Saints' bounty program

A forum for non-baseball sports
Post Reply
AWvsCBsteeeerike3
"I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
Posts: 27578
Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
Location: Thinking of the Children

Re: Saints' bounty program

Post by AWvsCBsteeeerike3 »

bob thrill wrote:So what's your point? That the league should just turn a blind eye and not punish them? They tried to take care of this through back channels for three years, but it didn't stop.
My point is its a stupid punishment that doesn't fit the crime and it is done for a PR and monetary reason that villifies a behavior that when all the bs is stripped away is the at the very core of the NFL. So....villify that behavior or don't. And, the righteousness of some people saying how the bounty system is horrible but the NFL is great is ridiculous. It's the same behavior. Hit the everliving [expletive] out of people. It's the same with or without bounties.

AWvsCBsteeeerike3
"I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
Posts: 27578
Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
Location: Thinking of the Children

Re: Saints' bounty program

Post by AWvsCBsteeeerike3 »

vinsanity wrote: Again; there's a difference between between legally hitting a guy as hard as you can and coaches encouraging you to break a rule to purposefully injure a guy. The bounty wasn't for 'subjectively hard hits' it was to make a player leave the field of play because of the hit.
Which legal hits do all the time.
Car accidents happen and people get hurt, but wouldn't you be pissed if the insurance company paid people to intentionally t-bone you and make your insurance rates go up?
Yes. Of course. But...you do realize the NFL (insurance company) is paying people to go out and intentinoally hit (t-bone) players without bounties. So...I don't really understand what your point is.
Your Raiders comparison; say both teams had the same amount of penalties - ok fine. Say they caused the same number of injuries. But if the Raiders were offering bounties they would have had more. If the Saints weren't they would have had less.
So...you even admit that the Saints were no more dangerous than the Raiders. I guess if player safety is the concern then the Raiders should be suspended as well. And, I still don't agree that removing bounties makes that big of a difference, if any at all.
Edit - So if I'm a blindside corner blitzing and I know my coach docks me $10k for a late hit and I know I can pull up on Favre after he throws, I do. If my coach is going to give me $10k for taking him out of the game and doesn't care if it's penalized, I wouldn't pull up. If he still has the ball, one way or the other I'm going to hit him as hard as I legally can without a bounty. If there's a bounty I'd probably slide in feet first to cleat his bad ankle.
That's so presumptious I don't know where to begin. How do you know the coach didn't care about getting a penalty? Show me a vido of a guy sliding in feet first because of a bounty. And, I'll show you one where there's not a bounty perse.

Maybe those two extra games wouldn't be as dangerous for players if the NFL used proper helmets and teams weren't paying players to injure, not hit hard, physically take a player out of the game.[/quote]

User avatar
Transmogrified Tiger
Puppy Murderer
Posts: 9323
Joined: April 25 06, 6:07 pm
Location: Across the River

Re: Saints' bounty program

Post by Transmogrified Tiger »

AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:
bob thrill wrote:So what's your point? That the league should just turn a blind eye and not punish them? They tried to take care of this through back channels for three years, but it didn't stop.
My point is its a stupid punishment that doesn't fit the crime and it is done for a PR and monetary reason that villifies a behavior that when all the bs is stripped away is the at the very core of the NFL. So....villify that behavior or don't. And, the righteousness of some people saying how the bounty system is horrible but the NFL is great is ridiculous. It's the same behavior. Hit the everliving [expletive] out of people. It's the same with or without bounties.
Do you think the punishment would have been the same if the Saints had told the truth the first time they were asked about the program?

User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: Saints' bounty program

Post by vinsanity »

I guess the bottom line for me is; why wouldn't you punish a coach for encouraging players to injure someone else? Do you not distinguish between a hard, legal play that accidentally causes an injury and an unnecessary illegal play that results in injury?

My point with the car analogy was accidents happen, by definition not on purpose. People get t-boned on accident all the time. Sometimes there's an injury because of it. But if the insurance company is paying someone to intentionally get in to those wrecks, it's not an accident. It's not the 'risk' I agreed to on the road. It may or may not cause an injury in each case, but will almost certainly cause one that could have been prevented if someone wasn't intentionally t-boning other cars.

Encouraging behavior that increases the risk to an already risky endeavor should not be tolerated.

For reference, what do you think the punishments should have been?

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: Saints' bounty program

Post by Freed Roger »

AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:
bob thrill wrote:So what's your point? That the league should just turn a blind eye and not punish them? They tried to take care of this through back channels for three years, but it didn't stop.
My point is its a stupid punishment that doesn't fit the crime and it is done for a PR and monetary reason that villifies a behavior that when all the bs is stripped away is the at the very core of the NFL. So....villify that behavior or don't. And, the righteousness of some people saying how the bounty system is horrible but the NFL is great is ridiculous. It's the same behavior. Hit the everliving [expletive] out of people. It's the same with or without bounties.

Man, it's been a long time since I played football. But hitting hard and hitting for injuries are two different things and everybody knows the difference. I've been on the field where I've seen a clean break of bones (clean hit-kickoff return-tibia or fibia). Nobody likes that [expletive] whether clean or not.

Obviously a legal clean hit can and does cause injury, but there are many many times where guys get injured untouched. IIRC Jamal Anderson of Dirty Bird fame- Falcons blew his ACL on an open field cut.

I think I commented during the season that the NFL has a major problem with keeping its star players healthy. This season sucked, IMO, because of it. Its a problem regardless of a bounty program. Yet, outside of banning the game itself - they aren't going to get anywhere with injuries until they get rid of the problem areas that they can go after - the intentional injuries and dirty hits -the blind sides, head shots, knee shots, spearing, late hits. And getting rid of a bounty program being the most obvious of these all.

