UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
User avatar
Maclowery
Child Pot Activist
Posts: 7742
Joined: June 15 06, 7:27 am
Location: NYC

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by Maclowery »

themiddle54 wrote:
slide_into_first wrote:If there is a misconception about the Babes Thread, I would like to clear it up. It is not intended to be misogynistic. The younger men post pictures of lingerie models and actresses who represent their concept of perfect beauty, while the older men counter with women who are not perfect but nevertheless beautiful. It is part of a mentoring process which the older ones take seriously. I'm not kidding. No one believes a woman can be judged solely by her appearance.
Not to be one of those message board jerks who insist on objective evidence outweighing gray area and stuff, but that whole thread is "Look at the X on Y"
I'll tell you what threads really grind my gears here. First off, there's a 2400 post long thread just talking about money. Oh sure, it's all 'complex' and 'well-researched' and 'polite', but where are the jugs? Second, all these threads with random funny pictures and movies. Who needs it? A social forum on a baseball site should be about one thing only: More baseball statistical discussion. Maybe some jugs, also. I won't even begin to complain about the beer thread, movie thread, music thread, TV thread, and hiking thread, all of which have very-irritatingly helped me find new things I like. For shame. I think about two things: Jugs and baseball. Next thing you know, you're going to see expert-written threads explaining nuclear reactors and particle accelerators. Ridiculous.

Online
User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30873
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by ghostrunner »

About the "just busting chops, breaking balls" thing, that's something you do with friends that you get along with. It's pretty clear when someone like Fat Bulldog is doing that, or like with people giving PJ grief over his age. It's another to save your sarcasm and dismissive comments for people you disagree with and clearly don't like. If you go to the bar with a friend, and you give each other [expletive], that's readily obvious and it's funny. If your friend starts giving other people [expletive] because he thinks they're idiots, your friend is being a jerk and the bartender is going to ask him to cool it.

Not saying this to pick on someone who is now gone, but to address the idea that this is just normal, acceptable behavior.

User avatar
Cronos
In perpetuum
Posts: 34778
Joined: June 30 06, 7:49 am
Location: St. Louis

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by Cronos »

ghostrunner wrote:About the "just busting chops, breaking balls" thing, that's something you do with friends that you get along with. It's pretty clear when someone like Fat Bulldog is doing that, or like with people giving PJ grief over his age. It's another to save your sarcasm and dismissive comments for people you disagree with and clearly don't like. If you go to the bar with a friend, and you give each other [expletive], that's readily obvious and it's funny. If your friend starts giving other people [expletive] because he thinks they're idiots, your friend is being a jerk and the bartender is going to ask him to cool it.
+++

For the "busting chops" or "busting balls" analogy to work, there has to be a significant amount of rapport and mutual trust and camaraderie already in place. Otherwise, it can come off as insulting or bullying.

Think about it: would you walk into a room of strangers, slap a guy on the shoulder and say "Hey ya you little [expletive], how the [expletive] are ya?" Of course not, because he's going to pummel you senseless if you do. If you don't have any sense of connection or camaraderie with someone online, who is just such a stranger, it may not be the wisest move to pull snark when you don't have such a relationship established.

Faceman
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 4800
Joined: May 23 06, 11:56 am
Location: Memphis, TN

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by Faceman »

There is a huge difference in baseball talk and social.

I'd bet anything this is 100% (or close) baseball talk related.

User avatar
PujolJunkie
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 10370
Joined: March 22 07, 4:54 pm
Location: north county, stl
Contact:

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by PujolJunkie »

For the record, I think just as little of all of you as I did when I first started here. My attitude will never change.

User avatar
Richie Allen
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 7458
Joined: December 22 06, 1:06 am

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by Richie Allen »

Spider John wrote:If the folks responsible for the board ask you time and time again to straighten up your act and you just ignore them,then you ought to get banned. It's disrespectful.
Exactly. We're at Michael's house and if you insist on ignoring his rules, you'll be asked to leave. It's not like there is a shortage of places on the Internet that can be used as an outlet for your obnoxious behavior. Michael, with the help of the Mods, has decided this is not going to be one of them. And that's one of the main reasons a lot of people have hung around here over the past 6 years. Let's not argue that this forum is weird because it's not like every other forum out there. Let's be proud and thankful that it's not.

User avatar
Richie Allen
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 7458
Joined: December 22 06, 1:06 am

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by Richie Allen »

Cronos wrote:
ghostrunner wrote:About the "just busting chops, breaking balls" thing, that's something you do with friends that you get along with. It's pretty clear when someone like Fat Bulldog is doing that, or like with people giving PJ grief over his age. It's another to save your sarcasm and dismissive comments for people you disagree with and clearly don't like. If you go to the bar with a friend, and you give each other [expletive], that's readily obvious and it's funny. If your friend starts giving other people [expletive] because he thinks they're idiots, your friend is being a jerk and the bartender is going to ask him to cool it.
+++

For the "busting chops" or "busting balls" analogy to work, there has to be a significant amount of rapport and mutual trust and camaraderie already in place. Otherwise, it can come off as insulting or bullying.

