Page 2 of 4

Re: Arguably

Posted: July 30 10, 1:06 pm
by TheoSqua
Spider John wrote:
vinsanity wrote:
The Third Man wrote:The best example of this I can think of was when Wikipedia's article on Pujols referred to him as "arguably one of the best hitters in baseball."
This one makes sense.

He is definitely one of the best hitters in baseball.
There's no argument that he's one of the best, but Wiki says the fact is arguable.
But it's not really arguable. Based upon statistics of his first 10 seasons, there's no doubt that he falls under "the best" regardless of what definition or context you use to define "best".

Re: Arguably

Posted: July 30 10, 1:10 pm
by vinsanity
TheoSqua wrote:
Spider John wrote:
vinsanity wrote:
The Third Man wrote:The best example of this I can think of was when Wikipedia's article on Pujols referred to him as "arguably one of the best hitters in baseball."
This one makes sense.

He is definitely one of the best hitters in baseball.
There's no argument that he's one of the best, but Wiki says the fact is arguable.
But it's not really arguable. Based upon statistics of his first 10 seasons, there's no doubt that he falls under "the best" regardless of what definition or context you use to define "best".
That's point. When I said it makes sense, it makes sense in the context of the rant. As opposed to saying 'arguably the best player in baseball' - Pujols being the best player today is arguable, saying he is one of the best isn't really.

Re: Arguably

Posted: July 30 10, 2:11 pm
by TheoSqua
vinsanity wrote:
TheoSqua wrote:
Spider John wrote:
vinsanity wrote:
The Third Man wrote:The best example of this I can think of was when Wikipedia's article on Pujols referred to him as "arguably one of the best hitters in baseball."
This one makes sense.

He is definitely one of the best hitters in baseball.
There's no argument that he's one of the best, but Wiki says the fact is arguable.
But it's not really arguable. Based upon statistics of his first 10 seasons, there's no doubt that he falls under "the best" regardless of what definition or context you use to define "best".
That's point. When I said it makes sense, it makes sense in the context of the rant. As opposed to saying 'arguably the best player in baseball' - Pujols being the best player today is arguable, saying he is one of the best isn't really.
And I was replying to Spider John, not you.

Re: Arguably

Posted: July 30 10, 2:19 pm
by Spider John
TheoSqua wrote:
vinsanity wrote:
TheoSqua wrote:
Spider John wrote:
vinsanity wrote:
The Third Man wrote:The best example of this I can think of was when Wikipedia's article on Pujols referred to him as "arguably one of the best hitters in baseball."
This one makes sense.

He is definitely one of the best hitters in baseball.
There's no argument that he's one of the best, but Wiki says the fact is arguable.
But it's not really arguable. Based upon statistics of his first 10 seasons, there's no doubt that he falls under "the best" regardless of what definition or context you use to define "best".
That's point. When I said it makes sense, it makes sense in the context of the rant. As opposed to saying 'arguably the best player in baseball' - Pujols being the best player today is arguable, saying he is one of the best isn't really.
And I was replying to Spider John, not you.

You and I agree, Theo. I misunderstood what Vin was saying, and was pointing out that Wiki was in error with the use of "arguably" concerning AP being one of the best.

Re: Arguably

Posted: July 30 10, 3:11 pm
by TheoSqua
Spider John wrote:
TheoSqua wrote:
vinsanity wrote:
TheoSqua wrote:
Spider John wrote:
vinsanity wrote:
The Third Man wrote:The best example of this I can think of was when Wikipedia's article on Pujols referred to him as "arguably one of the best hitters in baseball."
This one makes sense.

He is definitely one of the best hitters in baseball.
There's no argument that he's one of the best, but Wiki says the fact is arguable.
But it's not really arguable. Based upon statistics of his first 10 seasons, there's no doubt that he falls under "the best" regardless of what definition or context you use to define "best".
That's point. When I said it makes sense, it makes sense in the context of the rant. As opposed to saying 'arguably the best player in baseball' - Pujols being the best player today is arguable, saying he is one of the best isn't really.
And I was replying to Spider John, not you.

You and I agree, Theo. I misunderstood what Vin was saying, and was pointing out that Wiki was in error with the use of "arguably" concerning AP being one of the best.
Image

Re: Arguably

Posted: July 30 10, 3:32 pm
by cardsfansince82
This is arguably one of the better threads posted in the Rants forum today.

Re: Arguably

Posted: July 30 10, 8:10 pm
by Schlich
I'm thinking broadcasters just use it as a safety blanket for accidentally saying something wrong.

Re: Arguably

Posted: July 30 10, 8:18 pm
by obucard
RxOfCowbell wrote:I'm thinking broadcasters just use it as a safety blanket for accidentally saying something wrong.
Or for saying something other people might disagree with.

Re: Arguably

Posted: July 30 10, 8:33 pm
by Schlich
obucard wrote:
RxOfCowbell wrote:I'm thinking broadcasters just use it as a safety blanket for accidentally saying something wrong.
Or for saying something other people might disagree with.
i guess that's more of what i meant.

Re: Arguably

Posted: July 31 10, 7:15 pm
by go birds
lol dan just said it again