Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
- StatmanCrothers
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 6461
- Joined: April 17 06, 6:50 am
- Location: Boston burbs
- Contact:
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
So Geffen knew it was a good album. they pushed it. but if it hadn't been all kinds of awesome, it wouldn't have caught on regardless. the infrastructure for something like Nirvana to get played on the radio at all just wasn't there.
the record release party was fun but it wasn't packed.
a few week later, in December (album came out in November) I saw Nirvana were playing Stache's (in Columbus) about a 90 min drive from Cincy. It was 3rd date for Mrs Statman and I ... Urge Overkill opened, a sign that Nirvana was moving up the indie-rock ladder but it was still a very small bar/club, like maybe seeing them at Double Door in Chicago. They were very good. Word was getting out it was packed.
Six months later they were playing huge arenas, and not only was alt-rock getting played on mainstream radio, but rocking alt-rock!
the floodgates were open and truly, music was changed drastically. like any good thing, the major labels ruined it, signing anybody and their brother who kinda-sorta sounded like that Nirvana band, spawning some good with a tons of bad...
But the type of music that is now considered mainstream for the early 90s, and what that has evolved into for today, is due in large part to the insane catchiness and awesomeness of that one song "Smells Like Teen Spirit"
I bear witness. It was a huge change, and a generation of youth grew up listening to Smashing Pumpkins and Bush and Radiohead, where their older brothers were weened on Whitesnake, Warrant and Cinderella.
the record release party was fun but it wasn't packed.
a few week later, in December (album came out in November) I saw Nirvana were playing Stache's (in Columbus) about a 90 min drive from Cincy. It was 3rd date for Mrs Statman and I ... Urge Overkill opened, a sign that Nirvana was moving up the indie-rock ladder but it was still a very small bar/club, like maybe seeing them at Double Door in Chicago. They were very good. Word was getting out it was packed.
Six months later they were playing huge arenas, and not only was alt-rock getting played on mainstream radio, but rocking alt-rock!
the floodgates were open and truly, music was changed drastically. like any good thing, the major labels ruined it, signing anybody and their brother who kinda-sorta sounded like that Nirvana band, spawning some good with a tons of bad...
But the type of music that is now considered mainstream for the early 90s, and what that has evolved into for today, is due in large part to the insane catchiness and awesomeness of that one song "Smells Like Teen Spirit"
I bear witness. It was a huge change, and a generation of youth grew up listening to Smashing Pumpkins and Bush and Radiohead, where their older brothers were weened on Whitesnake, Warrant and Cinderella.
- StatmanCrothers
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 6461
- Joined: April 17 06, 6:50 am
- Location: Boston burbs
- Contact:
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
He had a host of Nashville session musicians on that album (including Charlie Daniels)...MrSaigon wrote:When I listen to the Unplugged album it sounds like Cobain couldn't even fret the strings. I'm sure that was just a style thing, because he really is a good guitarist (if not the 12th best ever). That's always bothered me though.TheoSqua wrote:Kurt Cobain was a phenominal song writer. Smells Like Teen Sprit is a great song and is well written. So i guess it depends on your definition of greatness in guitar playing.
You absolutely cannot compare him to some of the amazing technical guitarists, he would have never gotten an invite to G3. But when it comes to songwriting, in the vien of someone like Bob Dylan - whose musical talents are fairly limited from a technical standpoint but brilliant in that tons of people love listening to it - Kurt Cobain is easily one of the 100 most talented popular guitarists of the past decade.
About Dylan, did he play the most intricate guitar pieces on his early albums? I know his guitar playing was largely shot after the motorcycle accident. But he could pick it pretty good when he was a kid. Did he play guitar on 'Girl from the North Country'? That's a brilliant guitar song.
I've listend to a lot of early Dylan albums and he's a fine stylist but I've always thought of him as merely an adequate folk guitarist.
Online
- Popeye_Card
- GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
- Posts: 31097
- Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
The guitarist thing just bugs me because there was absolutely nothing special about his guitar playing technically, nor were any of the riffs anything iconic. Their reasoning was basically the same as all the justification for Nirvana praise--HE ENDED THE BUTT ROCK!--but hell, 90% of hair bad guitarists wipe the floor with Cobain. You're honestly going to tell me that he's a "greater" guitarist than Slash? There is no way on earth you can justify that. None.
The undisputed greatest guitar player of all time once said, "Heaven is lying at Buddy Guy's feet while listening to him play guitar.". That gets you a 30th rank. Being at the right place at the right time to end butt rock gets you 12th. The list is thus freaking worthless.
The undisputed greatest guitar player of all time once said, "Heaven is lying at Buddy Guy's feet while listening to him play guitar.". That gets you a 30th rank. Being at the right place at the right time to end butt rock gets you 12th. The list is thus freaking worthless.
- JackofDiamonds
- Bringer of Boston Baked Blue Balls
- Posts: 15010
- Joined: April 16 06, 9:15 pm
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
Popeye_Card wrote:The guitarist thing just bugs me because there was absolutely nothing special about his guitar playing technically, nor were any of the riffs anything iconic. Their reasoning was basically the same as all the justification for Nirvana praise--HE ENDED THE BUTT ROCK!--but hell, 90% of hair bad guitarists wipe the floor with Cobain. You're honestly going to tell me that he's a "greater" guitarist than Slash? There is no way on earth you can justify that. None.
