Rant: Indie elitists

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: Rant: Indie elitists

Post by Arthur Dent »

Richie Allen wrote:I suppose everyone has the right to like whatever they want for whatever reason but it doesn't mean no one can complain about it.
That wasn't really my point. I just think there is a tendency to romanticize the past when, in fact, there were many of the same deficiencies back then. At least in my experience, there's a lot of great music being made right now, and I get most of it without ever having seen much of the bands' images.

User avatar
Richie Allen
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 7458
Joined: December 22 06, 1:06 am

Re: Rant: Indie elitists

Post by Richie Allen »

Arthur Dent wrote:
Richie Allen wrote:I suppose everyone has the right to like whatever they want for whatever reason but it doesn't mean no one can complain about it.
That wasn't really my point. I just think there is a tendency to romanticize the past when, in fact, there were many of the same deficiencies back then. At least in my experience, there's a lot of great music being made right now, and I get most of it without ever having seen much of the bands' images.
That wasn't in response to anything you said. But since you bring up the romanticizing of the past, you continually rely on that to undermine anything positive that is said about the past. As if there being this term, romanticizing the past, means that nothing in the past could ever be better than it is now or could ever be as good as others make it out to be.

Sure, there's some great music being made now. Does that mean there couldn't be a time when there was better music being made? Or more of it? Do you ever give any credence to opinions other than your own? Would you suggest that the year 1966 was just like every other year in music? Brian Wilson, influenced by The Beatles' Revolver and Rubber Soul, was creating Pet Sounds. The Beatles were knocking off singles like Strawberry Fields and Penny Lane while, at the same time, influenced by what they heard about Pet Sounds, forming Sgt. Pepper. The Stones were at their zenith with albums like Aftermath and Between the Buttons. The Kinks were finishing Something Else and thinking about Village Green. The Zombies were making their best music and Odyssey and Oracle was just around the corner. Dylan had gone electric for good and Highway 61 Revisited was probably the highlight, if not Blonde on Blonde. Otis Redding was at his best, Aretha Franklin was starting to get recognized, Captain Beefheart burst onto the scene and Jamaican Ska was at it's highest point with Toots and the Maytals and Bob Marley making their greatest music. I could go on longer if I wanted to talk about Frank Sinatra releasing his best Reprise album and other important musical landmarks that happened in that single year. Velvet Underground. The Byrds. Frank Zappa. The Lovin' Spoonful. The Animals. The Yardbirds. Buffalo Springfield. The Small Faces. Tim Buckley. Simon & Garfunkel. The Hollies. Ray Charles. The Who. The Sonics. Them (Van Morrison). Marvin Gaye. Love. Stevie Wonder. And I'm still leaving out hundreds of great performers and albums. The point is, I don't think this is simply romanticizing the past and that every year since is comparable. Or that just a much great music is being made today. It's just not. Regardless if you insist on focusing on the fact that there were also bad songs from that year.
Last edited by Richie Allen on January 9 09, 12:33 am, edited 2 times in total.

User avatar
cards2468
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 14745
Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT

Re: Rant: Indie elitists

Post by cards2468 »

With all due respect, Richie Allen, but there is plenty of really good music being made today. I would venture to say there's even more musicians and genres than there ever has been. With new medias influencing kids, and even adults, of course you're going to see Britney Spears and what not getting more attention and appearing to define the new generation, but in reality there's plenty of very good music that is mainstream and plenty that's under ground. Just because new music now doesn't appeal to you the way music of the past does, doesn't make it inferior. I personally listen to music mostly from prior to the 90's, but people that prefer modern music don't offend me. Trust me, I get pretty annoyed with kids that dress and act to match their music, but to me it doesn't degrade their music.

User avatar
Richie Allen
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 7458
Joined: December 22 06, 1:06 am

Re: Rant: Indie elitists

Post by Richie Allen »

cards2468 wrote:With all due respect, Richie Allen, but there is plenty of really good music being made today. I would venture to say there's even more musicians and genres than there ever has been. With new medias influencing kids, and even adults, of course you're going to see Britney Spears and what not getting more attention and appearing to define the new generation, but in reality there's plenty of very good music that is mainstream and plenty that's under ground. Just because new music now doesn't appeal to you the way music of the past does, doesn't make it inferior. I personally listen to music mostly from prior to the 90's, but people that prefer modern music don't offend me. Trust me, I get pretty annoyed with kids that dress and act to match their music, but to me it doesn't degrade their music.
List them. I'm aware of a lot of current music and bands and there's no way it's more prolific than earlier decades. The good bands today might release a new album every 2 or 3 years. I pointed out almost 30 bands that put out landmark albums in a single year from the 1960s. Where is that happening today? The Shins with an album every 4 years? Weezer every 3 years? Belle & Sebastian every 2 or 3 years? In 3 years the Beatles went from She Loves You to Tomorrow Never Knows. And there were about 100 songs in between. You guys can continue to focus on the fact that there is some good music being made today or that I'm romanticizing the past but I think it's pretty obvious that 2009 or 2008 or 2007 or pick any year in the last couple decades is not anywhere near equal to 1966, 1965, 1967, 1968, 1964...when it comes to popular music.

User avatar
redbirdjazzz
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 4921
Joined: April 17 06, 10:50 am
Location: Columbia, MO

Re: Rant: Indie elitists

Post by redbirdjazzz »

Richie Allen wrote:
Arthur Dent wrote:
Richie Allen wrote:I suppose everyone has the right to like whatever they want for whatever reason but it doesn't mean no one can complain about it.
That wasn't really my point. I just think there is a tendency to romanticize the past when, in fact, there were many of the same deficiencies back then. At least in my experience, there's a lot of great music being made right now, and I get most of it without ever having seen much of the bands' images.
That wasn't in response to anything you said. But since you bring up the romanticizing of the past, you continually rely on that to undermine anything positive that is said about the past. As if there being this term, romanticizing the past, means that nothing in the past could ever be better than it is now or could ever be as good as others make it out to be.

