UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
User avatar
Maclowery
Child Pot Activist
Posts: 7742
Joined: June 15 06, 7:27 am
Location: NYC

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by Maclowery »

Middle, you missed my sarcasm. I apologize. Getting worked up over a silly bikini/lingerie thread is a total waste. They are around on all sorts of message boards, especially male-oriented ones like baseball, video game, and car enthusiast boards. Don't get so worked up about it. If you like, I will start a Hot Dudes thread with the help of some of my gal pals.

Our resident lady posters most likely roll their collective eyes at the eternal Babes thread, but c'mon. Really?

The baseball forum, in my opinion, operates at a wholly different level than the social and rants forum. Michael took a tough step to bring the main forum up to a more respectful level. If you are truly offended by a thread with models doing their job, good grief. Just don't click on it.

User avatar
ThatGuy
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 5114
Joined: October 15 06, 4:40 pm
Location: Knoxville, TN

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by ThatGuy »

themiddle54 wrote:That is my point. Maybe if you can't digest and understand my point you should refrain from replying.
This kind of tactic goes over well on the internet.

greenback44
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 11665
Joined: June 26 06, 8:54 pm
Location: In a Small Town with Jack and Diane

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by greenback44 »

I think it's a discussion worth having, whether babes threads (and drunken threads, for that matter) are appropriate for the forum.

That said, the point of discussion boards is, well, discussion, and I'm not sure smut is fundamentally contradictory to healthy discussion. There's a clear argument that it's not healthy for us posters, but it's harder for me to see the argument that it leads to unhealthy discussion. OTOH when posters label each other "roto cyber geek" or "the Billy Beane of Guam", that is a problem pretty much by definition. I will miss ICE, as he brought a lot to the board, but there's an opportunity cost to that kind of behavior.

User avatar
Richie Allen
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 7458
Joined: December 22 06, 1:06 am

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by Richie Allen »

themiddle54 wrote:
Maclowery wrote: I'll tell you what threads really grind my gears here. First off, there's a 2400 post long thread just talking about money. Oh sure, it's all 'complex' and 'well-researched' and 'polite', but where are the jugs? Second, all these threads with random funny pictures and movies. Who needs it? A social forum on a baseball site should be about one thing only: More baseball statistical discussion. Maybe some jugs, also. I won't even begin to complain about the beer thread, movie thread, music thread, TV thread, and hiking thread, all of which have very-irritatingly helped me find new things I like. For shame. I think about two things: Jugs and baseball. Next thing you know, you're going to see expert-written threads explaining nuclear reactors and particle accelerators. Ridiculous.
So you've equated at thread full of pics of women which is basically "Look at those [expletive]" to one about movies, TV, beer, music, or have said that women are, like those other things, hobbies or entertainments that we men enjoy. That misogynist thread needs to be wiped out more than the differently-pronounced version of 'teats' needs to be edited in the first sentence of this post.

You're having your cake and eating it. ICE didn't follow Michael's stated goal of having a baseball discussion board where people act like gentlemen to one another and the discussion is civil. But you'll defend the babes thread that's neither civil nor gentlemanly. You can't say the word t i t on this board, but you can post pictures of them and ogle them. ICE can't call someone a fool when he fails to understand the difference between objective fact and the hooey that a lot of fans believe in like chemistry and gray area and whatever else, but they can dance on his grave and say that he didn't understand how baseball works. Well, ICE did have the facts, a lot of people didn't vote 'yes' is all. And it is frustrating to say "here, the earth is flat, and here are heaps of studies that support it, and facts proved via scientific method" only for a few people to insist that their belief in nonsense is more important. Those are the posters who will keep intelligent talk out of the BT forums, because people like ICE*, and me, and skmsw, and others won't want to have the same argument with the same people repeatedly, not will we have the fortitude to not get condescending when someone insists that their belief trumps fact.

*Edit to add: well, not ICE. Obv he could never walk away from an argument, and got himself banned.
You really need to drop the "facts" argument. It's silly. And I'm pretty sure no one here has ever been banned for being too intelligent.

Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by Arthur Dent »

I'm surprised the babes thread has been chosen as the outstanding example of misogyny on the board.

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by Freed Roger »

when did festivus start?

Spider John
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 10952
Joined: May 18 06, 10:09 pm
Location: East of the middle of West Tennessee

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by Spider John »

Freed Roger wrote:when did festivus start?
Did it ever really end?

User avatar
JL21
NPR & THT Contributor
Posts: 36109
Joined: April 18 06, 7:44 am
Location: Chocolate City

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by JL21 »

slide_into_first wrote:Just because some people can't watch a baseball game without a slide rule to tell them if it's a good game or not doesn't mean that is the only way to enjoy baseball. \
themiddle54 wrote: your misinterpretation of my post is downright foolish.

...

I have called you foolish and stupid because you misinterpreted what I wrote and are defending the objectification of women which is veering into misogyny if not fully planted there. Yet this post has a better chance of being edited, and I have a better chance of being censored by a mod on the board than you do, because I called your ridiculous comments and that ridiculous thread 'foolish' and 'stupid'.

That is my point. Maybe if you can't digest and understand my point you should refrain from replying.
With due respect to the two of you, both of these posts are precisely the type of thing we're trying to avoid moving forward. As slide went on to say, it's about civility. If you disagree with someone, that doesn't inherently make that person "stupid" or "foolish", nor are they "foolish" if they use a different set of facts to arrive at their conclusions. It's incorrect to suggest that ICE was banned for using "facts". As others have pointed out, it's how rude and dismissive he was- consistently, after multiple warnings- when other posters used different sets of criteria to come to different conclusions. Moreover, he simply wouldn't let things go. It wasn't enough to be rude and dismissive the first time he disagreed. He had to continue harping on it again and again, aimed directly at specific posters.

The idea is to have intelligent baseball discussion. Being rude and dismissive when you disagree with someone lies in direct opposition to that. I also think it's well worth noting that for all the talk of ICE's fact-based arguments, these facts weren't necessarily insightful. As others have pointed out, it's not as if he was supplying proprietary info. Any of the rest of us could find these same facts by visiting Fan Graphs or BP or (pick your poison).

As for the comments about Social, I will say that the Baseball forum is held to a different standard than the other forums. It's the driver that brings people here. Nobody finds out about and visits GRB because of Fat Bulldog's advice column, no matter how amusing it is. Nobody comes to GRB to look at nearly nude women. People come here because of baseball. That doesn't mean that misogyny and the like is permitted. Since the "Babes" thread is one of the sticking points, I'd point out that Michael threatened to shut the whole thing down just a month or two ago. Trust me- the mods have noticed it a great deal lately. It's another issue that we've had, just shy of the horrible tone of the baseball forum.

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by Freed Roger »

Spider John wrote:
Freed Roger wrote:when did festivus start?
Did it ever really end?
what do you mean by that, huh! HUH!. WWHAT DO YOU MEAN BY THAT! (blue font)

User avatar
Lesson
Grandmaster Flashchat
Posts: 6630
Joined: February 4 10, 4:35 pm

Re: UPDATE: Rave: Mods, Rant: Mods

Post by Lesson »

JL, does this mean you'll post more often in BT?

Post Reply