The undisputed greatest guitar player of all time once said, "Heaven is lying at Buddy Guy's feet while listening to him play guitar.". That gets you a 30th rank. Being at the right place at the right time to end butt rock gets you 12th. The list is thus freaking worthless.
I love Jimi's "Blues" album. I think it's his greatest achievement, though I would have loved to see Band of Gypsies get a chance to develop a little more.
- StatmanCrothers
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 6461
- Joined: April 17 06, 6:50 am
- Location: Boston burbs
- Contact:
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
i agree the Rolling Stone guitarist list is ridiculous. just bizarre and pointlessPopeye_Card wrote:The guitarist thing just bugs me because there was absolutely nothing special about his guitar playing technically, nor were any of the riffs anything iconic. Their reasoning was basically the same as all the justification for Nirvana praise--HE ENDED THE BUTT ROCK!--but hell, 90% of hair bad guitarists wipe the floor with Cobain. You're honestly going to tell me that he's a "greater" guitarist than Slash? There is no way on earth you can justify that. None.
The undisputed greatest guitar player of all time once said, "Heaven is lying at Buddy Guy's feet while listening to him play guitar.". That gets you a 30th rank. Being at the right place at the right time to end butt rock gets you 12th. The list is thus freaking worthless.
- JackofDiamonds
- Bringer of Boston Baked Blue Balls
- Posts: 15010
- Joined: April 16 06, 9:15 pm
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
This is all really cool by the way.StatmanCrothers wrote:So Geffen knew it was a good album. they pushed it. but if it hadn't been all kinds of awesome, it wouldn't have caught on regardless. the infrastructure for something like Nirvana to get played on the radio at all just wasn't there.
the record release party was fun but it wasn't packed.
a few week later, in December (album came out in November) I saw Nirvana were playing Stache's (in Columbus) about a 90 min drive from Cincy. It was 3rd date for Mrs Statman and I ... Urge Overkill opened, a sign that Nirvana was moving up the indie-rock ladder but it was still a very small bar/club, like maybe seeing them at Double Door in Chicago. They were very good. Word was getting out it was packed.
Six months later they were playing huge arenas, and not only was alt-rock getting played on mainstream radio, but rocking alt-rock!
the floodgates were open and truly, music was changed drastically. like any good thing, the major labels ruined it, signing anybody and their brother who kinda-sorta sounded like that Nirvana band, spawning some good with a tons of bad...
But the type of music that is now considered mainstream for the early 90s, and what that has evolved into for today, is due in large part to the insane catchiness and awesomeness of that one song "Smells Like Teen Spirit"
I bear witness. It was a huge change, and a generation of youth grew up listening to Smashing Pumpkins and Bush and Radiohead, where their older brothers were weened on Whitesnake, Warrant and Cinderella.
- ghostrunner
- GOAT
- Posts: 30873
- Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
Hey Stat, don't know if I mentioned it here, but WOXY.com, which was the internet version (simulcast with the radio station for a time) of 97x finally kicked the bucket back in March. They'd moved from Cincy down to Austin and it looked good for a while, but the owners couldn't keep up with the bills.StatmanCrothers wrote:... but i was already a fan of "Smells Like Teen Spirit" their new single which I'd taped off the 2-hour "Gridloxx" underground alternative show on 97X (Bam! The Future of Rock and Roll) ...
Online
- Popeye_Card
- GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
- Posts: 31097
- Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
So the future of rock and roll was pretty short-lived, huh? I think I agree if all we are going to get is more Nickelback clones...
-
MrSaigon
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
It was a nice respite, grunge was, between synth-pop and butt rock and Creed and Linkin Park. But it was a nice run.Popeye_Card wrote:So the future of rock and roll was pretty short-lived, huh? I think I agree if all we are going to get is more Nickelback clones...
Thanks for the perspective, Mr. Crothers. All I know is I was listening to Clint Black and Garth Brooks in seventh grade, then I noticed everyone wearing cardigans and flannels, and shortly thereafter my musical taste expanded dramatically.
- InvincibleCakeEater
- GRB's obsessive compulsive baseball poster
- Posts: 28275
- Joined: October 12 07, 12:28 pm
- Location: Raptured
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
I agree for the most part and would say 100% of hair metal guitarists could wipe the floor with Cobain. I'm no musical prodigy, but was playing every single note of Nirvana songs at 12. It's just easy.Popeye_Card wrote:The guitarist thing just bugs me because there was absolutely nothing special about his guitar playing technically, nor were any of the riffs anything iconic. Their reasoning was basically the same as all the justification for Nirvana praise--HE ENDED THE BUTT ROCK!--but hell, 90% of hair bad guitarists wipe the floor with Cobain. You're honestly going to tell me that he's a "greater" guitarist than Slash? There is no way on earth you can justify that. None.
The undisputed greatest guitar player of all time once said, "Heaven is lying at Buddy Guy's feet while listening to him play guitar.". That gets you a 30th rank. Being at the right place at the right time to end butt rock gets you 12th. The list is thus freaking worthless.
And you must be confused, that's Jimi's quote, not Jeff Beck's. /snobbery