Sure, there's some great music being made now. Does that mean there couldn't be a time when there was better music being made? Or more of it? Do you ever give any credence to opinions other than your own? Would you suggest that the year 1966 was just like every other year in music? Brian Wilson, influenced by The Beatles' Revolver and Rubber Soul, was creating Pet Sounds. The Beatles were knocking off singles like Strawberry Fields and Penny Lane while, at the same time, influenced by what they heard about Pet Sounds, forming Sgt. Pepper. The Stones were at their zenith with albums like Aftermath and Between the Buttons. The Kinks were finishing Something Else and thinking about Village Green. The Zombies were making their best music and Odyssey and Oracle was just around the corner. Dylan had gone electric for good and Highway 61 Revisited was probably the highlight, if not Blonde on Blonde. Otis Redding was at his best, Aretha Franklin was starting to get recognized, Captain Beefheart burst onto the scene and Jamaican Ska was at it's highest point with Toots and the Maytals and Bob Marley making their greatest music. I could go on longer if I wanted to talk about Frank Sinatra releasing his best Reprise album and other important musical landmarks that happened in that single year. Velvet Underground. The Byrds. Frank Zappa. The Lovin' Spoonful. The Animals. The Yardbirds. Buffalo Springfield. The Small Faces. Tim Buckley. Simon & Garfunkel. The Hollies. Ray Charles. The Who. The Sonics. Them (Van Morrison). Marvin Gaye. Love. Stevie Wonder. And I'm still leaving out hundreds of great performers and albums. The point is, I don't think this is simply romanticizing the past and that every year since is comparable. Or that just a much great music is being made today. It's just not. Regardless if you insist on focusing on the fact that there were also bad songs from that year.
++

User avatar
haltz
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 22630
Joined: November 9 06, 6:45 am
Location: a proud midwestern metropolis

Re: Rant: Indie elitists

Post by haltz »

Neifi Perez would hit 94 HR in 1966 and Fall Out Boy would be the Beatles.

Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: Rant: Indie elitists

Post by Arthur Dent »

I have nothing against saying good things about the past. I'm just skeptical when people start saying that everything was better back when. There's a human tendency for selective memory of the glory days. There's more great music being made right now than I can handle. Maybe it was even better in the 60s/70s. Maybe there was less lousy music. I don't know. I wasn't there. But even if I was, I wouldn't know how to compare anyways. I'm trying to decide whether music now is better than it was when I was in high school, and I have no idea. I'm tempted to say it's better now, but that's probably has more to due to do with the fact that I look at it in a different way now than changes in the quality of the music being made. My interests are totally context dependent.

User avatar
PujolJunkie
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 10370
Joined: March 22 07, 4:54 pm
Location: north county, stl
Contact:

Re: Rant: Indie elitists

Post by PujolJunkie »

Richie Allen wrote:That's the kind of emotion I like to see about one's music!

Elvis Costello once said something along the lines of when he was a teenager it was all about the music for him and his generation and the clothes and skateboards and whatever was secondary. Today, which was about 15 years ago if I'm remembering correctly, it's about the clothes and the looks and the image first and the music is secondary. A lot of people let things other than the music dictate what they listen to. It's kind of sad and pathetic.
I will admit that a lot of the music I listen to happens to be pop-punkish rock and I completely get people who happen to find that kind of music obnoxious or even manufactured to an extent. Which is more or less the argument these two are making. But my entire argument is the fact that yes, they are something that a certain group of people listen to. But because I listen to them doesn't make me exclusive to that one genre.

I just find it amazing that somebody's excuse for stopping liking a band is that suddenly everybody liked them. Doesn't that just clarify your belief that they're awesome?

User avatar
Richie Allen
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 7458
Joined: December 22 06, 1:06 am

Re: Rant: Indie elitists

Post by Richie Allen »

Well I certainly don't just think everything is better because it's older. I think there is more music I like now than from the 1970s. And for sure the 1990s. And while I like a lot of music from the 1950s and 60s, although I can't stand the "Oldies" stations, I have little interest in jazz from the 60s, although it's most likely considered old.

User avatar
PujolJunkie
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 10370
Joined: March 22 07, 4:54 pm
Location: north county, stl
Contact:

Re: Rant: Indie elitists

Post by PujolJunkie »

haltz wrote:Neifi Perez would hit 94 HR in 1966 and Fall Out Boy would be the Beatles.
This made me laugh so hard and I honestly am not sure why.
Arthur Dent wrote:I have nothing against saying good things about the past. I'm just skeptical when people start saying that everything was better back when. There's a human tendency for selective memory of the glory days. There's more great music being made right now than I can handle. Maybe it was even better in the 60s/70s. Maybe there was less lousy music. I don't know. I wasn't there. But even if I was, I wouldn't know how to compare anyways. I'm trying to decide whether music now is better than it was when I was in high school, and I have no idea. I'm tempted to say it's better now, but that's probably has more to due to do with the fact that I look at it in a different way now than changes in the quality of the music being made. My interests are totally context dependent.
You know, I kind of agree with this and I kinda disagree with it. On one hand, there's a ton of music that I still listen to and love, mostly Motown stuff, Beach Boys, Four Seasons, Marvin Gaye, Sly and the Family, Beatles, etc. But on the other hand, and maybe this is just because I AM that young and I am living through a completely different age, I find this age in music to be unmatched. I think anybody who lives through a certain musical era at it's peak will say the same thing about that era.

Post Reply