Think about it: would you walk into a room of strangers, slap a guy on the shoulder and say "Hey ya you little [expletive], how the [expletive] are ya?" Of course not, because he's going to pummel you senseless if you do. If you don't have any sense of connection or camaraderie with someone online, who is just such a stranger, it may not be the wisest move to pull snark when you don't have such a relationship established.
I agree with both of you. And if ICE (and Snayke was the same way) had been a jerk to everyone equally, I think I could have actually put up with him better than the way he went about it. I almost never saw him say anything condescending to Steve, Pebbles and the other hyper-sabr guys. But if you weren't preaching from the same book as he was, almost everything he said was either sarcastic, condescending or both. So in the same thread he'll temper his disagreement with one person ("with all due respect, Steve") and then turn right around with the most disrespectful remarks he can think of to Socnorb or whoever. It really fosters a hateful atmosphere and after awhile it's almost inevitable that people start aligning themselves with certain groups or sides and renders the forum useless for anything other than senseless political-type idiotic bickering.

User avatar
cardsfansince82
is shooing asian children away from his fridge.
Posts: 27776
Joined: May 17 06, 10:23 pm
Location: at the gettin' place

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by cardsfansince82 »

I don't really have much else to compare GRB to. This is the only forum I've ever done enough posting or even lurking to have a good feel for. I have always viewed Baseball Talk as a very small part of why I spend time here. I joined here (and will continue to stay here until the mods send me to a nice family in the country) because there are a bunch of funny and intelligent people who just so happen to be baseball fans. Any posting I ever do in BT is lame jokes on the fly in game threads or when I feel the urge to vent about Tony. Maybe I'm in the minority, but I don't get much enjoyment out of every post referencing WAR so I choose to skim over it.

Everyone has that same choice when it comes to any other poster or aspect of the forum. There's always going to be posters or topics that rub you the wrong way. If I can't ignore it then I prefer to respond to it directly. I know the advice is to pm a mod or pm the person but I think it is better to get it out in the open and let the mods decide. If whatever it is that bothers you continues then the rational thing to do is spend less time here.

A few people have gone that route but I think the majority of the board evolution has to do with what mikechamp said. People are getting older and life circumstances change. For a couple of years now we have been down to a small handful of people who keep the conversation flowing after 5 PM. I'm not going to pretend that ICE wasn't obtuse at times, but it was also easy to stick out like a sore thumb at night. The forum needs people to drive conversation and that's the biggest reason why I think he'll be missed. I don't think other people are suddenly going to start posting more because he's gone.

I brought up ball breaking because I thought that's what we do here. Regardless of what the member count says, we've only had about 200 or so people contribute anything of substance in over 5 years. Why would you hang around that long if you didn't enjoy it or feel welcome? Everyone gets ribbed about something and what constitutes a personal attack is highly subjective. If something bothers you then let everyone know. A boatload of people including the mods gave Joe a hard time about smoking weed and he never responded until the day he left. How many times did ICE get called.a ginger? I bet he didn't request any of those custom ranks. He took that in stride just like most everyone else. If it stops being fun then don't waste your time, but don't expect everyone else to share your stance either.

I just realized I have no [expletive] clue what my point is. I'm drunk and rambling. All I know is I think this sucks and any problem with the board could be solved with more openness and less taking things seriously/personally.

User avatar
Tambourine Man
accepts no jimitators
Posts: 11413
Joined: April 21 06, 3:31 pm
Location: I Read the News Today Oh, boy

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by Tambourine Man »

cardsfan4lifesince1357 wrote:I'm drunk and rambling.
Wakeup or put down your pizza and read this. People make well-informed decisions when they're drunk.

The time has come to complete your transformation, cardsfan4lifesince1357. Guamanian Gary is where it's at.

Hopeful Randy is hopeful.
Image

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31097
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by Popeye_Card »

planet pujolsian wrote:
jim wrote:
Popeye_Card wrote:I will keep my thoughts on this matter simple.

On one hand, this feels pretty heavy-handed.

On the other hand, I know of many quality posters who have left this board or stopped doing much posting in BT because of the atmosphere in there, and to say that ICE was not a huge factor in that would be kidding themselves.

Let's also not get carried away with how many baseball facts he brought to the table. While a lot of us here like advanced metrics, they are by no means facts as to a player's value and potential. They are approximations, stated in numbers with far more decimal points than they deserve. CardsNumbers said it well--too often he dealt with black and white, and if you didn't like his side, well then you're stupid and wrong. So much of baseball is gray, and that is where the good discussion lies, IMO.
Great points popeye.
Unfortunately, he's one of the guys we sorely miss IMO.
While I do think that BT has gone a bit downhill, that isn't the main driver behind my posting slowdown. It has been work, life, all the stuff that mikechamp mentions. Wish that I had more time. ICE's banning doesn't really affect anything for me. .

Post Reply