The U is in serious trouble, or Phins vs. The World

A forum for non-baseball sports
Post Reply
phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: The U is in serious trouble

Post by phins »

clevername wrote:not according to USC fans. That's the way these things always go.
I'm not in a position to make any judgments on that case since I haven't studied it much. I thought they had receipts, cars, a house his family lived in and obviously couldn't afford allegedly. That's pretty damning evidence if they had that.

There are two key differences in the cases for me:

At Miami, it was a longer period of time allegedly. The violations were much less severe, and he doesn't claim to have paid football players anything more than $1,000, and has virtually no proof of it at all (payments wise). He does have proof of smaller violations. Players congregating at his house and on his boat is a violation. Players receiving free meals out, is a minor violation (he could have made home cooked meals for a small number of players and not be a violation). How much does the admin take the blame for him getting as much access? A lot, because they should have known he was shady? Or not as much because he was able to fool investors as well? I think there is going to be some culpability assessed due to the fact the head football coach hated the guy, and wanted him to have no part of the program. Yet, the admin. and other higher ups are seen photographed with him anyway.

You have to decide what you feel is worse if proof is there against Miami (proof that is there in some allegations, and not so much in others): A long period of time where players are partying, and getting minor, yet illegal, benefits. Or, the major violations for a short time period with major benefits.

Hard to say. I imagine the punishments will end up similar based on the statement from Shalala today. It wasn't good, that's for sure. Sounded like a President bracing her alumni, and fanbase for suspensions.

User avatar
cardsfansince82
is shooing asian children away from his fridge.
Posts: 27776
Joined: May 17 06, 10:23 pm
Location: at the gettin' place

Re: The U is in serious trouble

Post by cardsfansince82 »

phins wrote: He does have proof of smaller violations. Players congregating at his house and on his boat is a violation. Players receiving free meals out, is a minor violation (he could have made home cooked meals for a small number of players and not be a violation).
This is all I ever wanted you to admit. Your earlier posts you seemed in complete denial like there was actually a chance Miami could come out of this clean, or unaware that the parts of his story you were conceding were violations to begin with.
phins wrote:How much does the admin take the blame for him getting as much access? A lot, because they should have known he was shady? Or not as much because he was able to fool investors as well? I think there is going to be some culpability assessed due to the fact the head football coach hated the guy, and wanted him to have no part of the program. Yet, the admin. and other higher ups are seen photographed with him anyway.
I've read that Shannon specifically mentioned him by name in players meetings as someone to stay away from, and refused to shake his hand or talk to him at booster functions. I'm sure the administration knew of him, but almost certainly didn't know just how much extra contact he had with the players. I doubt stories about screwing hookers on a yacht were discussed much beyond the players themselves. Anything the coaches knew probably didn't get passed on. What little the administration knew was overlooked because he gave a lot of money.
phins wrote:You have to decide what you feel is worse if proof is there against Miami (proof that is there in some allegations, and not so much in others): A long period of time where players are partying, and getting minor, yet illegal, benefits. Or, the major violations for a short time period with major benefits.
I guess that sort of depends on how much of his story the NCAA believes. If what he says is true, those so called minor benefits add up to a whole lot over the years. Some of the things he is alleging are a lot more than just a thousand here or there. Just the bar tabs at those top clubs are going to be big, plus the clothes and jewelry he allegedly paid for, plus the yacht expenses, etc and these violations supposedly happened on hundreds of occasions. I personally believe most of what he said is true, because I've always felt this stuff goes on to some extent at every major program. His story doesn't seem implausible in a city like Miami, where there's a lot of money and a lot of extra temptations that a kid in Lincoln, NE simply doesn't have available no matter how tight he is with the boosters. I don't draw much distinction between the long/minor and short/major violations. I think if you happen to get caught you should be punished pretty harshly so athletic programs are forced to police themselves better.

As for the NCAA's stance, I have no clue. USC got hammered pretty hard, but Auburn got to hang a national championship banner. North Carolina had their whole team blown up at the beginning of last year over what was initially just a couple minor violations, but Ohio State more or less determined their own punishment. Who knows?

I initially figured Jacory Harris would definitely get suspended (not necessarily a bad thing for you) and probably Ray Ray and a few others, plus no bowl game for a year or two. But everything I've read from mainstream media seems to indicate the NCAA is buying most of his story, so maybe the punishment could be even worse. Shalala can talk all she wants about isolating the problem and making preemptive punishments, but the NCAA has the final say. The guy has been gone for a year plus and still has ties to 20% of the roster including most of the top players. For her to say that it should not reflect badly on everyone else involved is a bit of a stretch.

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: The U is in serious trouble

Post by phins »

If you think I'm in denial over anything, you haven't been reading. I've been saying wait for everything to come out, including facts.

There has been absolutely zero proof to show he was paying for most of the things he alleges. Having a receipt for something doesn't show you bought it for a Miami player etc.

On the flip side, it seems like he has proof of a bunch of smaller violations.

As for the NCAA, they haven't said word one about what they believe and don't believe, so anything you're reading regarding that is purely speculation. Lest we forget, media outlets write stories for hits and clicks, writing a story that says, "Wait for something to come out, I don't have an opinion of hearsay," is not going to clicks like "Miami should get the death penalty," will.

User avatar
robbotis
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 4791
Joined: April 18 06, 7:05 am
Location: Minneapolis

Re: The U is in serious trouble

Post by robbotis »

phins wrote:If you think I'm in denial over anything, you haven't been reading. I've been saying wait for everything to come out, including facts.

