked 30th in the league that season, Jay was forced to overcompensate their shortcomings by running an offense against which the defenses knew he had to throw. Taking all of this into consideration, the only reasonable conclusion you can come to is that for a third year quarterback to perform so well under the circumstances is a testament to how good his season truly was.

2. How's that whole "offensive mastermind" thing going for Mike Shanahan post-Elway & Davis? Not so hot.

Online
Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21913
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: NFL 2010 Divisonal Playoffs Week

Post by Socnorb11 »

JL21 wrote:
Socnorb11 wrote: paltry 86.0 QB rating
82.2 was the league average this year. Last year, it was 81.2. In 2008, it was 81.5. And on and on.

Better than the league average is not "paltry".
Semantics, I suppose. But when you consider the personnel around him, and his skill set, I'd say most people expected better.

Online
Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21913
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: NFL 2010 Divisonal Playoffs Week

Post by Socnorb11 »

thrill wrote: A couple thoughts.

1. Cutler made the Pro Bowl in 2008, threw for 4,526 yards, threw 616 times and completed 384 passes. This is significant to your point for three reasons. First, those stats are all franchise records on a team that featured John Elway for 16 seasons. Calling that a "paltry" season is bad analysis. Second point, the more attempts you throw, the more chance for interceptions and incompletions, two stats that negatively skew Quarterback rating disproportionately the more volume you throw. It's a flawed stat the more attempts and deeper throws a QB attempts. Kyle Orton for example was rewarded by the QB Rating for completing a high volume of short passes in the McDaniels offense. Third, based on the fact that Denver's defense was ranked 30th in the league that season, Jay was forced to overcompensate their shortcomings by running an offense against which the defenses knew he had to throw. Taking all of this into consideration, the only reasonable conclusion you can come to is that for a third year quarterback to perform so well under the circumstances is a testament to how good his season truly was.

2. How's that whole "offensive mastermind" thing going for Mike Shanahan post-Elway & Davis? Not so hot.

1) Jake Plummer went to the Pro Bowl while playing for Mike Shanahan. I'm pretty sure Trent Dilfer went to a Pro Bowl, too. So Pro Bowl doesn't really impress me. You're dismissing quarterback rating for reasons that I don't understand. You are single-handedly deciding which stats have value and which don't. Orton wasn't completing any more short passes than Cutler was. Both had virtually the same yards-per-attempt and yards-per-completion. Concerning Denver's 2008 defense, if you consider that Denver's defense this year was dead last in the league, and their offensive line started 3 rookies, I guess it's quite a testament to Orton that he was able to put up a better QB rating than Cutler.

2) Shanahan's offense was bad this year, but not as bad as Cutler's. Chicago was 30th in total offense.

User avatar
thrill
bronoun enthusiast
Posts: 30539
Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
Location: barely online

Re: NFL 2010 Divisonal Playoffs Week

Post by thrill »

Having been in many discussions similar to this one with you in the past, I'll stop making my case. I like my argument as much as you like yours, so I'll just leave it at that, lol.

Just curious though, what would have to happen for you to change your mind about Cutler?

For me, he'd have to have a game this Sunday where the offensive line gives him a reasonable amount of time and he still makes terrible decisions, specifically how much he tries to force the ball to his safety blankets (Olsen and Bennett) instead of checking down or throwing it away. How many multiple coverages he throws into when it isn't necessary, etc.


Edit - to clarify what I struggled to say about QB rating...attempting more deep passes penalizes quarterbacks unfairly for a few reasons. Basically it's because deep passes are completed at a much lower percentage that short and mid range passes and thus, more likely to be intercepted. Cutler throws more interceptions than Orton precisely because he throws more deep passes. The reason he throws more deep passes is because he has a stronger arm than Orton so his play callers ask him to throw deep while they rarely ask Orton to do the same. Cutler's rating suffers compared to Orton's because he throws more interceptions, he throws more interceptions because he's asked to throw more difficult passes than Orton and he's asked to throw them because he's better at throwing them than Orton. So basically, compared to Cutler, Orton is rewarded by the QB rating for having much less talent than Cutler. Looking at completion percentage, Cutler beats Orton 61.6% to 58.1%. This is made more significant when you factor the amount of more difficult throws Cutler is asked to attempt than Orton. He makes up for the riskier play selection with his arm strength. Cutler's short and mid range passing is more effective than Orton's because the ball gets to the spot quicker.

