Just like the goat and the "cruse". It's all the media people just mailing it in.Michael wrote:Bartman is all media driven.
Steve Bartman
- stlouie_lipp
- Hallelujah Brother
- Posts: 13380
- Joined: April 17 06, 7:36 pm
Re: Steve Bartman
- Sutter'sBeard
- is the oscar meyer weiner kid
- Posts: 3140
- Joined: July 25 06, 1:02 pm
- Location: Decatur, IL
Re: Steve Bartman
Amen! It's like clockwork. For us it's Don Denkinger. Need some fluff to fill the paper. Regurgitate, regurgitate, regurgitate= new story.stlouie_lipp wrote:Just like the goat and the "cruse". It's all the media people just mailing it in.Michael wrote:Bartman is all media driven.
- JL21
- NPR & THT Contributor
- Posts: 36109
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:44 am
- Location: Chocolate City
Re: Steve Bartman
For me, it's not so much Bartman. This is my Cub postseason rant....
(and I'll preface this by saying that it's NOT a knock on Cub fans, it's NOT an all-encompassing thing about Cub fans, or anything like that)
I cringe when I hear someone- usually a dumb celebrity- talk about how the Cubs have suffered more than any other team and fans. Obviously, suffering is not quantifiable. But I'm sorry, the Red Sox endured a hell of a lot more than the Cubs and their fans did. It's not even close.
-Bartman and the meltdown against the Marlins? That same week, AARON FREAKING BOONE did something worse. You see, Boone's dinger was in GAME 7. And Boone played for the Sox' arch-rival.
-Leon Durham's error? Imagine how much worse it would have been if, instead of it being in the LCS, it had been in the World Series. And imagine that the World Series title was so close that they'd already put the champagne in your locker room. Leon Durham is nothing in terms of causing fan suffering compared to Bill Buckner.
-The '69 meltdown? Sure, it was rough, I'm sure. But in the end, they finished a full 8 games back. Imagine if, mid-slide, they'd reversed everything and rebounded in time to re-tie the division, force a one-game playoff, AND were within 12 outs of winning that one-game playoff (against their arch-rivals no less)... only to lose. One was a horrible collapse. The other was a horrible collapse, followed by hope, followed by even more crippling torture in a collapse.
Add on top of that:
-Losses in the '88, '90, and '99 LCS for the Sox (other than '03 and '84, the Cubs haven't been to the LCS)
-Nail-biting 7-game losses in the '46, '67, and '75 World Series (plus the aforementioned '86), with some sort of chicanery haunting each one except '67.
It's insulting to real Sox fans to hear people talk about how much the Cubs and their fans have suffered.
(and I'll preface this by saying that it's NOT a knock on Cub fans, it's NOT an all-encompassing thing about Cub fans, or anything like that)
I cringe when I hear someone- usually a dumb celebrity- talk about how the Cubs have suffered more than any other team and fans. Obviously, suffering is not quantifiable. But I'm sorry, the Red Sox endured a hell of a lot more than the Cubs and their fans did. It's not even close.
-Bartman and the meltdown against the Marlins? That same week, AARON FREAKING BOONE did something worse. You see, Boone's dinger was in GAME 7. And Boone played for the Sox' arch-rival.
-Leon Durham's error? Imagine how much worse it would have been if, instead of it being in the LCS, it had been in the World Series. And imagine that the World Series title was so close that they'd already put the champagne in your locker room. Leon Durham is nothing in terms of causing fan suffering compared to Bill Buckner.
-The '69 meltdown? Sure, it was rough, I'm sure. But in the end, they finished a full 8 games back. Imagine if, mid-slide, they'd reversed everything and rebounded in time to re-tie the division, force a one-game playoff, AND were within 12 outs of winning that one-game playoff (against their arch-rivals no less)... only to lose. One was a horrible collapse. The other was a horrible collapse, followed by hope, followed by even more crippling torture in a collapse.
Add on top of that:
-Losses in the '88, '90, and '99 LCS for the Sox (other than '03 and '84, the Cubs haven't been to the LCS)
-Nail-biting 7-game losses in the '46, '67, and '75 World Series (plus the aforementioned '86), with some sort of chicanery haunting each one except '67.
It's insulting to real Sox fans to hear people talk about how much the Cubs and their fans have suffered.
Online
The Sox suffering has ended, though. I don't think that ANYBODY feels sorry for the Red Sox these days. In fact, they've probably moved into the top 2 teams that NOBODY feels sorry for.
-
Socnorb11
- The Last Word
- Posts: 21909
- Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am
Re: Steve Bartman
RC21 wrote:For me, it's not so much Bartman. This is my Cub postseason rant....
(and I'll preface this by saying that it's NOT a knock on Cub fans, it's NOT an all-encompassing thing about Cub fans, or anything like that)
I cringe when I hear someone- usually a dumb celebrity- talk about how the Cubs have suffered more than any other team and fans. Obviously, suffering is not quantifiable. But I'm sorry, the Red Sox endured a hell of a lot more than the Cubs and their fans did. It's not even close.
-Bartman and the meltdown against the Marlins? That same week, AARON FREAKING BOONE did something worse. You see, Boone's dinger was in GAME 7. And Boone played for the Sox' arch-rival.
-Leon Durham's error? Imagine how much worse it would have been if, instead of it being in the LCS, it had been in the World Series. And imagine that the World Series title was so close that they'd already put the champagne in your locker room. Leon Durham is nothing in terms of causing fan suffering compared to Bill Buckner.
