ThatGuy wrote:Wait, wait.
There are other countries in the world?
Yeah, but real people don't live in them, so don't worry.
maddash wrote:JCShutout wrote:The irony is I padded every (all 4) criticism with 2 or 3 examples of why our country is great. Apparantly, if the ratio is under 4:1, you hate America.
Ah, the complement sandwich. Nice.
What were the criticisms?
The emails and arguments did start with him, and I let myself get roped in again.
1) The constitution is not a perfect document. Yes you need the rule of law, but we have to take into account that this law was created by people, in a certain historical situation, who have their own grudges, and in a time when the majority of the people in the country (women and minorities and in many cases, those who did not own land) did not have a say in the laws. (Geez that's barely a criticism. All I'm saying it and Franklin are not a gods). You have to have balance between changing things too rapidly, and being irrelevant to the needs of the time. I know, total anarchism.
2) The situation for workers in the 19th century was pretty [expletive] due to corrupt business and government, and that unions (even though some/many are corrupt now) were helpful to workers. (His claim was that the situation was not [expletive] for workers in this country compared to the rest of the world and that unions were the cause of corruption, my comeback was that both the situation for American and non American workers were pretty [expletive], and then he went into how I hate America)
3) He commented that the working class would not sit idly by as their property and resources were taken from them. Stating that while I didn't want the government to take property from people, I asked him how private property was originally obtained. (So its okay to take from brown and red people, but if you take from white people its EVIL SOCIALISM!!! - and my point wasn't that we should take land, but to more critically think about people's access to land, resources and power concerning privledge)
4) While I'm critical and scared of big government, I'm equally critical and scared of big business. (obviously I'm from the Kremlin)
Honestly, that's it, and I even tried to build on his concerns to a workable dialogue about where we share values, but he just kept trying to turn it into "if you don't agree with me, you're the downfall of the country" (he has told me in person that people like me will be the downfall of the US).
He is the Catholic Hierarchy. Replace the constitution with "church tradition" and the founding fathers with the pope and my dad is what he hates. He critiques them for thinking the way he does.