cardsfansince82 wrote:
So now that it's clear the Heat aren't all that good you still want to criticize him for what you perceive as his intent? If anything he's done more to prove his greatness than if they cakewalked to multiple championships. It's obvious that he's never going to win over all the fans, but the new angles people come up with to dislike him are kind of ridiculous.
I never said that.
Saigon said James tried to stack a team and you essentially said no he didn't try to stack a team because Wade and Bosh aren't that good which is largely irrelevant.
Jeez. I never even criticized the guy. Just pointed out the inherent flaw in logic.
MrSaigon wrote:I don't see any problem with judging him for his intent. And I don't think there was any lack of clarity to what his intent was.
I was with you initially but a few things happened. Derrick Rose got injured, many people went too far with the hate and lost sight of his once-in-a-lifetime abilities as a player and I just lost the energy to hold his taking the easy way out against him.
When the Bulls were direct competitors to the Heat, I hated them. When they stopped being a threat, I was able to watch him and his team from a more neutral perspective and as a lover of the NBA, I can't not want to watch him play.
MrSaigon wrote:I don't see any problem with judging him for his intent. And I don't think there was any lack of clarity to what his intent was.
His intent was to have a championship caliber team like every other star player. People pretend like it doesn't take 2-3 great players to win a championship and he was supposed to just stay in Cleveland and waste his entire career for their smug satisfaction.
MrSaigon wrote:I don't see any problem with judging him for his intent. And I don't think there was any lack of clarity to what his intent was.
His intent was to have a championship caliber team like every other star player. People pretend like it doesn't take 2-3 great players to win a championship and he was supposed to just stay in Cleveland and waste his entire career for their smug satisfaction.
Most players want to bring a championship to their team. Lebron chose to place himself on a championship-caliber team. There is a difference, in my opinion. Jordan didn't come into the league winning championships. Detroit was his nemesis for several years........... but he was determined to overcome the challenge. Lebron didn't have that same determination.
And all of this nonsense about Lebron taking a "not very good" Miami Heat team and turning them into a championship caliber club is just that........... nonsense. He hand-picked the players that he wanted on his team. So if they're not very good, that's his own damn fault.
Quick, name the best player Lebron played with in Cleveland. A players career shouldn't be held hostage by bad management. He stayed for seven years and, presumably, knew what their plans were for the next few. He went to the best team during free agency, he didn't force a trade or leave after his rookie contract... I never understand the hate for this move. I get the hate for "the decision," but that's bad on ESPN and his agent as well.
Whatevs, I don't care who wins game 7, I like Duncan and Leonard as much as I like Lebron and Bosh, and I dislike ginobli as much as I dislike Wade. Then again... Birdman trumps all.
We are remembering that LeBron is from Akron, right? And that Cleveland is the most championship-starved city in the country, right? That he called his own TV special to piss on his hometown team?
Great talent, but [expletive] him. There is way more to it than choosing another team via free agency. I have less than zero respect for him.
IMO he's done some of the growing he needs to as a competitor, but I don't think it's totally ridiculous to suggest maybe he was trying to create a situation where he didn't have to. His thinking sure appears to be that a sword fight would be a lot easier with a gun. I imagine his thinking wasn't entirely unlike the analysts who at the time were counting the championships just like LeBron, and asking how many games they would beat the Bulls record record by (literally). No one should be as competitive as MJ, but I go back to his quote at the time of The Decision, along the lines of 'I never would have called Barkley and Magic to team up.'
[expletive] the 1980 USSR Hockey Team. That's what this is supposed to be.
Socnorb11 wrote:
Most players want to bring a championship to their team. Lebron chose to place himself on a championship-caliber team. There is a difference, in my opinion. Jordan didn't come into the league winning championships. Detroit was his nemesis for several years........... but he was determined to overcome the challenge. Lebron didn't have that same determination.
And all of this nonsense about Lebron taking a "not very good" Miami Heat team and turning them into a championship caliber club is just that........... nonsense. He hand-picked the players that he wanted on his team. So if they're not very good, that's his own damn fault.
Jordan never had that option, but let's not bring facts into this. Believe it or not the FA rules have dramatically changed since he was coming up. He was never an unrestricted free agent. Even if he wanted to leave the Bulls could have prevented him from doing so. The only way to leave back then was via trade or another team offering more than your team was willing to match. He also already had Pippen and Grant on his own team for multiple years so I'm not sure where else he was going to go to "overcome the challenge" that was better than what he had.
I can also guarantee that there are about 50 players Lebron would have picked over Bosh if he truly had that option.