Arguably

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
User avatar
Cronos
In perpetuum
Posts: 34778
Joined: June 30 06, 7:49 am
Location: St. Louis

Re: Arguably

Post by Cronos »

I guess I still don't get it; if someone used the word "inarguably", that would demonstrate that there's no doubt about it, ie you can't argue about it.

Isn't the use of the term "arguably" due to the fact that it basically says on the user's part "while some wouldn't agree, I think this player is ____". It demonstrates the possiblity that they could be wrong or others might disagree, but it's their opinion that the player is close to what they're describing?

User avatar
StatmanCrothers
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 6461
Joined: April 17 06, 6:50 am
Location: Boston burbs
Contact:

Re: Arguably

Post by StatmanCrothers »

even used correctly it's just a weasel word.


CYA

User avatar
New Pagodi
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 4219
Joined: April 18 06, 11:30 pm
Location: St. Louis
Contact:

Re: Arguably

Post by New Pagodi »

StatmanCrothers wrote:even used correctly it's just a weasel word.


CYA
I agree. It could be that some people might be better off by making more precise statements.

Online
User avatar
obucard
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 8181
Joined: April 18 06, 11:04 pm
Location: Central AR

Re: Arguably

Post by obucard »

Cronos69 wrote:I guess I still don't get it; if someone used the word "inarguably", that would demonstrate that there's no doubt about it, ie you can't argue about it.

Isn't the use of the term "arguably" due to the fact that it basically says on the user's part "while some wouldn't agree, I think this player is ____". It demonstrates the possiblity that they could be wrong or others might disagree, but it's their opinion that the player is close to what they're describing?
Exactly. It also allows for the person to not take ownership of the idea, just in case someone finds it completely stupid.

User avatar
Radbird
There's someone in my head but it's not me
Posts: 62390
Joined: April 18 06, 5:08 pm
Location: LF Bleachers @ Busch II

Re: Arguably

Post by Radbird »

Is this the correct usage?

"With his walkoff home run tonight, the Rockies Carlos Gonzalez completed arguably the most exciting cycle ever."

User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: Arguably

Post by vinsanity »

Radbird wrote:Is this the correct usage?

"With his walkoff home run tonight, the Rockies Carlos Gonzalez completed arguably the most exciting cycle ever."
I'd say yes.

But I don't think it's just a cop out. We could argue day and night about what defines a hitter as best and IMO there isn't one clear cut stat that can define the best hitter clearly.

User avatar
cardsfansince82
is shooing asian children away from his fridge.
Posts: 27776
Joined: May 17 06, 10:23 pm
Location: at the gettin' place

Re: Arguably

Post by cardsfansince82 »

vinsanity wrote:
Radbird wrote:Is this the correct usage?

"With his walkoff home run tonight, the Rockies Carlos Gonzalez completed arguably the most exciting cycle ever."
I'd say yes.

But I don't think it's just a cop out. We could argue day and night about what defines a hitter as best and IMO there isn't one clear cut stat that can define the best hitter clearly.
I say no.

"With his walkoff home run tonight, the Rockies Carlos Gonzalez completed one of the most exciting cycles ever."

"Arguably" is bad in just about any situation. Take a stand on something. For as much money as announcers and talking heads get paid, they should be able to provide an informed opinion about something without completely hedging their bets. "Arguably one of" is even worse. It's a complete non-opinion.

User avatar
go birds
-go birds
Posts: 32057
Joined: February 5 10, 9:54 am

Re: Arguably

Post by go birds »

irregardless

Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21911
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: Arguably

Post by Socnorb11 »

cardsfansince82 wrote:
vinsanity wrote:
Radbird wrote:Is this the correct usage?

"With his walkoff home run tonight, the Rockies Carlos Gonzalez completed arguably the most exciting cycle ever."
I'd say yes.

But I don't think it's just a cop out. We could argue day and night about what defines a hitter as best and IMO there isn't one clear cut stat that can define the best hitter clearly.
I say no.

"With his walkoff home run tonight, the Rockies Carlos Gonzalez completed one of the most exciting cycles ever."

"Arguably" is bad in just about any situation. Take a stand on something. For as much money as announcers and talking heads get paid, they should be able to provide an informed opinion about something without completely hedging their bets. "Arguably one of" is even worse. It's a complete non-opinion.
Saying it's "one of the most exciting cycles ever" isn't exactly taking a stand. Is it one of the top 3 most exciting? Is it one of the top 100 most exciting? Is it one of the top 1,000 most exciting?

I actually think that "arguably the most exciting" is more precise. You're saying that you can make a case that it is THE most exciting. Not just among the most exciting.

User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: Arguably

Post by vinsanity »

Socnorb11 wrote:
cardsfansince82 wrote:
vinsanity wrote:
Radbird wrote:Is this the correct usage?

"With his walkoff home run tonight, the Rockies Carlos Gonzalez completed arguably the most exciting cycle ever."
I'd say yes.

But I don't think it's just a cop out. We could argue day and night about what defines a hitter as best and IMO there isn't one clear cut stat that can define the best hitter clearly.
I say no.

"With his walkoff home run tonight, the Rockies Carlos Gonzalez completed one of the most exciting cycles ever."

"Arguably" is bad in just about any situation. Take a stand on something. For as much money as announcers and talking heads get paid, they should be able to provide an informed opinion about something without completely hedging their bets. "Arguably one of" is even worse. It's a complete non-opinion.
Saying it's "one of the most exciting cycles ever" isn't exactly taking a stand. Is it one of the top 3 most exciting? Is it one of the top 100 most exciting? Is it one of the top 1,000 most exciting?

I actually think that "arguably the most exciting" is more precise. You're saying that you can make a case that it is THE most exciting. Not just among the most exciting.
He didn't say 'arguably one of the most exciting cycles ever', he said 'arguably the most exciting cycles this year'.

The first means 'a case could be made that this is in fact one of the most exciting cycles.' - IMO you don't have to state that a case can be made that it is one of the most exciting, you're wiggle room comes from the phrase 'one of'. But the second is 'a case can be made, this is the most exciting cycles this year' - you're claiming it's the best, but leave your self wiggle room by only claiming the case is arguable.

If he had said 'most exciting cycle this year', someone would be in his grill about another cycle or what if you said Dallas Braden's perfect game was the best game pitched this year? Well what about Halladay's? What if he said it was the most exciting pitching performance this year? What about Galarraga's near miss?

Post Reply