There has been absolutely zero proof to show he was paying for most of the things he alleges. Having a receipt for something doesn't show you bought it for a Miami player etc.

On the flip side, it seems like he has proof of a bunch of smaller violations.

As for the NCAA, they haven't said word one about what they believe and don't believe, so anything you're reading regarding that is purely speculation. Lest we forget, media outlets write stories for hits and clicks, writing a story that says, "Wait for something to come out, I don't have an opinion of hearsay," is not going to clicks like "Miami should get the death penalty," will.
What proof are you looking for?
There's photos of players on his yacht, in private rooms at clubs, corraborating reports from several players.
I'm not sure what more proof there is.

User avatar
Transmogrified Tiger
Puppy Murderer
Posts: 9323
Joined: April 25 06, 6:07 pm
Location: Across the River

Re: The U is in serious trouble

Post by Transmogrified Tiger »

robbotis wrote:What proof are you looking for?
There's photos of players on his yacht, in private rooms at clubs, corraborating reports from several players.
I'm not sure what more proof there is.
For real. Maybe I got back-paged before, but this is all stuff that corroborates Shapiro and directly implicates the coaching staff.
• Yahoo! Sports has acquired a photo of Allen in Shapiro’s luxury box during the 2009 season, with then-recruit Jeffrey Godfrey standing in the background.

• Yahoo! Sports has acquired a balance sheet from Shapiro’s bankruptcy, showing $92,300 in recorded transactions from Shapiro to Allen between April 2008 and January 2009. Yahoo! Sports also acquired $55,800 in canceled checks signed by Allen for some of the aforementioned transactions.

• A LinkedIn business profile belonging to Allen shows he worked for three sports agencies that survived in various forms – Axcess Sports (with Shapiro), Luke Sports & Entertainment (with recording artist and avid Hurricanes fan Luther Campbell), and The Players Agency (also with Shapiro).

• Yahoo! Sports acquired a canceled $2,500 check to corroborate Shapiro’s claim of giving Hurtt an interest-free loan. The check, which includes a signature on the back, is dated July 31, 2009.

• One source corroborated Shapiro having paid for bills for Hurtt and a large group of athletes at Café Grazie on two occasions. The source said that on each occasion, Shapiro called the restaurant and made the owners aware that Hurtt would be bringing a large group in for a meal, with explicit instructions that the bills be charged to the booster’s American Express black card.

• Two sources present at Patchan’s alleged visit to Shapiro’s home corroborated the presence of the recruit and his family, as well as the presence of two Miami assistants and multiple Miami players.

• One source corroborated Shapiro’s account of Hill and Clint Hurtt being present when the booster had impermissible recruiting contact at his mansion with Andre Debose, Ray-Ray Armstrong and Dyron Dye.

• Three sources present at Patchan’s alleged visit to Shapiro’s home confirmed the presence of the recruit and his family, as well as Pannunzio, Stoutland and multiple Miami players.

AWvsCBsteeeerike3
"I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
Posts: 27578
Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
Location: Thinking of the Children

Re: The U is in serious trouble

Post by AWvsCBsteeeerike3 »

Are those major infractions? I really have no clue what it would take to get the 'death penalty' but some of those things seem to be fairly minor...like taking players out to dinner or out on a boat...not a big deal I wouldn't think. It's not like he was giving them hundreds of thousands of dollars or houses or cars or whatever...

User avatar
BW23
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12896
Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm

Re: The U is in serious trouble

Post by BW23 »

I'm not that concerned about any of this, and now that I have a long commute to and from work, I listen every now and then to Fox Sports Radio and ESPN Radio (the only sports choices here). But I do have a question.

Is it really fair to compare this and USC? Here's why I ask. Wasn't the USC stuff mainly on Reggie Bush? And the Miami stuff on, say, at least 65 more players...if not 99 more players? Granted, the stuff Bush got was pretty big.

But to me, and again, I don't have a dog in this fight nor do I really care, it's easier for a school to miss things happening with one athlete, even if he's one of the biggest the school's had in decades, than it is to miss it with 100 of them.

User avatar
clevername
Bringer of FRBG
Posts: 10380
Joined: April 16 06, 7:13 pm
Location: Alabama

Re: The U is in serious trouble

Post by clevername »

the only real comparison between the Bush case and this one is the fan reaction of each university to the allegations and proof and the likelihood of sanctions.

AWvsCBsteeeerike3
"I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
Posts: 27578
Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
Location: Thinking of the Children

Re: The U is in serious trouble

Post by AWvsCBsteeeerike3 »

Yeah, I don't have a dog in the fight either. (Although I obviously don't see eye to eye with a lot of things the NCAA does)

But, I've heard a lot about the 'death penalty' because of how serious this is. I was just wondering what is so serious about it? From TT's post, it looks like there is a connection b/w Shapiro and Allen (who is allen, a sports agent?) and that connection is shady because Shapiro was involved with paying for some player's meals, gifts whatever. but it doesn't show him doing anything that is 'outlandish' like buying houses, cars, etc.

I am not agreeing with either side, but there appears to be a lot of smoke. And, of course where there is smoke there is fire, but I don't see anything big enough to deserve a death penalty for Miami.

The compensation or whatever you want to call it doesn't even appear to be that large....

User avatar
Transmogrified Tiger
Puppy Murderer
Posts: 9323
Joined: April 25 06, 6:07 pm
Location: Across the River

Re: The U is in serious trouble

Post by Transmogrified Tiger »

Allen was part of the Miami staff.

Post Reply