AWvsCBsteeeerike3
"I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
Posts: 27578
Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
Location: Thinking of the Children

Re: Saints' bounty program

Post by AWvsCBsteeeerike3 »

Transmogrified Tiger wrote:
AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:
bob thrill wrote:So what's your point? That the league should just turn a blind eye and not punish them? They tried to take care of this through back channels for three years, but it didn't stop.
My point is its a stupid punishment that doesn't fit the crime and it is done for a PR and monetary reason that villifies a behavior that when all the bs is stripped away is the at the very core of the NFL. So....villify that behavior or don't. And, the righteousness of some people saying how the bounty system is horrible but the NFL is great is ridiculous. It's the same behavior. Hit the everliving [expletive] out of people. It's the same with or without bounties.
Do you think the punishment would have been the same if the Saints had told the truth the first time they were asked about the program?

I have no clue about the timeline. I think if this had never been uncovered by the media, the punishment might have not even occured to keep the story out of the media.

AWvsCBsteeeerike3
"I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
Posts: 27578
Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
Location: Thinking of the Children

Re: Saints' bounty program

Post by AWvsCBsteeeerike3 »

vinsanity wrote:I guess the bottom line for me is; why wouldn't you punish a coach for encouraging players to injure someone else? Do you not distinguish between a hard, legal play that accidentally causes an injury and an unnecessary illegal play that results in injury?

My point with the car analogy was accidents happen, by definition not on purpose. People get t-boned on accident all the time. Sometimes there's an injury because of it. But if the insurance company is paying someone to intentionally get in to those wrecks, it's not an accident. It's not the 'risk' I agreed to on the road. It may or may not cause an injury in each case, but will almost certainly cause one that could have been prevented if someone wasn't intentionally t-boning other cars.

Encouraging behavior that increases the risk to an already risky endeavor should not be tolerated.

For reference, what do you think the punishments should have been?
I don't really care. The punishment? Who knows... I simply stated the punishments were too harsh to reiterate that I'm not arguing a strawman. This was an overreaction by the league to villify the very lifeblood that it relies on.

But, to give you a finite answer you can attack, I'll say they should have done the following:

Take away the Saints 2nd round pick. Fine everyone else an undisclosed amount.
More importantly.....
Implemented a 1 game suspension for any player that knocks another player out of a game on a clean hit.
Implemented a 3 game suspension for any player that knocks another player out of a game for a dirty hit.
Implemented a minimum 6 game suspension for any helmet to helmet tackle. After said suspension, if there is another incident with the same player, it's a minimum year suspension. After that, it's a lifetime ban.
Do stuff like this....and then start talking about how you are trying to avoid injuries. Of course, that will never happen, especially the first two, because the league relies on precisely those type of hits for it's insane popularity.

BTW, I don't even know if I would be in favor of all that stuff above, I don't watch the NFL. But...at least they would have a point that they were worried about player safety if they did something like that....not just create a whipping boy and whip the [expletive] out of him.

User avatar
cpebbles
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 8829
Joined: August 30 07, 12:28 pm

Re: Saints' bounty program

Post by cpebbles »

Up/down by 2 scores against a division rival, get "knocked out" of the game by their best defender.

User avatar
Transmogrified Tiger
Puppy Murderer
Posts: 9323
Joined: April 25 06, 6:07 pm
Location: Across the River

Re: Saints' bounty program

Post by Transmogrified Tiger »

AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:
Transmogrified Tiger wrote:
AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:
bob thrill wrote:So what's your point? That the league should just turn a blind eye and not punish them? They tried to take care of this through back channels for three years, but it didn't stop.
My point is its a stupid punishment that doesn't fit the crime and it is done for a PR and monetary reason that villifies a behavior that when all the bs is stripped away is the at the very core of the NFL. So....villify that behavior or don't. And, the righteousness of some people saying how the bounty system is horrible but the NFL is great is ridiculous. It's the same behavior. Hit the everliving [expletive] out of people. It's the same with or without bounties.
Do you think the punishment would have been the same if the Saints had told the truth the first time they were asked about the program?

I have no clue about the timeline. I think if this had never been uncovered by the media, the punishment might have not even occured to keep the story out of the media.
The league came to the Saints long before the media had any idea about the situation, and the Saints denied it all. Don't you think the severity of the punishment has to do with the cover up as much as condemning the specific program?

User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: Saints' bounty program

Post by vinsanity »

AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:But, to give you a finite answer you can attack, I'll say they should have done the following:
Why would I attack the answer to a question I asked? I'm legitimately just trying to understand you on the situation because I'm not clear if you think bounties on injuries are perfectly acceptable or if you agreed they should get in trouble, bounties should go away but it's just not a 'big deal'. Just curious what you thought was fair.
Do stuff like this....and then start talking about how you are trying to avoid injuries. Of course, that will never happen, especially the first two, because the league relies on precisely those type of hits for it's insane popularity.
Where did they say they were trying to avoid injuries? They said they wanted protect players. The point of the game is to hit hard. It is to move fast. When you do those things, injuries will happen. You could put them in bubble wrap, outlaw all contact, play flag football and injuries will happen. They wanted to protect players from needless injuries encouraged by the coaches.

I agree the NFL could do a lot more. They could enforce properly fitted helmets. They could require concussion reducing helmets. They could and probably should punish people with the head-to-head and late hit penalties more severely. Some of the policies recently have been moving in that direction.

If you found out Chapman was offered a $10k bonus to put one in Matt Holliday's/David Freese's/Berkamn's/Molina's ear hole wouldn't you want that behavior outlawed? Wouldn't you want Baker and Mack Jenkins and Walt Jocketty to be punished for telling a guy with 100mph fastball to throw at a guys head?

Post Reply