He's just a way better quarterback than Kyle Orton in every conceivable way. Orton benefits statistically from more conservative play calls because of his physical shortcoming, thus using a flawed stat like QB rating to compare him to Cutler is unfair. I don't know if I did a better job explaining it.

User avatar
InvincibleCakeEater
GRB's obsessive compulsive baseball poster
Posts: 28275
Joined: October 12 07, 12:28 pm
Location: Raptured

Re: NFL 2010 Divisonal Playoffs Week

Post by InvincibleCakeEater »

He's probably dismissing QB rating because it sucks.

User avatar
lukethedrifter
darjeeling sipping elite
Posts: 37260
Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
Location: Huis Clos

Re: NFL 2010 Divisonal Playoffs Week

Post by lukethedrifter »

snobroc isn't the only guy that thinks Cutler is the second coming of Jeff George though he might be proving haterz wrong this season.

Online
Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21913
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: NFL 2010 Divisonal Playoffs Week

Post by Socnorb11 »

lukethedrifter wrote:snobroc isn't the only guy that thinks Cutler is the second coming of Jeff George though he might be proving haterz wrong this season.

He's doing the same thing Rex Grossman did a few years ago. Watching the Bears' defense lead the team deep into the playoffs.

Online
Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21913
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: NFL 2010 Divisonal Playoffs Week

Post by Socnorb11 »

InvincibleCakeEater wrote:He's probably dismissing QB rating because it sucks.
And I'm fine with that opinion. Is there another stat that would make this a better discussion?

Online
Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21913
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: NFL 2010 Divisonal Playoffs Week

Post by Socnorb11 »

thrill wrote:Having been in many discussions similar to this one with you in the past, I'll stop making my case. I like my argument as much as you like yours, so I'll just leave it at that, lol.

Just curious though, what would have to happen for you to change your mind about Cutler?

For me, he'd have to have a game this Sunday where the offensive line gives him a reasonable amount of time and he still makes terrible decisions, specifically how much he tries to force the ball to his safety blankets (Olsen and Bennett) instead of checking down or throwing it away. How many multiple coverages he throws into when it isn't necessary, etc.


Edit - to clarify what I struggled to say about QB rating...attempting more deep passes penalizes quarterbacks unfairly for a few reasons. Basically it's because deep passes are completed at a much lower percentage that short and mid range passes and thus, more likely to be intercepted. Cutler throws more interceptions than Orton precisely because he throws more deep passes. The reason he throws more deep passes is because he has a stronger arm than Orton so his play callers ask him to throw deep while they rarely ask Orton to do the same. Cutler's rating suffers compared to Orton's because he throws more interceptions, he throws more interceptions because he's asked to throw more difficult passes than Orton and he's asked to throw them because he's better at throwing them than Orton. So basically, compared to Cutler, Orton is rewarded by the QB rating for having much less talent than Cutler. Looking at completion percentage, Cutler beats Orton 61.6% to 58.1%. This is made more significant when you factor the amount of more difficult throws Cutler is asked to attempt than Orton. He makes up for the riskier play selection with his arm strength. Cutler's short and mid range passing is more effective than Orton's because the ball gets to the spot quicker.

He's just a way better quarterback than Kyle Orton in every conceivable way. Orton benefits statistically from more conservative play calls because of his physical shortcoming, thus using a flawed stat like QB rating to compare him to Cutler is unfair. I don't know if I did a better job explaining it.
I think you're speculating that Cutler is being asked to do more than Orton. But I don't know that I buy that.

Physical tools are drastically overrated for QB's, in my opinion. It's more of a cererbral position. And from what I've seen, Cutler is poor at reading defenses, checking off, making good decisions, etc. His physical tools will alway make him dangerous, but his lack of complete understanding of the game will keep him from being elite, in my opinion.

When he played in Denver, they blamed it on his horrid defense (as you did, to some extent). Last year, they blamed it on the horrendous running game and lack of skill receivers. This year, they blame it on his offensive line. There's always an excuse for him......... it's never his fault when things go poorly. And when you look at the numbers, things have certainly gone poorly for the Bears' offense this year.

Post Reply