-The '69 meltdown? Sure, it was rough, I'm sure. But in the end, they finished a full 8 games back. Imagine if, mid-slide, they'd reversed everything and rebounded in time to re-tie the division, force a one-game playoff, AND were within 12 outs of winning that one-game playoff (against their arch-rivals no less)... only to lose. One was a horrible collapse. The other was a horrible collapse, followed by hope, followed by even more crippling torture in a collapse.
Add on top of that:
-Losses in the '88, '90, and '99 LCS for the Sox (other than '03 and '84, the Cubs haven't been to the LCS)
-Nail-biting 7-game losses in the '46, '67, and '75 World Series (plus the aforementioned '86), with some sort of chicanery haunting each one except '67.
It's insulting to real Sox fans to hear people talk about how much the Cubs and their fans have suffered.
The Sox suffering has ended, though. I don't think that ANYBODY feels sorry for the Red Sox these days. In fact, they've probably moved into the top 2 teams that NOBODY feels sorry for.
- JL21
- NPR & THT Contributor
- Posts: 36109
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:44 am
- Location: Chocolate City
Re: Steve Bartman
I'm well aware of this. It still doesn't change the fact that the Sox went through a hell of a lot more than the Cubs.Socnorb11 wrote:The Sox suffering has ended, though. I don't think that ANYBODY feels sorry for the Red Sox these days. In fact, they've probably moved into the top 2 teams that NOBODY feels sorry for.
Even still, I think there's an argument to be made that the Indians have suffered more than the Cubs as well. The Tribe got to TWO World Series and had a mini-dynasty in the 90's. In the end, they had no WS title.
Online
I think your Red Sox rant would have been relevant a few years ago, but I think that their suffering has been redeemed.
-
Socnorb11
- The Last Word
- Posts: 21909
- Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am
Re: Steve Bartman
So do you think it's worse to get to the World Series, and fail to win, as opposed to not getting there at all? I'm not sure. Maybe it is worse. As a Cardinal fan, 2004 was awfully painful.......... so I can see that.RC21 wrote:I'm well aware of this. It still doesn't change the fact that the Sox went through a hell of a lot more than the Cubs.Socnorb11 wrote:The Sox suffering has ended, though. I don't think that ANYBODY feels sorry for the Red Sox these days. In fact, they've probably moved into the top 2 teams that NOBODY feels sorry for.
Even still, I think there's an argument to be made that the Indians have suffered more than the Cubs as well. The Tribe got to TWO World Series and had a mini-dynasty in the 90's. In the end, they had no WS title.
I think your Red Sox rant would have been relevant a few years ago, but I think that their suffering has been redeemed.
-
jim
- Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
- Posts: 50393
- Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm
Re: Steve Bartman
I predict Cub fans will stop talking about Steve Bartman when Cardinal fans stop talking about Don Denkinger. And on that day, hell will reach a high of -40F.
- JL21
- NPR & THT Contributor
- Posts: 36109
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:44 am
- Location: Chocolate City
Re: Steve Bartman
I think it's much, much, much worse to get there and lose than it is to not get there at all. You can't have your hopes dashed if you don't have hope.Socnorb11 wrote:So do you think it's worse to get to the World Series, and fail to win, as opposed to not getting there at all? I'm not sure. Maybe it is worse. As a Cardinal fan, 2004 was awfully painful.......... so I can see that.
I respectfully disagree, though I understand your point. One WS title is excellent, awesome, amazing... but it doesn't undo years and years and years of heartache. And it wasn't just the fact that they didn't win. It was HOW they didn't win.I think your Red Sox rant would have been relevant a few years ago, but I think that their suffering has been redeemed.
Of course, it's sort of moot for me anyway because (of obvious reasons) I've never been able to enjoy that '04 WS title much.
-
jim
- Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
- Posts: 50393
- Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm
Re: Steve Bartman
Did you read "Reversing the Curse"? Many Card fans will shy away from that one, but it's really a good book that really gave me some insight into the suffering (and hate of the Yankees). On jim's recommended list.RC21 wrote:I think it's much, much, much worse to get there and lose than it is to not get there at all. You can't have your hopes dashed if you don't have hope.Socnorb11 wrote:So do you think it's worse to get to the World Series, and fail to win, as opposed to not getting there at all? I'm not sure. Maybe it is worse. As a Cardinal fan, 2004 was awfully painful.......... so I can see that.
I respectfully disagree, though I understand your point. One WS title is excellent, awesome, amazing... but it doesn't undo years and years and years of heartache. And it wasn't just the fact that they didn't win. It was HOW they didn't win.I think your Red Sox rant would have been relevant a few years ago, but I think that their suffering has been redeemed.
Of course, it's sort of moot for me anyway because (of obvious reasons) I've never been able to enjoy that '04 WS title much.
Online
I think the difference is that Denkinger unjustly affected the outcome of the game.
Bartman was minding his own business, and did what almost any of us would have done. Denkinger failed to do a job that he was being paid to do.
Alou catching that ball was an extreme long shot. Orta being out was a "sure thing".
There are pretty distinct difference, in my opinion.
-
Socnorb11
- The Last Word
- Posts: 21909
- Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am
Re: Steve Bartman
jim wrote:I predict Cub fans will stop talking about Steve Bartman when Cardinal fans stop talking about Don Denkinger. And on that day, hell will reach a high of -40F.
I think the difference is that Denkinger unjustly affected the outcome of the game.
Bartman was minding his own business, and did what almost any of us would have done. Denkinger failed to do a job that he was being paid to do.
Alou catching that ball was an extreme long shot. Orta being out was a "sure thing".
There are pretty distinct difference, in my opinion.

