Re: Shohei Ohtani Appreciation Thread
Posted: June 28 23, 10:05 am
A Message Board Dedicated to Discussing St. Louis Cardinals Baseball!
https://gatewayredbirds.org/forum/
I’m there.Joe Shlabotnik wrote: ↑June 28 23, 11:01 amAt some point, don't we have to consider Ohtani above Bonds and Ruth? Are we there yet?
Agree with this 100%. It's almost impossible to compare today's game to Ruth's era; and it's tough to imagine Bonds pitching like anything resembling Ohtani. It's also significant, to me, that Ruth was only a dominant starting pitcher in one season when you adjust for scoring in that era. He only had two other seasons with an ERA+ over 120. Ohtani is now working on this third straight season as a dominant, #1 starter (ERA+ over 140 in each). Ruth is the only real comp to me, given how lightyears ahead of his (admittedly limited) competition Ruth was, and how similarly incomparable Ohtani is to any other player.WAR God wrote: ↑June 28 23, 3:08 pmI’m there.Joe Shlabotnik wrote: ↑June 28 23, 11:01 amAt some point, don't we have to consider Ohtani above Bonds and Ruth? Are we there yet?
I don’t want to hold it against either of those players that they played in a previous era. But the game has never been harder. Peak velocity, peak training, peak game planning, peak analytics. Even from Bonds to now, it’s a totally different thing. the game is getting more specialized, and this guy is dominating at the plate and on the mound.
I know some people think this is going to lead to more two-way players, and it might, but I don’t foresee anyone doing the stuff he’s doing on both ends. Too rare. Not in my lifetime. He’s a cyborg.
Shohei Ohtani's secretive free agency is a missed opportunity for him and MLB
His short journey through free agency could have been a celebration of baseball. Ohtani has more leverage than any player ever. Everybody wants him, and everybody wants to give him a lot of money. This really should all be fun, generating excitement among baseball fans dreaming of Ohtani in the lineup of their favorite team.
Instead, his decision is being handled like delicate negotiations over a secret spy swap. There is silence and threats, with club executives rolling their eyes as they describe the warnings they have been given from Ohtani's camp about publicly discussing their efforts to sign the most dynamic and popular talent on earth. "Sorry, can't talk about the guy everybody is talking about," said one general manager, laughing.
i find that last quoted section condescending too.And Ohtani's reflex always has seemed to be to bear as little media and fan responsibility as possible, as was clear in his years in Anaheim. But the biggest stars in sports -- Michael Jordan, Derek Jeter, Patrick Mahomes et al -- understood that by speaking with the media, they are speaking to the patrons of their sport: the fans -- the paying customers.
Ohtani has not yet embraced that opportunity. And as he nears his decision in the midst of an imposed information blackout, he has missed a chance to serve the game he loves.