BW23 wrote:Sikeston's done. They got whooped by a superior team in Helias. Sikeston played awful, most of which was caused by Helias' great play. Sad to see such a great team end the season that way. The private schools strike again.
Private school,schmivate school. That's an excuse for losing and accepting that premise is a guaranteed way to keep making early exits from post season. That sort of talk should not be tolerated at Sikeston or anywhere else where people wish to have championship grade FB programs.
Helias gets it done by playing smart football. They aren't exactly overrun with D-1 or even a lot of D-2 kids. That's how Jeff City HS has done it for over 50 years. That's what Blair Oaks has done for the last decade or so. They got battered a few times by Monroe City and smartened up their approach.
From the early 90's until the chronic whiners got the multiplier passed, the likes of Monroe City, Centralia and Palmyra acquitted themselves very well against the likes of John Burroughs and Lutheran North.
not to blow your passing comment out of proportion BW, but I have to agree with Bugtussle's post. Especially for HS football. Sure there is some recruiting in a few local STL private schools, but for the most part they probably lose more players to public schools on account of tuition costs than they could ever recruit.
Now basketball, where a couple players can make a good team great, the recruiting happens. see movie "Hoop Dreams." But that is more of a big city thing - Chicago, and St L to lesser extent, not in Jeff City.
Bugtussle may recall a time when it was the public school in our town that was rumored to recruit/set up players for basketball.
And I'm not a fan of the multiplier either - its commie bull crap where the enrollment at private school is factored to put them in a higher class. My experience with private schools, especially those in smaller towns like Jeff City is that they can have good sports not because they have more money and buy players, its more because the families that sacrifice financially to send their kids to private schools have a vested interest in the school and its activities.
They play by different rules. They should have separate playoffs.
Freed Roger wrote:
And I'm not a fan of the multiplier either - its commie bull crap where the enrollment at private school is factored to put them in a higher class. My experience with private schools, especially those in smaller towns like Jeff City is that they can have good sports not because they have more money and buy players, its more because the families that sacrifice financially to send their kids to private schools have a vested interest in the school and its activities.
My #1 beef with the multiplier is that it sends the message to the kid at the Class 1 or Class 2 school that "YOU AREN'T AS GOOD AS THE KID AT THE PRIVATE SCHOOL!"
Of course the self proclaimed education geniuses who dreamed this crap up didn't have enough brain power to consider that angle.
I don't know the history of states other than Illinois but I think the multiplier is a good idea. Take a look at the state champions of the past in Illinois and I bet at least a third of them are private schools. Mt. Carmel (Chicago) is(or at least used to be) an all boys school. With having your whole student body as possible players, it gives you an unfair advantage over similar sized schools with half girls.
Sutter'sBeard wrote:
I don't know the history of states other than Illinois but I think the multiplier is a good idea. Take a look at the state champions of the past in Illinois and I bet at least a third of them are private schools. Mt. Carmel (Chicago) is(or at least used to be) an all boys school. With having your whole student body as possible players, it gives you an unfair advantage over similar sized schools with half girls.
No multiplier in the real world. There is no rational reason for having one in the educational world--where we allegedly prepare kids for the real world.
The whole multiplier is a crutch. Only cripples need crutches.
Freed Roger wrote:
And I'm not a fan of the multiplier either - its commie bull crap where the enrollment at private school is factored to put them in a higher class. My experience with private schools, especially those in smaller towns like Jeff City is that they can have good sports not because they have more money and buy players, its more because the families that sacrifice financially to send their kids to private schools have a vested interest in the school and its activities.
My #1 beef with the multiplier is that it sends the message to the kid at the Class 1 or Class 2 school that "YOU AREN'T AS GOOD AS THE KID AT THE PRIVATE SCHOOL!"
Of course the self proclaimed education geniuses who dreamed this crap up didn't have enough brain power to consider that angle.
I don't know the history of states other than Illinois but I think the multiplier is a good idea. Take a look at the state champions of the past in Illinois and I bet at least a third of them are private schools. Mt. Carmel (Chicago) is(or at least used to be) an all boys school. With having your whole student body as possible players, it gives you an unfair advantage over similar sized schools with half girls.
