thrill wrote:My cousin tore her MCL playing soccer and didn't get surgery for two weeks because she wanted to walk at graduation. Doctor said, no problem. Wear this brace when you're being active but it's not necessary if all you are doing is walking or riding a bike. However, there's a risk that if you put lateral pressure on it, there's a good chance your knee will either dislocate or your acl and meniscus will tear.
In order to throw a football, one would need to plant his back foot and push off laterally to propel the ball. "Whoops," said reactionary media/fans/players.
Timeout here ... there is too much misinformation being throw around here. Docs can chime in, but here is what I learned about the knee.
Common injuries are MCL tears and ACL tears (PCL far less common), and meniscus tears. It is common to tear all three - the "Terrible Triad" it is called. My son had a grade 3 tear of the MCL, a grade 3 tear of the ACL (almost all ACL tears are grade 3 - you usually completely tear it or you don't and there isn't much in between), and he had torn meniscus. He got the whole ball of wax.
The MCL is on the outside of the knee, and gets good blood flow. You can stretch it (Grade 1), a non-complete tear (Grade 2), or a complete tear (Grade 3). None of those require surgery, as the blood flow allows the ligament to repair itself. So I really doubt your cousin had surgery for an MCL, although she very well could have had her MCL torn.
The ACL is inside the knee, and does not get any blood flow and therefore can not repair itelf. You tear it, the only way to fix it is to build another one. Surgeries typically will NOT happen immediately after the tear, it is generally thought that it is better to get all of the swelling out of the knee before the surgery. 2-4 weeks is typical, and often rehap actually begins BEFORE the surgery. Riding a bike is definitely part of the rehab, you want to strenghten the muscles around the knee before the surgery to help with post surgery rehab. Yes, you can walk and to the uneducated eye can look not hurt. i.e. no limp. Brace is typically worn to prevent any accidental movement which would cause slipping of the tibia and femur. But this idea that you are in a wheelchair or crutches is just completely wrong.
Mensisus is the padding, and often you chew that up when you blow your knee out. Depending on where it happens, you usually need surgery to clean it out. And usually it's in a spot where it won't grow back, although one of the meniscus pads does get blood flow and can repair itself Once cleaned out you don't have the padding that you should, but there shoudl be no stability issues with the knee.
If you blow your PCL out you are in pretty bad shape. THat requires surgery immediately - McGhee did that in the Orange Bowl. Miracle that he is playing at the level he has during his career. But no doubt he's not what he would have been.
If Cutler had a grade 1-2 MCL sprain, he should have played. Completely torn MCL would be very difficult to play on, maybe even more difficult than a torn ACL. Not to mention you reduce stability in the knee with a completely torn MCL and have a higher risk of more damage - meniscus or the ACL.
I knew none of this before my kids knee was blown, I would have thought a torn ACL meant you couldn't walk on it or whatever. But that's not the case, and like thrill said if you need to plant or cut the knee is simply not going to be stable enough to do it. No amount of toughness or pain tolerance in the world is going to cause your knee not to collapse on you.
Hopefully I got most of this right, some of the docs and others who have dealt with this (TFG) can chime in.