Page 3 of 34
Re: GDT NLWC-Cubs (Arrieta) @ Pirates (Cole) 7:08 CDT
Posted: October 7 15, 10:24 am
by Molly
Saw this on FB:
IT'S TRUE: Cubs play at 7:08PM Wednesday which IS 19:08 military time. 1908 is the last World Series Win. It was 107 years ago and the game is on 10/7. Mind. Blown. Sometimes you have to fact check and this one is true.
Re: GDT NLWC-Cubs (Arrieta) @ Pirates (Cole) 7:08 CDT
Posted: October 7 15, 10:26 am
by ndistops
Vidor wrote:Bud's game is stupid on many levels, but one of the ways it is stupid is that it is considered a "round" of its own so you can reset the rosters, so you can have several more hitters in this game as its only one game. They should make it so one has to keep the same roster for the coin flip and the following division series.
I disagree. If you're going to have this game at all, you need to allow the teams in it to do whatever they can to win it.
Re: GDT NLWC-Cubs (Arrieta) @ Pirates (Cole) 7:08 CDT
Posted: October 7 15, 10:27 am
by JoeMcKim
This year is the first time the Cubs have played the Pirates in postseason play, and if the Cubs win it'll be the first time they've played the Cardinals in postseason play.
Re: GDT NLWC-Cubs (Arrieta) @ Pirates (Cole) 7:08 CDT
Posted: October 7 15, 10:34 am
by wart57
Molly wrote:Saw this on FB:
IT'S TRUE: Cubs play at 7:08PM Wednesday which IS 19:08 military time. 1908 is the last World Series Win. It was 107 years ago and the game is on 10/7. Mind. Blown. Sometimes you have to fact check and this one is true.
Re: GDT NLWC-Cubs (Arrieta) @ Pirates (Cole) 7:08 CDT
Posted: October 7 15, 10:42 am
by Radbird
ndistops wrote:Vidor wrote:Bud's game is stupid on many levels, but one of the ways it is stupid is that it is considered a "round" of its own so you can reset the rosters, so you can have several more hitters in this game as its only one game. They should make it so one has to keep the same roster for the coin flip and the following division series.
I disagree. If you're going to have this game at all, you need to allow the teams in it to do whatever they can to win it.
I agree, ndi. It is a round of its own - whether one game or seven. The teams didn't create the WC game - don't penalize them further for making it.
Re: GDT NLWC-Cubs (Arrieta) @ Pirates (Cole) 7:08 CDT
Posted: October 7 15, 10:57 am
by obucard
Personally I think they should expand it to a best-of-3, with either the first 2 or the last 2 a doubleheader.
Re: GDT NLWC-Cubs (Arrieta) @ Pirates (Cole) 7:08 CDT
Posted: October 7 15, 10:57 am
by Vidor
Requiring the WC teams to keep the same roster for the division series would not be penalizing them. It would make sure that we don't have two games every year where teams can field nine-man benches. People like to complain about 40-man rosters in September; this is worse because of the winner-take-all nature of this game.
Re: GDT NLWC-Cubs (Arrieta) @ Pirates (Cole) 7:08 CDT
Posted: October 7 15, 11:01 am
by Jocephus
Re: GDT NLWC-Cubs (Arrieta) @ Pirates (Cole) 7:08 CDT
Posted: October 7 15, 11:14 am
by Transmogrified Tiger
Vidor wrote:Requiring the WC teams to keep the same roster for the division series would not be penalizing them. It would make sure that we don't have two games every year where teams can field nine-man benches. People like to complain about 40-man rosters in September; this is worse because of the winner-take-all nature of this game.
9 man benches in a winner-take-all game are bad because _____
Re: GDT NLWC-Cubs (Arrieta) @ Pirates (Cole) 7:08 CDT
Posted: October 7 15, 11:32 am
by Vidor
Transmogrified Tiger wrote:Vidor wrote:Requiring the WC teams to keep the same roster for the division series would not be penalizing them. It would make sure that we don't have two games every year where teams can field nine-man benches. People like to complain about 40-man rosters in September; this is worse because of the winner-take-all nature of this game.
9 man benches in a winner-take-all game are bad because _____
...because baseball should ideally be played like baseball, and baseball for the rest of the year isn't a game where you can carry a nine-man bench.