I assume every state either counts only eligible (male) population or doubles it for single gender schools. What they are referring to is a system where either private schools have their own playoffs (BW is for this) or, like the system in Mo, private schools population is multiplied by something like 1.2 bumping up the borderline schools to the next higher class.
In MO they actually split the highest class in two so that there are only 32 teams per class as opposed to 64 or so for all the others.
Sutter'sBeard wrote:
I don't know the history of states other than Illinois but I think the multiplier is a good idea. Take a look at the state champions of the past in Illinois and I bet at least a third of them are private schools. Mt. Carmel (Chicago) is(or at least used to be) an all boys school. With having your whole student body as possible players, it gives you an unfair advantage over similar sized schools with half girls.
No multiplier in the real world. There is no rational reason for having one in the educational world--where we allegedly prepare kids for the real world.
The whole multiplier is a crutch. Only cripples need crutches.
What lesson about the real world does it teach? That certain people get advantages in life that most don't? I guess that's a fair one.
The rules are different. Nobody can deny that. Let everyone play by the same rules or group them apart from each other.
Sutter'sBeard wrote:
I don't know the history of states other than Illinois but I think the multiplier is a good idea. Take a look at the state champions of the past in Illinois and I bet at least a third of them are private schools. Mt. Carmel (Chicago) is(or at least used to be) an all boys school. With having your whole student body as possible players, it gives you an unfair advantage over similar sized schools with half girls.
No multiplier in the real world. There is no rational reason for having one in the educational world--where we allegedly prepare kids for the real world.
The whole multiplier is a crutch. Only cripples need crutches.
What lesson about the real world does it teach? That certain people get advantages in life that most don't? I guess that's a fair one.
The rules are different. Nobody can deny that. Let everyone play by the same rules or group them apart from each other.
Or better yet make it like the Bowl system where every team gets to play in one and they all get trophies.
Maybe they should all have a Turkey Day game like Kirkwood and WG. No joke that it's basically a bowl game and a pretty nice consolation game for non state title years.
BW23 wrote:
What lesson about the real world does it teach? That certain people get advantages in life that most don't? I guess that's a fair one.
The rules are different. Nobody can deny that. Let everyone play by the same rules or group them apart from each other.
Life isn't fair. Deal with it. A HS German teacher I had was rather fond of the phrase. Of course he'd probably get fired for daring to vocalize something so truthful now.
I will say non coed school should have multiplier.
But coed Private schools in jeff city breese or quincy aren't in metro areas and effectively have the same geograpahical constraints bringing in player
as the public schools there. So why should they be multiplied. ?
My elder girl went to private coed school before going to public. The private school had about 3 times as many girls as guys because of CBC being popular.. Then to hit that school with a multiplier -talk about unfair. Nevertheless-fans of the public school that knocked them out of boys bb playoffs had signs and chants about the "public schools over private"... I kid you not.
As for
Separate championships for private and public- haven't they watered down championships enough with all the classes? Back in the day-just getting to state was huge in BB. In FB, just making the playoffs was an accomplishment in IL
Sutter'sBeard wrote:
I don't know the history of states other than Illinois but I think the multiplier is a good idea. Take a look at the state champions of the past in Illinois and I bet at least a third of them are private schools. Mt. Carmel (Chicago) is(or at least used to be) an all boys school. With having your whole student body as possible players, it gives you an unfair advantage over similar sized schools with half girls.
No multiplier in the real world. There is no rational reason for having one in the educational world--where we allegedly prepare kids for the real world.
The whole multiplier is a crutch. Only cripples need crutches.
You seem dead set on the issue, but I too, like the multiplier.
Sutter'sBeard wrote:
I don't know the history of states other than Illinois but I think the multiplier is a good idea. Take a look at the state champions of the past in Illinois and I bet at least a third of them are private schools. Mt. Carmel (Chicago) is(or at least used to be) an all boys school. With having your whole student body as possible players, it gives you an unfair advantage over similar sized schools with half girls.
No multiplier in the real world. There is no rational reason for having one in the educational world--where we allegedly prepare kids for the real world.
The whole multiplier is a crutch. Only cripples need crutches.
There is no rational reason for having football, or any other sport, in the educational world either --- but we do.